Increased European cybersecurity cooperation overcomes diverging data protection frameworks – status quo challenges are a test of relations NOT their breakdown
Annegret Bendiek 14 - Deputy Head of EU/Europe Research Division at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs. (“Tests of Partnership Transatlantic Cooperation in Cyber Security, Internet Governance, and Data Protection,” German Institute for International and Security Affairs, March 2014, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/253145/1/2014RP05.pdf ) PJW
Edward Snowden’s revelations of the scope of surveillance conducted by U.S. intelligence agencies have been the subject of much debate in Europe, especially in Germany. It came as a surprise to many that Europe’s closest political ally has been intercepting private communications on a large scale, even going so far as to wiretap high-ranking officials of the European Union and its member states. Moreover, the U.S. government has been and continues to use the most important Internet platforms in daily use by Europeans — Google, Yahoo, Amazon, and others —to acquire information about European citizens, through methods that are fundamentally opposed to European legal sensibilities and to the fundamental right of informational self-determination. These practices have damaged the transatlantic partnership between Europe and the United States and may well have resulted in a breach of trust that will prove irreparable. Some observers argue that the two partners’ differences over the right balance between cyber security and data protection are ultimately irreconcilable because they are the product of differing geostrategic positions. Because U.S. engagement is more global in scope, the threats to U.S. security are thought to be more serious than those faced by Europe. For this reason, “Venus Europe” and “Mars America” are unlikely to find common ground on cyber security policy and data protection in the near future. Indeed, the kinds of cooperation in global multistakeholder Internet governance that have been taken for granted in the past may well become increasingly controversial in the future. Although relations are currently being tested, the transatlantic cyber partnership continues to stand on a solid normative and institutional foundation. Both sides agree on the fundamentals of Internet regulation. Both are of the conviction that universal accessibility to the Internet is extraordinarily useful not only for democratic decision-making and free markets but also for the future of the liberal democratic order. And both sides are united also in the search for effective means to limit malicious software, to fight crime, and to secure critical infrastructure. The controversy surrounding the NSA’s espionage activities exposed differences in what the United States and EU member countries consider to be the legitimate means and methods of reaching their common goals. It also revealed that they have different approaches to handling normative dissonance. Nevertheless, it certainly should not be misunderstood as an existential threat to the transatlantic partnership. Instead, transatlantic differences can and should be speedily resolved through political dialogue. Three major problem areas must be dealt with in this process. Global: The present mode of Internet regulation lopsidedly favors the United States and does not sufficiently integrate the emerging powers of Brazil, India, South Africa, China, and Russia. The concept of “multistakeholder governance” may rhetorically evoke egalitarian fairness, but in practice camouflages the fact that U.S. interests and U.S. corporations are de facto the most important agenda setters in Internet governance. Financially weaker actors wield precious little influence in central institutions such as the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) or the Internet Governance Forum (IGF). The United States and Europe have defended in unison the existing governance model for a long time. The recent disclosures about U.S. surveillance practices, however, are causing more Europeans to question the status quo, and a realignment with states like Brazil is taking place. Transatlantic: The EU and the United States diverge sharply in their views on the most important goals for transatlantic cooperation between national governments in the field of cyber security policy, especially regarding the appropriate balance of security and freedom. U.S. cyberspace policy is driven increasingly by the military logic of deterrence, which entails maintaining and strengthening an offensive capacity. Europeans, however, treat the security aspects of cyberspace policy as a police matter, and their main goal is strengthening systemic resilience and resistance to attack and fraud. Accordingly, U.S. and European intelligence agencies differ in their areas of responsibility and authority, and they have acquired quite different attitudes regarding informational selfdetermination and other civil liberties. To prevent these differences from degenerating into massive conflict, both sides must engage each other more openly. Success depends on the United States and Europe recognizing that on both sides, domestic politics limit the range of feasible compromise. As long as the United States seeks to maintain its position as a dominant global power, U.S. cyberspace policy will continue to be driven by national security issues and thus also by the military logic of deterrence. For the EU, however, questions of data protection will continue to be of central significance as long as its approach to cyberspace is police-driven and focused on improving its defensive capacities. Only if these limits are respected will mutual cooperation in cyber security policy and Internet governance find some middle ground that pays off for both sides. Transnational: The transatlantic cyber partnership is being challenged by a number of transnational conflicts involving different perceptions of the proper state-citizen relationship. Unfortunately, these require urgent attention at a time when mutual trust between states and citizens has been eroded. Disclosures have sensitized citizens to the dangers inherent in the digital revolution. It is possible that public trust in the safety of Internet communications has been deeply shaken and that some groups will begin to demand the renationalization of information and communication technology infrastructure. In the run-up to negotiations over the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), for example, demands for the creation of supranational legal instruments and independent mediating bodies are already being voiced. In the coming years, both the EU and the United States will have to get used to emerging countries like Brazil, India, South Africa, and Indonesia demanding the more frequent use of multilateral agreements in Internet governance within the multistakeholder process.