Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO can account for different state capacities – North Macedonia proves

Also critical of anti NATO sc authors

Risso 21 (Linda, Senior Researcher at the Centre for Army Leadership, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst. Before joining the Ministry of Defence, Linda worked as a historian at the Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe in Mons, Belgium. “A Forgotten Success”Linda Risso (2021) A Forgotten Success, The RUSI Journal, 166:6-7, 96-105, DOI: 10.1080/03071847.2022.2072764)LR

In August 2001, Operation Essential Harvest contributed significantly to the de-escalation of ethnic tensions in North Macedonia and prevented another conflict in the Western Balkans. Scholars have neglected to mention the operation in their analysis of NATO history.3 Security experts often forget about it even when the focus of their work is the evaluation of NATO’s crisis management capabilities.4 As argued elsewhere, this is mostly due to the traditional crisis-driven approach to NATO history where the attention of scholars keeps focusing on the same ‘turning points’ or ‘moments of crisis’ rather than on the long-term development of the Alliance.5 The first signs of increased ethnic tensions emerged in January 2001 in the town of Tearce, in the northwest of the country.9 In March 2001, fighting broke out along the North Macedonia–Kosovo border near the village of Tanuševci and it grew into a full-blown insurgency carried out by a previously unknown Albanian guerrilla group, the National Liberation Army (NLA) led by Ali Ahmeti. The NLA soon controlled the area around Tetovo, North Macedonia’s second city. Ahmeti had fought in the Kosovo Liberation Army against Slobodan Milošević and was applying the same military strategies and tactics to the fight against North Macedonia’s security forces.10 Two attempts to solve the crisis failed in rapid succession: one by the OSCE’s envoy, US Ambassador Bob Frowick; and one by North Macedonia’s President Boris Trajkovski. Frowick brokered a negotiation agreement that officially included the NLA as one of the interlocutors and which was therefore received as a betrayal and rejected by the political parties in Skopje.13 On 14 June, NATO Secretary General Lord Robertson and EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Javier Solana travelled to Skopje to support efforts for a political solution to the conflict. A couple of weeks later, Solana appointed François Léotard as the EU envoy to Skopje.15 Léotard worked with US Ambassador James W Pardew, who had been sent to North Macedonia by President George W Bush.16 NATO also sent a team led by Pieter Feith, a Dutch diplomat who was the head of the NATO Balkan Task Force. Feith was Lord Robertson’s personal representative and liaised with Mark Laity, who had also been sent by Robertson to work as Trajkovski’s special adviser.17 Lord Robertson used ‘personal representatives’ to avoid the formal involvement of the North Atlantic Council (NAC). At the time, opinion within the NAC was divided and several member countries were wary of further involvement in the Balkans as public opinion was critical of NATO’s involvement in Kosovo. The appointment of envoys as the Secretary General’s personal representatives did not require a vote, which was both faster and diplomatically convenient.18 Feeble as it might have been, the ceasefire opened a space for diplomatic talks. The Ohrid Framework Agreement (OFA) was signed on 13 August 2001 at the presidential holiday retreat near Lake Ohrid.31 According to the Agreement, the cessation of hostilities would be followed by the voluntary disarmament and disbandment of the NLA. It established a pathway for government devolution and the reform of minority political and cultural rights, which would require specific constitutional amendments (Annex A) and legislative modifications (Annex B). The Agreement included changes to how the country’s official languages were to be recognised: any language spoken by more than 20% of the population would become a co-official language along with the Macedonian language at the municipal level. At that point – and to this day – only the Albanian language, with approximately 25% of speakers, qualified as a co-official language. These provisions laid the basis for the inclusion of the Albanian minority in North Macedonia’s political and civil life and mapped a pathway to reform.32 Operation Essential Harvest was officially launched on 22 August 2001. Around 3,800 NATO troops were deployed.45 In their interviews, both White-Spunner, Chip Chapman (CO, 2 PARA) and Andrew Budd (military planner at SHAPE) stressed the role of special forces for liaison and intelligence purposes. 22 SAS, along with selected individuals from other allied countries, were sent to join TFH. Their task was to liaise with the Albanian rebels of Ali Ahmeti and to gather intelligence while at the same time building trust. The special forces reassured the NLA that it was NATO that was collecting the weapons and that it would proceed to destroy them as North Macedonia’s security forces were not involved in the operation.46 Operation Essential Harvest accomplished its mission within schedule and it officially concluded on 26 September 2001. NATO troops collected around 3,785 weapons over 30 days. This included 3,210 assault rifles, 483 machineguns, 161 support weapons such as mortars and anti-tank weapons, 17 air-defence systems, two tanks and two armoured personnel carriers. In addition, 397,625 items of mines, explosives and ammunition were collected.48 In one of the last press conferences, General Lange stressed that despite the lack of certainty about whether the NLA held more, ‘the turning in of 3,300 weapons is not just a gesture, it is a very real and substantial effort to remove the combat effectiveness of the so-call [sic.] NLA fighters’.49

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.