Marxism is blatantly orientalist – proves the alt fails and serves as an impact turn to the alt
Lindner 21(Kolja Lindner, KOLJA LINDNER is a lecturer (maître de conférences) in German political theory at the Université Paris 8. His research interests lie broadly in political theory and social inequality, postcolonialism, secularism, and Marx. His major publications include Marx, Marxism and the Question of Eurocentrism (forthcoming), Le dernier Marx (edited, 2019), and Die Hegemoniekämpfe in Frankreich: Laizismus, politische Repräsentation und Sarkozysmus (2017).,12-1-2021, "Hegemonic Orientalism and Historical Materialism," No Publication, https://read.dukeupress.edu/critical-times/article/4/3/517/294165)//BRownRice
Said makes two criticisms of Marx. (1) According to Said, Marx advances “the notion of an Asiatic economic system in his 1853 analyses of British rule in India”2 as well as the idea of a “fundamentally lifeless Asia” (O, 154). Both notions are by this account “perfectly fitted . . . to a standard Orientalist undertaking” (O, 154)—that is, to an effort “to manage—and even produce—the Orient politically, sociologically, militarily, ideologically, scientifically, and imaginatively” (O, 3). This view was based on “Romantic and even messianic” (O, 154) sources of the kind that Said locates in Goethe's West-östlicher Diwan. (2) For Said, a contradiction arises as “Marx's moral equation of Asiatic loss with the British colonial rule he condemned gets skewed back towards the old inequality between East and West” (O, 154). Against the backdrop of an essentialist homogenization, Marx severely downplayed the suffering of colonized people: “They are Orientals and hence have to be treated in other ways” (O, 155). He reconciled condemnation and affirmation of “the human depredation introduced into [the Asiatic] system by English colonial interference, rapacity, and outright cruelty” (O, 155) through the notion of the “historical necessity” (O, 153) of a social transformation in Asia.