Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Lethal autonomous weapons are profoundly gendered. They reinforce patriarchal structures by identifying men as potential combatants while running the risk of unchecked sexual violence against women and nonbinary people.

Conway, 20 [Marissa Conway is a CFFP Writer, August 2020, accessed on 6-21-2022, Centre for Feminist Foreign Policy, “Smashing the Patriarchy: The Feminist Case Against Killer Robots” https://static1.squarespace.com/static/57cd7cd9d482e9784e4ccc34/t/5f356f1e5eb59d07e78fb329/1597337376556/Smashing+the+Patriarchy_+The+Feminist+Case+Against+Killer+Robots.pdf]/ISEE

Killer robots reinforce violence patriarchal structures, which have sustained a long and terrible legacy of targeting violence in gendered ways. The usage of killer robots raises a host of concerns as to how they might target innocent men as potential combatants, as well as increase sexualised violence against women, girls, and non-binary people. Many international regulations have been developed to protect people from gender-based violence, and yet, there is no accountability structure for weapons that operate completely autonomously, meaning these killer robots could commit unchecked violence. Combatants or Civilians? Under the administration of President Obama, during which drone strikes became a critical act of US military intervention and targeted killing, the criteria for distinguishing between a civilian and a militant or terrorist was blurred to the point of non-distinction. The CIA counted all military-age males who were in a strike zone as combatants “unless there [was] explicit intelligence posthumously proving them innocent” (Becker and Shane, 2012). The reasoning behind this (il)logic was that if people are spending time around known terrorist hotspots, then they would likely be up to “no good”. This resulted in incredibly low reported rates of civilian Gender-Based Violence and Accountability casualties, as almost all men killed were considered to be combatants. This is but one example of how profiling based on gender, or any social category for that matter, can be twisted in a way that creates a tangible threat for people who simply share the gender of the target profile. Given the lack of clarity as to how combatants are defined, there is a high risk of false positives and targeting of innocent civilians. Developing sound regulations and processes that would guarantee the safety of civilians is an incredibly challenging, and probably impossible, task (Moyes, 2019). Attempts to do so would also place the burden of navigating legal obligations onto AI, a technology which does not have the capacity to make the kind of judgement calls humans are capable of. Killer robots would not be able to identify nuances within a target profile, and without meaningful human intervention, would always result in the use of force, therefore risking the death of innocent people (Moyes, 2019). Sexualised Violence Gender-based violence also manifests in sexualised violence, including the rape, forced pregnancy, slavery, and torture of women, girls, and non-binary people. While proponents for killer robots have argued that such machinery would reduce sexualised violence, the uncomfortable truth is that the opposite is likely (Sandvik and Lohne, 2015). Acts of this nature are often used purposefully in conflict scenarios as a mechanism to instill fear, humiliation, and shame, or for purposes of ethnic cleansing. A killer robot, with no conscience or ability to reject unethical instructions, would execute orders based upon whatever programming it received, including orders to commit sexualised violence (Sharkey, 2020). The assumption that new technology would function precisely as it “should” without consideration of the context in which it’s developed, as well as the motives of the user, is a reckless presumption (Sandvik and Lohne, 2015). United Nations Security Council Resolution 1820 (2008) takes a specific focus on the use of sexualised violence as a weapon of war and war crime, unilaterally condemning it in alignment with the Rome Statute of the International Court and the Geneva Convention (UN General Assembly, 1998; International Committee of the Red Cross, 1949). However, should these weapons commit such atrocities, their distance from human intervention begs the question of legal accountability. Killer robots themselves cannot be tried for crimes. So who, then, should bear that responsibility (Acheson, 2020)? Ultimately, human intent and system performance can never be fully consistent when it comes to killer robots. This misalignment is of grave concern to a FFP framework. As gender equality and protecting vulnerable populations is of central concern to FFP, the potential for gender-based violence should killer robots be developed is simply too great a risk to take. The margin of error of these weapons results in the death of innocent people, a risk that should be considered too great to consider this technology usable.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.