Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Overcorrect for disability – epistemic exclusion of disables subjects creates an internalization of ableism in both abled and disabled bodies

Katta Spiel et al 20 [Katta Spiel, Os Keyes, Rua M. Williams, Judith Good, Eva Hornecker, Cynthia L. Bennett, April 25-30th, 2020, “I am just terrified of my future” – Epistemic Violence in Disability Related Technology Research, accessed 7/11/22, -ekh-]

As disabled scholars, we find strength in community and share deep bonds with each other. Within these communities, there is fierce loyalty. There is a strength within that seems dangerous to the outside. We are unruly bodies, classified by society into a plethora of interlocking sets of dysfunction and disorder – because our neurology and our physiology cannot be contained into normative expressions by medicine, by discipline, nor even by our own shame. Though, when it comes to academia, we see a lack of representation [7] and a lack of conditions enabling us in taking part in scholarship with self-determination [24].

As disabled scholars researching, our experiences, particularly when researching technologies within the context of our own conditions, share peculiar commonalities. Be it around physical, sensory, cognitive, or psychological conditions, we find ourselves represented in the literature as objects of inquiry – systematically belittled, disregarded, ignored and dehumanized. Despite several calls for the inclusion of disabled people in technology research about them [30, 48, 54], work that claims inclusive methods continues to distance disabled people from the shared construction of knowledge through tokenistic forms of “voice” that fail to redistribute power and agency to disabled people [4]. Instead, disabled people are often persistently excluded from making meaning about technologies presumably for them [50]. Such epistemic exclusion allows the circulation of implicit bias against disabled subjects as producers of knowledge. Privileging, for example, neurotypical perspectives on neurodivergent needs [49], demarcating the space for technologies almost exclusively to domains of cure, therapy and intervention – all of which are tied to rhetorics removing the intricacies of disabled lives from the range of human experiences [11, 52].

As disabled scholars navigating the academy, we find ourselves related to by our non-disabled peers as a problem, needy, difficult, unruly. We face disbelief in light of our diagnoses (“You don’t really look autistic!”, “How did you get through school with ADHD?”, “Dyscalculia isn’t really a thing, you know?”, “I never would have thought!”), dismissal of access needs as too costly, our complaints being framed as aggression and continuous erasure of our situated, lived expertise as “too much” (“You have to be more appreciative about what came before.”, “We are just learning about all of this!”, “You’re so emotional!”, “If this is a persistent issue for you, maybe the issue isn’t other people.”).

As disabled scholars researching our own conditions, we are deeply hurt. We read about ourselves as disordered, as an emotional, financial and overall burden to the people around us, as incapable of forming social relationships, undesirable, less than, limited, incapable, as fundamentally lacking—echoing the worst nightmares of our internalized ableism [10]. The texts are full of the “language of the helping professions” [16]; even though we assume that authors do mean well, those who do not position their work to disability as politicized may be subscribing to a notion of doing good, while not realizing and reflecting that what is allowed to be understood as “doing good” is reliant upon entrenched sociocultural traditions of ableism.

As disabled scholars, we say this, (pain)fully acknowledging that we have, in previous publications and inadvertently, done our fair share to uphold this system ourselves, and acknowledge that we cannot claim to be free from doing so with this piece or any in the future. This issue goes beyond individual blame, it persists as a systemic cultural bias that seeps into academia which is dominated by Western positions [8]. Even as unruly parts of the system, we find ourselves complicit in holding it up, sometimes to survive it, but still often simply because we have not yet disentangled ourselves from hegemonic understandings of “doing good”. Yet, we are hurt. Our (becoming) disabled beings seem to splice our human selves.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.