Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Autonomous weapons reaffirm the idea that men are more desirable than women – they represent masculinity in its most ideal form

Daniel M. Sutko 19(Department of Human Communication Studies, California State University, Fullerton, Fullerton, CA, USA), 9-26-2019, "Theorizing femininity in artificial intelligence: a framework for undoing technology’s gender troubles," Taylor & Francis, https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/09502386.2019.1671469

Finally, we could frame a cyborg narrative to theorize about long-term gender effects as a result of the introduction of the Human Universal Load Carriage (or HULC), a type of prosthetic armor in development for use by able-bodied soldiers (Chavez 2011). Thompson describes the exoskeleton as ‘a robotic device the soldier wears like a full body suit. It would enhance Soldier performance, increasing strength without losing agility’ (Hames 2008). Both implants and the exoskeleton thus create a situation where technology is not merely something used by the warrior, but rather part of who he or she is. The cyborg narrative suggests that an exoskeleton could level the playing field through increasing the ability of women warriors to lift heavy loads through augmenting their upper body strength. In an article on the official Army.mil website, a developer notes that ‘this is absolutely focused on the American Warfighter and all of the jobs he or she will have to do’ (emphasis added)7. A woman interviewed in the same article notes as well that ‘this will magnify human strength while on the battlefield’ (Chavez 2011). Harnessing of robotic technology thus holds the promise that women soldiers may more successfully enter combat, since physical requirements are replaced by requirements for mental acuity and reflexes. Indeed, increased use of new technologies of this type might affect the gender makeup of the military in the long term as many different types of people might be drawn to the military as a career, including more women. In addition, many new autonomous technologies are focused on the areas of tracking and communications, again invoking the language of the cyborg, as planners explain how in the future the military unit will be linked together through two-way blue force tracking capabilities which provide GPS coordinates for individual soldiers to be shared among a unit, thus providing info on where the friendly unit is located and who the friendly unit is, as well as info on status and intent (Sweeney 2008). Using these technologies, each member can be aware of the physical position, physical health and intent of all members of the unit. In this way, the unit could in the future behave more like a hive or a swarm (or the Borg of the Star Trek canon). Leadership would thus rest not on a traditional, hierarchical unit but rather on a network in which members interact not only with the leadership but also laterally with each other. Such a development could go far towards destabilizing traditional hierarchical leadership forms in the military, which are often coded as male instead of creating a more cooperative mode of war fighting. Once again, these technologies might thus represent a step towards the destabilization of the traditional gendered regime of women's jobs and men's jobs. While new developments thus appear to give feminists much reason for optimism, in reality a new narrative has arisen which describes how robotic technologies will create not a cyborg but a ‘super soldier’. In this narrative, the human operator is not seen or described as dependent upon or merged with technology. Rather he (or she) is seen as controlling the technology, subduing it in the ways in which man has traditionally utilized and subdued nature and thus, in this way reinforcing a binary distinction between that which dominates and that which is dominated (Kaplan 1994). This narrative appears in guidelines developed by military planners and passed to organizations of defense contractors who create new technologies. Designers are encouraged to expropriate features of the animal kingdom in creating weaponized bugs and animals, thus replicating the way in which scientists previously expropriated women's bodies through taking technological control of the reproductive process (Wajcman 1991). Designers expropriate nature to create new weapons, or they harvest and harness features from the animal kingdom to create a new type of supersoldier or superwarrior; one with better eyesight, better hearing and other technologically enhanced features as he either wears the technology or has it surgically implanted in his own body. Both developers and those who hire them often refer to Darwin, suggesting both that the new soldier represents a higher stage of evolution, as well as the fact that (in Hobbesian or Realist terms) survival of the fittest is still the rule when it comes to warfare. Robotic technology, thus, becomes an adjunct of the warfighter, who is coded as male and, instead of eliminating gender differences, technological advances create a new soldier who is a more virile and a more deadly male. In this narrative, technology does not protect the soldier but instead enhances the soldier. The new ‘super soldier’ is described in the 2009 report Future Soldier 2030 Initiative (US Army Natick Soldier RD and E Center 2009). In addition, when a drone or robot acts to protect a warfighter or carries out an act of combat, the narrative is often adjusted to suggest that the activities which occur are not the achievement of the robot, but are instead achievements of the (usually male) designers of the technology. Thus, Major Ray Maher, Assistant Product Manager for the Air Warrior Product Office, notes that ‘the formula is soldiers helping soldiers helping soldiers’ – referring to the way that soldiers act as weapons testers assisting engineers who create technology for defending soldiers (Siniard 2011). In this way, soldiers are seen not as being aided by technology, but rather by engineers. In both of these situations, the US military's reading of the ways in which technology