Challenging the state is key
Lisa Yoneyama 16, 9-8-2016, "Cold War Ruins: Transpacific Critique of American Justice and Japanese War Crimes," Duke University Press, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1215/9780822374114, kav
Importantly, the redress activism reinvigorated in the United States since the turn of the new century has enlisted Asian/Americans as new subjects of historical justice.2 Underpinning reemerging memories of Japanese imperial violence and the impetus to seek redress in the U.S. judicial system is the heightened presence of Asian immigrant-citizen-subjects and their growing importance in American representative politics. The demographic shift in the U.S. body politic is one crucial factor in the belated but increasing Asian/American presence in redress activism. The 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act abolished ethnonational and racial quotas, leading to a dramatic increase in immigration from Asia. Many new immigrants carried with them traumatic memories of suffering and loss wrought by Japanese colonialism as well as Japanese military invasions before and during the Asia-Pacific War. Much of the institutional drive for redress therefore comes from California and other North American locations where new and old Asian populations now pose a significant representational force. The Alliance for Preserving the Truth of Sino-Japanese War, the Global Alliance for Preserving the History of wwII in Asia (ga), and the Association for Learning and Preserving the History of wwII in Asia (alpha)—three overlapping North American network organizations demanding redress and apologies from the Japanese government and corporations not exclusively but largely for Chinese victims of Japan’s aggressive war—are particularly noteworthy. Prompted by the publication of Iris Chang’s Rape of Nanking: Forgotten Holocaust of World War II (1997), these organizations have also successfully mobilized the nineties discourse of international criminal justice and human rights to target Japanese war crimes.3 With regard to “comfort women” redress, Korean/American and Asian/American transnational feminists have deployed American juridical venues, legislatures, communities, social media, and spaces of cultural production to disseminate memories of the Japanese military’s sex trafficking and forced prostitution throughout the empire. In ways that were not possible in the immediate aftermath of the war, Asian/Americans have emerged as new subjects of justice in the U.S. polity. The increasing visibility of Asian/Americans in U.S. redress culture at the same time reminds us of the ways in which the constitution of U.S. public institutions and discourses has been a racialized process. 4 More urgently, attention to the racial differences among subjects who pursue redress calls into question the history of the uneven distribution of power within America’s nationalized liberal public sphere, forcing us to understand that reparation issues concern more than interstate normalization and reconciliation. Transborder redress culture affects colonial diasporic peoples as well as refugees and migrants who were violently uprooted by colonialism and war, and who became further displaced in many cases as a result of the political and economic disfranchisement they experienced in the process of decolonization. In analyzing the Americanization of Japanese war crimes, the redress practices of colonial diasporic and migrant peoples emerge as critical terrains of possibility and scrutiny for transnational practices seeking historical justice. Americanization’s new phase, at least in the above sense, thus registers the nationalization of Asian transnational migrants. Through subjectification to U.S. judicial, legislative, and other state apparatuses of knowledge, Asian immigrant-citizens are not only beckoned to speak as owners of and witnesses to memories of Japanese imperial violence in Asia. They also become speaking subjects by subjecting themselves to the institutional arrangements that enable their speech and visibility, but only to the extent to which they are recognized by the given parameters of historical knowledge and the idea of justice. The exploration of Japan’s historical revisionists in the previous chapter demonstrated that National History performs a vital function as a normative epistemic apparatus that disciplines and interpellates nationalized citizen-subjects through mobilizing them toward the proper recitation of the nation’s honorable and supposedly uniformly shared past. The normative remembering of the nation’s past is intimately linked to the management of knowledge and subjectivities. Given such inseparable relationships among nationalism, normativity of citizenship, history, power, and knowledge, what are the ramifications of memories of Japanese imperial violence that travel from Asia and then become integrated with hegemonic American war memories and the persistent American discourse on historical justice? What type of political subject might we anticipate this process interpellates? The special issue of the Journal of Asian American Studies, published in 2003, on “Korean Comfort Women” addressed precisely this question by focusing on the Asian American investment in Japan’s wartime military “comfort women” issue. Guest-edited by the American literary critic Kandice Chuh, the special issue was based on an Association for American Studies (asa) session, titled “Siting/Citing ‘Comfort Women’ Critically: Transnational Memories in Korea-Japan-U.S. Liaisons.”5 In her essay theorizing the Asian American investment in Japan’s wartime military “comfort women” issue, Chuh raised a fundamental question regarding Asian Americanists’ objectification of “comfort women.”6 Chuh examined the literary representation of comfort women by the works of two Korean American authors, Comfort Woman (1998), by Nora Okja Keller, and A Gesture Life (2000), by ChangRae Lee, calling into question the “highly troubling ideological and political ends” the Asian American knowledge of “comfort women” might accommodate (8). Laura H. Y. Kang’s essay in the special issue likewise problematized the Americanization of Korean “comfort women” and its effect on knowledge and power.7 Asking “who are and should be the ‘we’ who must remember and represent this subject,” Kang argued for the urgent need to attend to the “multiple mediations and disciplinizations” (28) that are integral to the economy of Americanized “comfort women” knowledge, or the process she saw as “the various conjurings of ‘comfort women’” (46). As an alternative to such an Americanization of “comfort women” discourse, Kang calls our attention to the issue of class, suggesting the need to consider “what U.S. citizenship might mean not only for differently racialized and gendered but also differently capitalized subjects” (47). The investigations into the new phase of the Americanization of memories of Japanese imperial violence and the historical justice they call for can most productively yield critical politico-intellectual outcomes when situated in the perspectives put forward by the above Asian/American interventions. In keeping with Chuh’s and Kang’s theorizations, in what follows I explore the not-so-uniform effects of Asian/American mobilization into redress efforts within the U.S. public sphere. I will focus on juridicohistorical discourse—a nexus of power and historical knowledge produced by juridical practices—and intend to closely examine the ways in which Asian/Americans are erected as the law’s agent-subject who enunciates, enacts, or at other times defers, not a single but multiple ideas of historical justice. American discourse on Japanese war crimes is profoundly shaped by U.S. nationalism and assumptions about modernity, liberalism, colonialism, and postcoloniality that are embedded in Cold War epistemologies. Asian/America, as a discursively constituted terrain, is deeply implicated in this knowledge production.8 And yet Asian/Americans as new subjects of justice animated by the power invested in them as American citizen-subjects also necessarily illuminate contradictions of transnationality within the American civic sphere in such a way that they hold out the possibility of a radical politicization of justice and a critique of Americanization.9 Asian/American involvement in redress unveils, often inadvertently, the long history of entanglements and the complicity of imperial violence, as well as the amnesia about these matters between Japan and the United States. In this process, juridico-historical discourse may produce new subjects and publicity that transnationally rally around antiracist, decolonial notions of history and justice. At the same time, however, this process is not automatic or easily decipherable. Asian/Americans, as the agent-subjects of U.S. state apparatuses, tend to secure their nationalized status by underwriting America’s Cold War myth of liberation and rehabilitation vis-à-vis Asia. The North American liberal, multicultural nationalism, moreover, has effectively mobilized Asian ethnonationalisms as an enabling constituent element. Continuing the work of the previous chapters, in the following I seek out an analytic with which we might discern the risks, the possibilities, and the multiple and contested implications of this seemingly new phase in the Americanization of justice.