Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff is an impossible move to deploy biotech to fix disability that inevitably entrenches ableism

Ellcessor 16 (Elizabeth Ellcessor is an associate professor of media studies at the University of Virginia, “Cyborg hoaxes: Disability, deception, and critical studies of digital media”, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1461444816642754, 4/19/16, Buck)

Despite the common analysis of online media as opportunities for self-exploration or identity experimentation, cyborg hoaxes present disability as a fixed element of identity that may, in turn, be “fixed” by technology that extends an individual beyond their (limited) capacities. In the first place, cyborg hoaxes reproduce stereotypical representations of disability as a fixed element of identity with predictable restrictions. Second, any promise of technology “fixing” disability implies that disability ought to be fixed and reflects an ableist ideology. Disability is presented as a fixed, static, identity marker in cyborg hoaxes. The very use of disability as an excuse, as described above, is indicative of an assumption that disability produces predictable symptoms. The presentation of disability as a static identity marker, with unchanging consequences, reflects assumptions of a dualist and ableist culture, in which ability is contrasted with disability and gradations are largely invisible. Cyborg hoaxes cling tightly to a narrow narrative of disability and limitation, while (as will be discussed later) people with disabilities online exhibit a range of changeable relationships to society, technology, and sexuality. Insofar as technology offers to “fix” disability, it does so through invisibility, enabling people with disabilities to take on non-disabled representations of self. Yet, as media scholars Katie Ellis and Mike Kent (2010) caution, “if people with disability in this sense become invisible in virtual worlds, this could have implications for the visibility of people with disability in broader society” (p. 123). There are strong tendencies to assume the whiteness and maleness of online participants in the absence of complex representations of alternative identities (Nakamura, 2002). An able-bodied perspective is similarly dominant and reinforced by the invisibility of disability online. Kafer (2013) argues that culture often imagines technologically enabled futures as spaces without disability, meaning that “the value of a future that includes disabled people goes unrecognized, while the value of a disability-free future is seen as self-evident” (p. 3). Technology may also “fix” disability by offering access to a social life that is portrayed as otherwise impossible due to disability. Rheingold (1994), for example, wrote that “Joan’s mentor had given her a computer, modem, and a subscription to CompuServe, where Joan instantly blossomed” (p. 165). This statement privileges technology as a means to overcome stigma or isolation, but it relies upon an ignorance of how technologies can reinforce oppression through features that cannot be used by people with disabilities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.