The alternative is an embracement the a framework of Discrit to rupture the line between ability and disability. Understanding race and disability on both a marco and micro scale is key to disrupt normative conceptions of ability.
Annamma et al 2012 (Annamma, Subini Ancy ; Connor, David ; Ferri, Beth. “Dis/Ability Critical Race Studies (DisCrit): Theorizing at the Intersections of Race and Dis/Ability.” Race, Ethnicity and Education, vol. 16, no. 1, 30 Oct 2012, United Kingdom: Routledge, pp. 1–31, doi:10.1080/13613324.2012.730511.) // RB
Rationale for DisCrit Scholars outside Dis/ability studies might see an article about dis/ability and think, ‘This is a special education issue so I do not have to concern myself.’ However, we believe that issues of perceived dis/ability constitute issues of equity that involve all people. Like Du Bois before them, many critical scholars outside the field of special education have recognized that the social construction of dis/ability depends heavily on race and can result in marginalization, particularly for people of color and those from non-dominant communities (Gutiérrez and Stone 1997; McDermott, Goldman, and Varenne 2006; Oakes 1995; Rubin and Noguera 2004). Given the racial gap in graduation, incidents of discipline, and incarceration rates, along with vast over-representation of students of color in special education and the lackluster achievement rates within many of these special education programs, we must critically examine why so many students labeled with a dis/ability, particularly students of color, are either experiencing failure or being perceived as failing and on what grounds.
We introduce DisCrit as an exploratory conversation wherein we ask, ‘How might DisCrit further expand our knowledge (or understanding) of race and dis/ability?’ We seek to add important dimensions to CRT analysis by considering the ways race and dis/ability are co-constructed. Our goal is not to replace or replicate CRT, but to recognize what it both enables and constrains and then propose the necessity of considering ability within the framework. Indeed, we are indebted to CRT, LatCrit and Fem-Crit (as well as Feminist Legal Studies), along with Dis/abilities Studies theorists, for laying the groundwork and stimulating our thinking in this endeavor (Bell 1987; Berry 2010; Brantlinger, 1997; Crenshaw et al. 1995; Delgado Bernal 2002; Delgado and Stefancic 2001; Erevelles et al. 2006; Ladson-Billings and Tate 1995; MacKinnon 1998/2011; Reid and Valle 2004; Solórzano and Bernal 2001; Solórzano and Yosso 2001). We draw on many of these works, not to co-opt them, but rather to illustrate points of connection between and among dis/ability and the various social locations theorized by these scholars with the intent to further develop theory that will be of service in understanding the lived realities of people. DisCrit is an attempt to recognize a confluence between fields that are profoundly connected but are, for various reasons, often unable or unwilling to engage in joint thinking and efforts to solve issues faced by people of color. The aim of DisCrit is to push DS and CRT to academically and practically bridge commonalities utilizing the tensions between the theories as places for growth instead of resistance and separation. Ultimately we want to extend CRT and DS in ways that are useful and thoughtful to better understand how concepts of race and ability are intertwined. We believe, for instance, that racism and ableism are normalizing processes that are interconnected and collusive. In other words, racism and ableism often work in ways that are unspoken, yet racism validates and reinforces ableism, and ableism validates and reinforces racism. For students of color, race does not exist outside of ability and ability does not exist outside of race; each is being built upon the perception of the other (Crenshaw 1993). However, because racism and ableism are ‘so enmeshed in the fabric of our social order, [they] appear both normal and natural to people in this culture’ (Delgado and Stefancic 2001, 21). Our goals, then, align with Delgado and Stefancic’s (2001) desire to unmask and expose the normalizing processes of racism and ableism as they circulate in society.
