Centering the question of antiblackness in educational spaces is necessary to disrupt the antiblack logics of the nation state that pathologize black youth as lacking intellectualism
Justin A. Coles 2021 “It’s really geniuses that live in the hood”: Black urban youth curricular un/makings and centering Blackness in slavery’s afterlife, Curriculum Inquiry, DOI: 10.1080/03626784.2020.1856622]//sheima
In regards to antiblackness, learning was rooted in the specific idea that Black people lacked intellectualism (Anderson, 1988; Ladson-Billings, 2006; Ruelas, 2017; Williams, 2009). However, many scholars have documented the ways Black people were more than capable of, and possessed a fierce desire for, learning (Anderson, 1988; Cornelius, 1991; Gundaker, 2007; Payne & Strickland, 2008; Span, 2009; Williams, 2009). The deficit theory of Black anti-intellectualism was used because whites owning enslaved persons understood that Black learning would subvert slavery’s structure. In particular, whites held the belief that “learning will spoil the nigger for work” (Anderson, 1988, p. 6 J. A. COLES 20). While some enslaved Blacks were granted access to literacy to aid in basic tasks to help run the property, such as helping with accounts and supplies, this was not the reality for most (Gundaker, 2007). ¶ Socially constructed and stereotypical imaginings of Black people as “less able to think abstractly,” were used by whites to argue that Blacks were naturally fit for slavery (Plous & Williams, 1995, p. 796). As Ruelas (2017) explained, “slave masters were intent on keeping their slaves illiterate.” Due to the ways antiblackness positioned Black people as less than, the majority of those enslaved were excluded from all educational experience. Indeed, the enslaved “were not allowed books, pen, ink, nor paper, to improve their minds” (Williams, 2009, p. 9). The mind of the slave was deemed a non-factor, which facilitated the ways they were reduced solely to their ability to labor (Spivey, 1978) and to fuel and sustain capitalism (Smith, 2012).¶ After emancipation, many white northern missionaries, full of zeal, went to the US South to educate Blacks (Anderson, 1988; Bush, 2004; Jones, 1992; Williams, 2009). However, this enthusiasm diminished as they “began to realize that they had failed to understand the full effects of generations of slavery” (Newby & Tyack, 1971, p. 195). Bullock (1967, p. 93) revealed that educators “decided to sell the idea of Negro education to white Southerners by sacrificing the principle of racial equality …the best way to assure the sale was to emphasize its value to the purchaser” (as cited in Newby & Tyack, 1971, p. 196). History reveals that the living and learning experiences of Black youth are rooted in the full effects of chattel slavery and sustained through sacrificing racial equality; making curriculum for Black children one of the US’ earliest projects in interest convergence or when “the interest of blacks in achieving racial equality will be accommodated only when it converges with the interests of whites” (Bell, 1980, p. 523).¶ Centering Blackness as Critique of Antiblackness Today, Black youth are still not fully benefitting from educational experiences (Baszile, 2019; Caldera, 2020; Coles & Powell, 2020; Lozenski, 2017; Ohito, 2016), because antiblackness continues to manifest in present-day curriculum (Brown & Brown, 2020). This becomes clear when we understand that “the telos of educational praxis for most schools can only come into being through the logics of the imperialist, (settler) colonialist state” (Snaza, 2019, p. 13). In our nation, where the legacy of slavery and antiBlack racism is the paradigmatic signifier of white settler supremacy (Day, 2015), curriculum can be understood as anti-Black by design. ¶ Regardless of a student’s Black ethnicity, how they dress, or their buy-in to myths of Black exceptionalism, Black youth have “no permanent shield against the injuries of racism,” or “the enduring impact of anti-Blackness in everyday life” (Wallace, 2018, p. 278). Distinctly, the schooling of Black people in the US has served as a site of racial animus and miseducation throughout history and continues to serve as a site of Black suffering (Dumas, 2014). While antiblackness robs Black youth of affirming curricular spaces, schools are also robbed of the dynamic knowledges of Black children, Black genius. Ladson-Billings’ (1995) concept of culturally relevant pedagogy and subsequent asset based concepts like culturally sustaining pedagogy (Paris & Alim, 2014) are in fact fueled by the idea that the lives of Black and other minoritized youth can inform the ways schools become better, more humanizing social institutions.¶ Here, I am reminded of Gaztambide-Fernandez and Murad’s (2011) curriculum imperative of browning curriculum and pedagogy or examining “race, nation, and their intersections with multiple forms of oppression within curriculum studies” (p. 15). Through browning, we can “force the hidden hand of the racism that lurks at every turn of the curriculum studies discourse” (Tuck & Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2013, pp. 83–84), revealing “the ways in which colonial heteropatriarchal White supremacy continues to pervade curriculum studies” (Gaztambide-Fernandez & Murad, 2011, p. 15). Brown and Au (2014) extended curricular browning, charging the field to “give specific and detailed theoretical attention to issues of ‘race’ and curriculum that address the material, historical, and discursive processes of ‘race’ and racism” (p. 381). However, for this to manifest, educators need to critically evaluate what Dyson (2015) labeled as ideologically charged institutional discourse, which categorizes Black students as inherently less than, resulting in ongoing Black curricular exclusion. ¶ If we consider the ways US curriculum sustains antiblackness by resting in ahistorical narratives that marginalize “the myriad ways that Black people lived in and shaped U.S. life” (Brown & Brown, 2020, p. 76), it can be deduced that Black people suffer at the hands of curriculum by having their Blackness devalued. Centering Blackness in curriculum is necessary to facilitate the disruption of learning designed through the anti-Black logics of the nation-state. The need for a centering of Blackness in curriculum that leverages critiques of antiblackness, becomes evident when we understand that “thus far there has been little theorizing in education on the specificity of antiBlack racism” or what Dumas (2016b) contends “is the broader terrain of anti- blackness” (p. 12). While antiblackness will always find a home within curriculum, I contend that through a direct centering of Blackness, curriculum workers can be more attentive in efforts to co-construct curricular spaces that position Black youth life-worlds as essential. ¶