Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Disputes over burden-sharing won’t endanger the alliance, they only strengthen its resilience to internal disagreement

Koivula ‘21 – Assistant professor at the Department of Warfare, the Finnish National Defence University (Tommi, Defense & Security Analysis, 37:2, 145-163, “Carry that weight: assessing continuity and change in NATO’s burden-sharing disputes”, May 12, 2021, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/14751798.2021.1920092?needAccess=true )//RG

The “arrow” of this course of developments suggests that the scope and diversity of NATO burden-sharing disputes is growing and likely to grow further in the near future. In effect, the burden-sharing discourse is in the process of spilling over from its traditional domains. In terms of forecasting, this course of development suggests that this expansion will take at least three forms in the next few years: First, domestic politics within members seem to count more and more in the development of burden-sharing disputes. This dimension is not new, as the age-old guns vs butter predicament has always loomed large among NATO members, and as the US Congress has often been the venue for such arguments. Still, in most NATO countries, questions of security policy have traditionally been left outside of day-to-day domestic political quibbles. However, the advent of the rise of populism, non-liberal political forces in several NATO countries, and the overall increasingly transactional approach to international relations, are likely to shape the domestic willingness in several member countries to engage in multi- lateral security co-operation. Second, whilst the “classical” debate on military expenditure is likely to remain, or even dominate NATO agenda, the transatlantic discourse on burden-sharing is increasingly likely to cover non-military domains such as comprehensive security, resilience, security co-operation, and diplomacy. Instead of closed-door interstate bargaining, the political space of NATO seems to be more and more dominated by a bidding race both on NATO and domestic fora of what is one’s contribution to common good. Third, burden-sharing disputes are likely to extend beyond the level of NATO itself as partner countries are also likely to be dragged into these disputes and into the discourse of burden-sharing. Be it defence co-operation, joint exercises, or participation in peace operations, partners are likely to face an environment emphasising demands of good partner- ship, reputational resources, constructive approach, and other forms of contribution from the involved countries. These developments notwithstanding, the intensity of burden-sharing disputes is not likely to endanger the existence of the Alliance. During its 70 years’ existence, NATO has proved its ability to withstand internal strains. Even though many contributions, such as Richter and Driver have regarded unequal burden-sharing as a threat for NATO60; and this article started by noting the inherent dangers caused by burden-sharing disputes, the overall picture seems to be more multi-dimensional. After all, in many respects the Alliance indeed faces change and progress though argument. Debate may be one of NATO’s defining characteristics. It may also be necessary in order to define and redefine its strategic purpose. In this regard, disputes related to burden-sharing can also be seen as a manifestation of the Alliance’s ability to withstand and accommodate internal disagreement, sometimes for protracted periods of time.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.