Accumulating ballots is good and key because it forces engagement with our method – simply modelling USFG policy replicates the racist tendencies of the state and forcing us to engage with it is equally harmful
Reid Brinkey 8(THE HARSH REALITIES OF “ACTING BLACK”: HOW AFRICAN-AMERICAN POLICY DEBATERS NEGOTIATE REPRESENTATION THROUGH RACIAL PERFORMANCE AND STYLE, Shanara Rose Reid Brinkley, 2008, Page 114-115)//BRownRice
Signifyin’ on institutional symbols of American democracy, Jones’ draws attention to the parallels in power structures between the federal government and the decision-making arms of the debate community. The “halls of Congress” represent the halls of debate tournaments. “Capitol Hill” where the laws of this country are enacted is a metaphor for debate tournament tabrooms where wins and losses are catalogued. Tournament ballots metaphorically represent the signing of the judges ballot at the conclusion of debates. In facts, debaters often argue that the “impacts” they identify or the solvency for their plan happens “once the judge signs the ballot,” as if assigning a winner or loser actually results in the passage of a policy. Jones argues that it is the ballot that is the most significant tool in influencing the practices and procedures of the community. In other words, the competitive nature of debate guarantees that teams and coaches remain responsive to trends amongst the judging pool. Ultimately, debate competition is a run to capture or win the judges ballot. That the ballot “enacts” the “policies” of the debate “community,” makes the space of competition a critical arena from which to attempt community change. Up until this point, the policy debate community had dealt with issues of diversity and inclusion outside of tournament competition. Directors, coaches, assistants, and debaters may have engaged in outreach and recruitment practices designed to diversify the debate community, but discussions and support for such actions were not generated from debate tournament competition. Those discussions occurred in collaborative versus competitive settings where stakeholders were encouraged to dialogue without concern for winners or losers. For example, OSI (the original non-profit arm of the UDL) sponsored Ideafests to bring stakeholders in the debate community together to discuss the national expansion of the UDL. Thus, Green’s following argument during tournament competition directly violates the traditional practice of discussing issues of diversity and inclusion in the community, outside of competitive debate rounds: Racism is one of the leading exports of the United States Federal Government and it exploits it on to other countries. It doesn’t acknowledge its problems at home and the debate community replicates those values by playing in this fantasy world that we cannot change. By sitting silent, by not acknowledging, or addressing the problems within this community. It is easy for us to say that there are problems racism and sexism but the problem comes when we recognize those systemic issues and do nothing to change our methods of how we challenge those problems.109 Green is holding the debate community accountable for its failure in significantly increasing diversity and inclusion. They hold teams accountable for their methodological choices in debate participation forcing other teams and judges to consider whether or not the traditional or normative ways of engaging in competition result in an activity and environment hostile to those debate bodies marked by difference. Let me remind you of the use of the term “export” in the previous quotation. Green argues that the US federal government “exports” American racism to other nations. Significantly, they argue that the debate community does the same. The Louisville debaters make a very controversial argument, one that if true, deeply wounds the debate community. They argue that the racism in the debate community, just like U.S. institutional racism, is exported to the UDL. Note this excerpt from Jones: And, I gave an example of the Urban Debate Leagues, how people don’t recognize how they export these type of oppressions onto Urban Debate Leagues, when they assume that they are ignorant and have nothing to contribute to this activity. So they teach them how to debate, never realize that they know how to debate in the first place. This is the example, these is the ways in which we have to change the social structures and the power relations that affect our world.”110 As I stated earlier in this chapter, it is largely the development of the UDL and its representations within the debate community that led to the creation of the Louisville Project. Remember that the UDL is often held as the communal exemplar that demonstrates the policy debate community’s commitment to diversity and inclusion. Thus, to argue that the debate community perpetuates institutional racism even while acting against it is a confrontational stance for the Project members.