enhances gender contradicts Haraway's narrative. Reliance on new technologies becomes not a weakening or a form of dependence but rather the ultimate male enhancement. Here, we can consider the naming of the exoskeleton as the ‘HULC’ and the intertextual reference to the masculine comic book hero The Incredible Hulk who represents a sort of supermale. New technologies are thus described as creating a ‘super soldier’ who is more male, more lethal and more dominant than previous human alone soldier, thus reinforcing what Peterson (2010: 26) calls the valorization of hypermasculinity. In addition, Haraway's cyborg narrative rests on the assumption that robotics will be available to all individuals or all soldiers and, thus, a blurring of the lines between human and machine, female and male as well as disabled and able will occur. However, strict, hierarchical access regimes for new body-enhancing technologies currently exist. Within the Marine Corps, Blue Force Tracking systems are only available to Special Operations Forces and Other Government Agency (OGA) personnel, as are Personnel Recovery (PR) BFT systems. And within the Army, Blue Force Tracking Technology is available only to combat units (Schwerin 2011) from which women are still excluded. Thus, women have been systematically excluded from using these two technologies, just as Berg and Lie suggest that women have been denied access to other technological capabilities and equipment in the past (Berg and Lie 1995: 340). In this way, new body-enhancing and communications technologies access regimes threaten to create a new type of digital divide – not between the poor and the wealthy based on who can afford technology, but between male and female, as technology is presented as being created for men to enjoy and use and often in ways that demean women.8 Thus, rather than flattening gender differences through the use of new technology, instead a new hierarchy will emerge between enhanced and non-enhanced soldiers. Indeed, one can imagine a new hierarchy in which ‘supermales’ – with superior hearing, eyesight (including the ability to see in the dark), the ability to heal themselves when injured, and to go without sleep and food – dominate over both ‘regular men’ and women.9 Again, robotic technology would thus reinforce hegemonic masculinity rather than eliminating it. AUTONOMOUS TECHNOLOGY AND THE GENDER CONSTRUCT OF WARFARE Thus far, we have illustrated how social constructs of the technology of autonomous warfare have successfully contained and limited its revolutionary or emancipatory effects – showing how the military has successfully created a narrative which reframes technological activity as masculine, as well as the one which reframes technological dependence as technological enhancement. However, we still need to consider the question of distance from the battlefield. In what ways does the fact that men and women now fight virtually from the comfort of home change our understanding of combat as a gendered phenomenon? Clearly, the ability to fight virtually has allowed for more women soldiers to participate in ‘combat’. Data indicates that 17 per cent of those assigned to drone activities at Creech Air Force Base in Nevada are female (Singer 2012). But does the participation in war activity from a remote location where one is not actually at risk of death change how we think about war as an activity? Presently, the US military's answer to these questions is simply that there is no distinction between remote combat and close-range combat. In the words of Colonel Chris Chambliss of Creech Air Base: ‘I don't think we're 7500 miles away at all. I think if you walk out the hangar and you go into one of the ground control stations, you're in the fight’ (Sixty Minutes 2009). The military also reinforces a distinction between home activity and combat activity through mandating that drone operators not take phone calls from home while on duty, and that they wear the same uniforms as those engaged in air combat. Studies on the prevalence of PTSD in drone operators indicate that adopting a ‘combat mindset’ can be just as wearing emotionally regardless of the location where one is while engaged in combat. Thus far, the military strategy of equating virtual and real tasks, regarding virtual assistance as enhancement rather than weakness, and simply ignoring the distances from the battlefield, has been quite effective. The debate about the changed meaning of combat simply is not present in the military community. Thus, developments in the field of autonomous warfare provide fodder for the constructivist position that technological developments do not necessarily lead to social progress or change. In the SCOT school, analysts argue that technology's meaning is largely dictated by the environment and by the usage regimes imposed by those who control the technology. According to this view, technological inventions alone can never force a change in social structures, though, in certain instances, technological developments might help to support social changes being carried out by the users (Pinch and Bijker 1984; LaTour 2005; Oldenziel and Zachmann 2009). As Grint and Woolgar suggest: The gender of a technology does not lie encased in the fabric of the material. It is instead a temporary contingent upshot of ongoing interpretation by designers, sellers and users. The politics and values of technology result from the gaze of the human; they do not lie in the gauze of the machine. (Grint and Woolgar 1995: 305) Thus, so far it appears that the military has been able to ‘hold the line’, introducing new technologies while simultaneously dictating to their designers and their end-users what they will mean and how they will be used. In this instance, it, thus, appears possible to introduce revolutionary technologies without necessarily leading to a significant change in the activity of a warfighter, the role of a warfighter or the overall meaning of warfare. The emancipatory potential of autonomous technology, thus, might exist but has not so far been realized.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.