Bifo’s theory justifies the massive violence done by contemporary capitalism
Keefer 11 [Lucas Keefer is currently a graduate student studying philosophy and psychology at Georgia State University. “Review - The Soul at Work” //ASherm]
Of course, some Marxist theorists have already been aware of this need for a critique of contemporary consciousness and have suggested important alternatives. Berardi follows Deleuze and Guattari in adopting a therapeutic approach, though we might also follow Lefebvre (1943/2009) and suggest that a critique of semiocapitalism might also depend on returning to an analysis of the reality of alienation in the everyday lives of those oppressed. If the “soul” oppresses itself under semiocapitalism, it does so only by investing all meaning in the symbolic reality of simulations. Marxist-scientific critique remains, therefore, one way of returning this oppressed symbolic consciousness to the reality of its oppression (see also e.g. Martín-Baró, 1994). Berardi also notes the ways in which semiocapitalism pathologizes (and medicates) reactions against alienation (207). The increased rates of depression and availability of anti-depressants, Berardi suggests, are an indication of humanity’s resistance to a system of symbolic production that exploits subjectivity. As a result, no medicalization of depression can ever hope to successfully treat the root cause of depression, which lies in the alienated existence of postmodernity. The problem here is striking: treatments for depression cost money and only further demand that people labor under semiocapitalism to afford their medications and therapy. It is a race to the bottom in which exploitation and treatment perpetuate each other indefinitely. Berardi suggests a therapeutic shift towards schizoanalysis, following Deleuze (214-219), which suggests that therapeutics must be an ongoing project of restoring autonomy in the face of capitalism’s control over desire. One noteworthy omission from this text is the absence of any consideration of semiocapitalism’s relationship to other capitalisms. While Berardi illustrates the process of alienation in semiocapitalism, these analyses must be tempered by a recognition that cognitive labor is not the norm. While globalization may change this over time, we should recognize that semiocapitalism itself depends upon the more concrete alienation of the physical laborers who provide food (e.g. de Botton, 2009), etc. For semiocapitalism to be parasitic upon the “souls” of human laborers, it must also be parasitic upon the bodies of others to perpetuate the physical existence that underlies the alienation of the soul.