A complete ban is possible and it solves. Only prohibiting LAWS entirely resolves questions of enforcement and circumvention.
Wareham 17 Mary Wareham, 1-5-2017, "The Growing International Movement Against Killer Robots," Human Rights Watch, https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/01/05/growing-international-movement-against-killer-robots//mb24
Affirming the principle of meaningful human control via a preemptive ban This matter of whether autonomous weapons are ethically acceptable lies at the core of the debate over them. The fundamental question is not technological, but philosophical: “Will machines be given the power and authority to kill a human being?” History has shown that for some weapons that significantly threaten non-combatants, including poison gas, biological weapons, chemical weapons, blinding lasers, antipersonnel mines, and cluster munitions, responsible governments have found it necessary to supplement the limits already in the international legal framework. Fully autonomous weapons have the potential to raise a comparable level of humanitarian concern. Based on current and foreseeable technology, the ICRC says there are serious doubts about the ability of autonomous weapon systems to comply with IHL “in all but the narrowest of scenarios and the simplest of environments.” Because of this, the ICRC says “it seems evident that overall human control over the selection of, and use of force against, will continue to be required.” The Campaign to Stop Killer Robots fundamentally objects to autonomous weapons because it rejects the notion that a machine should be permitted to take a human life on the battlefield or in policing, border control, or any circumstances. It seeks to affirm the positive principle that weapons systems, military attacks, and the use of violent force in policing should always be kept under meaningful human control. In order to do that, the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots calls on states and others to endorse its call for a preemptive ban on the development, production, and use of fully autonomous weapons systems. The global coalition of non-governmental organizations does not oppose military use of autonomy and technologies relating to artificial intelligence, but it draws the line at the development of machines that could select and fire on targets without human intervention. Research and development activities should be banned if they are directed at technology that can be used exclusively for fully autonomous weapons or that is explicitly intended for use in such weapons. A preemptive prohibition is both possible and desirable. The Convention on Conventional Weapons Protocol IV banning blinding lasers provides precedent for the creation of a protocol on lethal autonomous weapons systems. The campaign has urged that states ban rather than regulate fully autonomous weapons because a complete prohibition is clearer and easier to enforce than partial regulations or restrictions and eliminates room for different interpretations. A complete prohibition creates greater stigma against the weapons and discourages their proliferation. Mere regulation would still allow governments to obtain them, and be tempted to use them illegally. The serious international security and proliferation concerns relating to fully autonomous weapons include the real danger that if even one nation acquires these weapons, others may feel they have to follow suit in order to defend themselves and to avoid falling behind in a robotic arms race. There is also the prospect that fully autonomous weapons could be acquired by repressive regimes or non-state armed groups with little regard for the law. These weapons could be perfect tools of repression and terror for autocrats. Another proliferation concern is that such weapons would increase the likelihood of armed attacks, making resort to war more likely, as decision-makers would not have the same concerns about loss of soldiers’ lives. This could have a destabilizing effect on international security. Since 2013, a broad range of individuals, organizations, and states have come forward to endorse the call for a preemptive ban on fully autonomous weapons systems, including: • Bolivia, Cuba, Ecuador, Egypt, Ghana, The Holy See, Pakistan, State of Palestine, and Zimbabwe. • The European Parliament, which adopted a resolution by a vote of 534–49 calling for a ban on “development, production and use of fully autonomous weapons which enable strikes to be carried out without human intervention.” • Twenty-one Nobel Peace Laureates, who expressed concern that “leaving the killing to machines might make going to war easier.” • More than 120 religious leaders and organizations of various denominations, who view the weapons as “an affront to human dignity and to the sacredness of life.” • More than 270 scientists in 37 countries, who warned how interactions by devices controlled by complex algorithms “could create unstable and unpredictable behavior … that could initiate or escalate conflicts, or cause unjustifiable harm to civilian populations.” • More than 3,000 artificial intelligence (AI) and robotics experts, who said they have “no interest in building AI weapons and do not want others to tarnish their field by doing so, potentially creating a major public backlash against AI that curtails its future societal benefits.” • Canadian technology company Clearpath Robotics, which said it had “chosen to value our ethics over potential future revenue” by pledging not to manufacture “weaponized robots that remove humans from the loop.” • The ethics council of the $830 billion Norwegian government pension fund, which is looking at whether investments in companies making lethal autonomous weapons systems would violate the fund’s fundamental humanitarian principles. • The UN Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions and the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, who in a report recommended, “Autonomous weapons systems that require no meaningful human control should be prohibited.” Finding the way forward, faster toward an outcome In May 2013, states first deliberated on autonomous weapons in a multilateral forum when a UN special rapporteur presented a report to the Human Rights Council that called for an immediate moratorium on the weapons. At the Convention on Conventional Weapons, also in Geneva, representatives from more than 85 countries met in May 2014 and April 2015 for a total of nine days to discuss lethal autonomous weapons systems, while a third meeting took place in April 2016. Various UN agencies, international organizations, the Red Cross, and civil society groups coordinated by the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots are also participating throughout these deliberations and other meetings, which have helped sharpen the focus on lethal autonomous weapons systems and the concerns raised by them. The process is helping to establish a common base of knowledge from which some nascent norms or principles are finding broad agreement, most notably the notion that human control must be retained over the operation of weapons systems. However, the informal talks are being criticized for “treading water” as they lack ambition, demonstrate no sense of urgency, and reflect the CCW’s usual “go slow and aim low” approach. The Campaign to Stop Killer Robots calls on states to agree to a more formal and substantive process, with up to four weeks of work dedicated in 2017, when they decide on the way forward at the end of the year. The CCW Review Conference in December 2016 should agree to begin formal negotiations and aim to complete them within one or two years by producing a preemptive prohibition on lethal autonomous weapons systems. Pakistan—the first and probably most ardent supporter of the call for a ban—will serve as president of the CCW Review Conference, where states must take crucial decisions on the process going forward and desired outcome. Sustained and substantive national campaigning is required to make any headway reining in autonomous weapons, including legislative scrutiny in the form of debate, questions, and inquiries, and new legislation to ban the weapons. As Canada’s new Minister of Defense Harjit Sajjan commented to the Halifax Security Forum, legislative oversight is required as technology advances so that the burden of deciding on ethical dilemmas associated with their use is not placed on service men and women. The US is the only country with a detailed written policy guiding it on fully autonomous weapons, which it says “neither encourages nor prohibits” development of lethal autonomous weapons systems.” The US has described fully autonomous weapons as a potential “force multiplier.” Recent media interviews with top Pentagon officials provide some disturbing signs that the five-year policy may soon be replaced by guidelines allowing acquisition of human-out-of-the-loop weapons systems. However, officials also express support for retaining human control by stating, for example, that “we will not delegate lethal authority to a machine to make a decision.” Israel has also spoken about the desirability and potential benefits of autonomous weapons systems, urging other countries to “keep an open mind” because it is “difficult” to foresee how developments may look in 10-30 years from now.” No other state has publicly expressed interest in pursuing such systems and several have explicitly stated that they are not developing such systems and that have no plans to do so. But there have been extensive discussions about the potential benefits of such weapons, and many states are concerned that potential enemies will acquire fully autonomous weapons, making their continued development inevitable. The trend toward ever-greater autonomy in warfare has been accelerating greatly in recent years, at an ever-faster pace. A strong, inclusive, and unified effort is needed now to prevent the unconstrained development of fully autonomous weapons systems.