A DisCrit theory in education is a framework that theorizes about the ways in which race, racism, dis/ability and ableism are built into the interactions, procedures, discourses, and institutions of education, which affect students of color with dis/abilities qualitatively differently than white students with dis/abilities (Crenshaw 1993; Solórzano and Yosso 2001).3 The qualitatively different experiences of students of color labeled with the same dis/ability in comparison to white peers in education settings is illustrative. For example, students of color tend to be educated in settings segregated from the general population more often than their white peers with the same dis/ability label who were more likely to receive support in the general education classroom and learn alongside their general education peers (Fierros and Conroy 2002). In other words, dis/ability status justifies segregation and unequal treatment for students of color compared to their white counterparts. Additionally, African American students are ‘67% more likely than white students with emotional and behavioral problems to be removed from school on the grounds of dangerousness and 13 times more likely than white students with emotional and behavioral problems to be arrested in school’ (Meiners 2007, 38). Dis/ability status works somewhat differently within higher education. For example, although there has been an increase in students with Learning Dis/abilities (LD) entering college, the majority of students are white and from families whose annual income exceeded $100,000 (Reid and Knight 2006); signaling that being white and possessing economic means allows a student with LD to gain access to higher education. The experiences of students of color with dis/abilities, such as where they are educated, with whom they are educated, and their access to college, tend to be qualitatively different than the experiences of their white peers with the same label (Blackorby and Wagner 1996). The role of the liberal, white middles class in maintaining structures and practices of privilege within education has been documented by Brantlinger in her study of social class and race interlock (2003). Using DisCrit, we seek to address the structural power of ableism and racism by recognizing the historical, social, political and economic interests of limiting access to educational equity to students of color with dis/abilities on both macro and microlevels (Connor 2008a). We recognize that ability and dis/ability are perceived and created based on ideologies of race and located within social and institutional structures as well as personal attitudes. As Collins (1990) notes: First, the notion of interlocking oppressions refers to the macrolevel connections linking systems of oppression such as race, class, and gender. This is the model describing the social structures that create social positions. Second, the notion of intersectionality describes microlevel processes-namely, how each individual and group occupies a social position within interlocking structures of oppression described by the metaphor of intersectionality. Together they shape oppression. (492).
DisCrit seeks to understand ways that macrolevel issues of racism and ableism, among other structural discriminatory processes, are enacted in the day-to-day lives of students of color with dis/abilities. Additionally, we find Crenshaw’s (1993) work on intersectionality useful for theorizing the ways in which race and ability are likewise intertwined in terms of identity. Similar to Crenshaw’s articulation of race and gender, students of color labeled with a dis/ability likewise ‘have no discourse responsive to their specific position in the social landscape; instead they are constantly forced to divide loyalties as social conflict is presented as a choice between grounds of identity’ (Crenshaw et al. 1995, 354). Although Crenshaw does not speak directly to dis/ability, Watts and Erevelles (2004) contend that students of color labeled as disabled, like women of color or gay and lesbian people of color, must also choose where to stand in social conflicts with groups that do not fully share their identities. Moreover, in terms of dis/ability identity, dis/abled students are often positioned such that they are likely (and even encouraged) to reject identifying as disabled as something that is inherently negative or shameful (Connor 2008a) rather than a potentially politicized identity or critical consciousness (Peterson 2009; Shakespeare 1996). The consequences of simply being labeled as disabled, even if one does not claim that identity, can result in rejection from cultural, racial, ethnic and gender groups (Goodwin 2003). Moreover, unlike race and ethnicity, individuals who are disabled, like individuals who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender (LGBT) typically do not share this social status with their immediate family members (Morris 1991; Shakespeare 1996). DisCrit draws on insights from Dis/ability Studies to provide a discourse responsive to the social positioning of students of color with a dis/ability, reframing dis/ability from its subordinate position to a positive marker of identity and something to be ‘claimed’ (Caldwell 2011; Linton 1998b). The ways in which over-representation of students of color in special education currently work, reinforces the racial hierarchies the US subscribes to, namely: (1) the under-representation of Asian Americans, which problematically allows them to be seen as a homogenized ‘model’ minority (Lee 2009); (2) the exclusion of Native Americans in almost all research and continues to emphasize their invisibility in education and larger societal discourse even though they are vastly over-represented in many categories of special education, particularly in states with large numbers of Native American students (Brayboy 2006; Fierros and Conroy 2002); (3) the overrepresentation of Latinos/Latinas in some regions of the country where their population is high and the ways those who speak a second language ntersects with notion of ability. Additionally, emerging bilinguals are more likely to be over-represented in middle and high school and this timing may coincide when they are exited or graduated from segregated ESL or bilingual programs (Artiles et al. 2005); and (4) and the continual over-representation of African Americans across the US, regardless of social class, positions them as the continual problem in American education (Erevelles et al. 2006). Each of these trends in over-representation must be examined in relation to race and ability. In this case, an additional consideration would include gender, given that most of these statistics represent males; at the same time, females of color are also disproportionately represented in disciplinary actions, special education and the juvenile justice system compared to their white female peers (The American Bar Association and National Bar Association 2001; Losen and Skiba 2010; Mendez and Knoff 2003; Oswald, Coutinho, and Best 2002).
