NATO empirically solves info sharing/trust with FMN mechanisms to streamline
***Federated Mission Network (FMN)
Hanna et al 17 (Michael Hanna – BA cum laude in International/Global Studies @University of Central Florida, MA in Security Policy Studies @ The George Washington University, Assistant Squad Leader; InstructorAssistant Squad Leader; Instructor United States Marine Corps, Researcher, Center for Technology and National Security PolicyResearcher, Center for Technology and National Security Policy National Defense University, DoS -, David Granzow-military, Bjorn Bolte, and Andrew Alvarado. “David Granzow” )LR
Current global conflict trends are pulling NATO away from its traditional collective defense mission into stability and reconstruction (S&R) operations with greater frequency. S&R environments require NATO to collaborate with and support host nation governments, international organizations, and a range of non-governmental organizations to address security, political, and social challenges. However, NATO encounters difficulty with collecting and sharing intelligence and information in these environments. This inability to communicate compounds the already complex issues faced by all entities involved. This article identifies three policy options to help NATO improve its support to S&R operations by enhancing information-sharing mechanisms within NATO and with non-NATO stakeholders. These options are: 1) the completion of the Federated Mission Network that seeks to aggregate classified and unclassified information in a regulated virtual space; 2) the indoctrination of a Joint Information Fusion Cell to act as a physical clearinghouse for information; and 3) the development of Regional Coordination Centers and Stabilization and Reconstruction Teams to implement individual S&R projects. A packaged, distributable network that can be used simultaneously by NATO and its partners to share classified intelligence, and by IOs, NGOs, and NATO actors to share unclassified information in a common, minimally regulated space. NATO established the Afghan Mission Network (AMN) in 2010. It provided a federated, classified network that allowed all NATO member states contributing forces to the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) mission to exchange data and intelligence. Certain non-NATO states were then read on to the AMN using bilateral security agreements. However, ISAF partners continued to struggle with sharing information with non-NATO actors providing much-needed services in Afghanistan. Efforts to use unclassified interfaces, including the All Partners Access Network (APAN), Civil-Military Fusion Center (CFC), Protected Information Exchange (PIX), and RONNA-HarmonieWeb, did not resolve recurring issues of structural obstacles or lack of buy-in.19 NATO has since endeavored to develop a hybrid network, known as the Federated Mission Network (FMN), to hold both classified and unclassified material on a single network.20 As the FMN is still under development, this paper will outline what functions and considerations should be taken into account for the final product: • A labeling scheme allowing registered users to submit information across the classification spectrum, and an access management scheme to limit information by clearance level • A layered archive and search function to store classified intelligence at the NATO Top Secret, NATO Secret, NATO unclassified, and open source levels, respectively • A user-generated, Wiki-type database for unclassified information, with an open edit function regulated by a NATO administration team21 • Chat functions across the classification spectrum to provide for direct communication between users • A fillable-forms portal allowing NATO and non-NATO entities to submit requests for information (RFIs) in both directions, and • A financial trust fund management function for tracking donations, pairing needs with resources using an open proposal scheme. The resulting network would take the form of a distributable, off-the-shelf product that NATO could deploy to areas of instability and be used by NATO and non-NATO entities simultaneously. Firstly, the FMN brings multiple actors onto a common network and provides different levels of access to vetted users. Through the RFI function, the FMN provides an open line of communication, albeit indirectly, for requesting specific information from NATO and vice-versa. Admittedly, not all requests will be approved, especially when the sources and methods used to obtain the information requested are particularly sensitive. Further, the Wiki function establishes a one-stop clearinghouse for open-source and unclassified information, opening new channels for information exchange. Secondly, the donations management function, modeled after the Afghanistan Reconstruction Trust Fund, will improve the efficiency of resource allocation and will limit cases of fraud.22 This mechanism holds all registered monetary donations in a common account managed by the overarching political lead in a S&R context, be it the host nation government, a UN support mission, or another entity. Because all entities supporting the overall S&R operation will have access to the information contained in this element, the opportunity for graft, embezzlement, and misallocation is greatly reduced. The Request for Proposal (RFP) function allows local and foreign actors to post needs, ranging from reconstruction projects to training seminars, and for NGOs to compete for resource awards designed to fulfill specific, widely identified needs. Finally, by developing a packaged, distributable network, NATO will be able to deploy the FMN alongside the initial contingent of NATO personnel sent to a S&R environment. From the first day of an operation, the FMN can be installed, activated, and have all dysfunctional elements worked out as the full scope of the mission is being developed. The FMN can be set up in multiple locations at once, using dedicated communications systems to manage operations separately. In this way, NATO can support multiple S&R, disaster relief, humanitarian aid, and other operations simultaneously.