Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Maintaining lethal autonomous weapons causes a tradeoff of priorities. Killer robots won’t create peace, but they do sustain a system where military dominance must come at the cost of human security.

---AT: PICs/DA’s war !---Root cause

Conway, 20 [Marissa Conway is a CFFP Writer, August 2020, accessed on 6-21-2022, Centre for Feminist Foreign Policy, “Smashing the Patriarchy: The Feminist Case Against Killer Robots” https://static1.squarespace.com/static/57cd7cd9d482e9784e4ccc34/t/5f356f1e5eb59d07e78fb329/1597337376556/Smashing+the+Patriarchy_+The+Feminist+Case+Against+Killer+Robots.pdf]/ISEE

FFP addresses the root causes of violence and insecurity by calling for an institutional overhaul of foreign policy and national security. Our world is structured around the patriarchy and naturally, its systems and power hierarchies will be reflected in the weapons we produce. This report will highlight some of the issues revealed when a feminist lens is turned onto killer robots. In Chapter 1, militarisation and masculinity will be explored, including how ideas about masculinity influence a militarised approach to national security. In Chapter 2, gender-based violence and the question of accountability are discussed. The distinction between combatant and civilian are blurred within a patriarchal and racist context, and the ability for killer robots to commit sexualised violence is highlighted. Lastly, in Chapter 3, racism and imperialism is analysed, with a look at how existing societal biases are built into any new technology we would produce. Finally, the report concludes with a summary of the policy recommendations included throughout each of the three chapters. For decades, feminists have campaigned against the violent patriarchal structures that sustain conflict and keep an elite few in power. By building societal hierarchies so that only a small and specific group of people have access to the top - which often in Western countries means straight white men - particular ideas about who is best suited to lead become intrinsically linked to gender and gendered traits. This means the lens through which foreign policy is often conducted has its roots in stereotypical masculine characteristics that have historically been accepted as best for policymaking. These traits include things like being rational, strong, and assertive, while avoiding more feminine-coded traits like emotion or empathy. These ideas about gender feed directly into how national security is understood as a militarised space (Cohn, 2018). Gender (referring to someone’s identity as a man, woman, or gender non-conforming) and gendered traits (referring to concepts about masculinity and femininity) are overlapping but not entirely synonymous. Reference to masculinity here is done so with the understanding that it is a social construct based upon stereotypes to fuel a patriarchal hierarchy of power. The ability to exercise such traits, however, is not exclusive to men, and this report is not interested in reinforcing dated and static ideas of men as masculine and women as feminine. As bell hooks notes, “Black women are very likely to feel strongly that white women have been quite violent, militaristic in their support and maintenance of racism” (hooks, 1995). Anyone is capable of expressing a wide variety of characteristics. Furthermore, including other social categories like race or class into this consideration likewise continues to reveal a complicated system of power dynamics based around identity that play out both between individuals as well as states. The power dynamics found in much of today’s foreign and security policy are framed around realism, an ideology that understands state relationships through the lens of power optimisation. Part of this process means developing new weapons technology in order to continually seek military dominance. Killer robots fit in well with this strategy, and sustain a system that values maintaining power and security through military dominance. The means of keeping peace, then, rests upon the ability to threaten or inflict violence (Conway, 2016; Starr, 2020). Military domination becomes an easily justifiable form of peacekeeping, and masculine-coded traits like aggression and dominance are seen not just as fundamental to security policy, but taken as objective truth within security policy. In this sense, masculinity is systematised by associating ideas about manliness with the willingness to exercise violence (Cohn, 1993). By centring masculine traits as preferential in security policy, “human bodies and their vulnerability, human lives and their subjectivity - all of which are marked as feminine in the binary dichotomies of gender discourse” (Cohn, 1992), get left out. By making it clear that ideas or traits that are coded as feminine are not legitimate, alternative ideas and approaches to security policy are silenced. However, an FFP framework is interested specifically in these silenced ideas, both to explore the fresh perspective they offer and to understand why they were silenced in the first place. A feminist framing of security also takes a step back from the realist and masculine lens through which much of security policy is developed, and instead is interested in what makes the average person secure and safe. Much more immediate needs must be met when security is reframed with the average individual, rather than the state, in mind. Access to safe housing, healthy food, a good education, and affordable healthcare become some of the most prominent indicators of someone’s health and wellness. The ability to lead a life free from discrimination due to gender, race, class, sexuality, or ability are also much better indicators for how sustainability peaceful a society is (Hudson, 2014). A strong military and extravagant weapons arsenal falls low on the lit of priorities in comparison. An FFP would then call for investment not into weapons technology and the military, but instead into the infrastructure of a society and programs to increase equality. As long as militarisation is the lens through which security policy is developed, and gendered traits remain driving factors behind ideas about security, sustainable peace is not possible. By investing in new weapons technology, we are continuing down a path that guarantees violence rather than challenges it. Killer robots will not contribute to peace, but sustain a system where a narrow and patriarchal understanding of security is supported, continuing to leave many vulnerable and at risk of violence.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.