As we frame our discussion of DisCrit, we draw on research that relies on the statistical categories of ability and race because these categories result in socially constructed inequities, not because we believe they are necessarily biological realities. This is essential to state explicitly as we do not want to impose identity categories upon any one individual or group of people. Instead, we seek to highlight how the process of structural racism externally imposes identities on individuals by applying socially constructed labels. We also hope to illustrate how specific consequences are associated with labeling. We therefore acknowledge that while ability and racial categories are socially constructed, they continue to have real material outcomes in terms of lived experiences. DisCrit problematizes the ways that binaries between normal/abnormal and abled/disabled play out in a range of contexts. From the physical layout of K-12 schools, where special education is often relegated to separate hallways or even buildings removed from the rest of the students, to universities where departments of Special Education are often detached from Curriculum and Instruction in schools of education (Young 2011). Thus, in symbolic and material ways dis/ability occupies quarantined spaces (Foucault 1977: Graham and Slee 2007). Similar lines are drawn in such diverse contexts as film and media, to publications on dis/ability, to sports and recreation.4 Where particular kinds of texts get published and circulated is another salient example of this line between able/disabled. For example, articles that focus upon the over-representation of students of color are often published in special education journals, whereas articles that are perceived as general education topics are published in journals that are specific to general education. Thus, rarely do these topics of race and dis/ability intersect. When those of us in special education attempt to write for a ‘general education’ journal audience, editors respond that we must give explicit explanations for why our work should be read by those who do not work within the field of special education. This professionally enforced line between special education and general education journals sustains and encourages the compartmentalization of these two artificially separated domains instead of seeing sharing the same field of education. Furthermore, the separation of research reifies the differences between ability and disability, emphasizing divisions among educators and the students we serve. We see this general–special dividing line being drawn in K-12 schools, teacher education programs, teacher certification, education research, and society at large. It is a line that is focused upon what children with dis/abilities cannot do, instead of emphasizing what their strengths are and what unique abilities they possess. It also reifies some students as ‘regular’ or normative and others as so different that their instruction should be left to specialists. DisCrit questions how this line is drawn, how it has changed over time for a variety of types of dis/abilities, who has the control over this line, and what effects the line produces in education and in society? In other words, DisCrit recognizes the shifting boundary between normal and abnormal, between ability and disability, and seeks to question ways in which race contributes to one being positioned on either side of the line. Like whiteness as a social construct or the phenomenon of differential racialization, which both expand and contract racial categories to include and exclude different people in order to limit and extend benefits of being labeled as such, ability and disability changes throughout history in similar ways and are deeply impacted by perceptions of race (Banks 2002; Delgado and Stefancic 2001; Leonardo 2007). In order to understand this phenomenological ‘line,’ it will be necessary to examine ways in which differential minority groups have become racialized in various regions of the country throughout different periods of time – and how beliefs about of dis/ability affect those occurrences. Encountering the social construction of dis/ability, many people pose the question, ‘Are you arguing that there are no physical or mental differences in abilities?’ In response, we would acknowledge that there are, of course, corporeal differences among humans though those differences are rarely, if ever, as fixed and obvious as generally assumed. However, we are most interested in human responses to those differences we currently call dis/abilities.5 We do not see the benefit of drawing what is inevitably an arbitrary (and unstable) line, where certain differences are not perceived as part of normal human variation, but rather become a ‘thing’ so different that we must call them disabled. Moreover, the very notion of difference relies on something else being normative. We are all different from one another. In other words, a person who is perceived as having a dis/ability is no more or less different from someone who is considered nondisabled than that nondisabled person is different from him/her. Yet, the person with the dis/ability is perceived as the one who is inherently different. However, there can be no difference without a norm, upon which difference is measured. We agree, therefore, with Baglieri and Knopf (2004) who state, ‘The question is not whether we perceive differences among people, but, rather, what meaning is brought to bear on those perceived differences’ (525, emphasis added). In the remaining portion of this article we put some of these ideas into specific tenets and then elaborate on each tenet. We do so not to be prescriptive, but rather to try to operationalize what kinds of specific questions and issues can be illuminated from a DisCrit approach.