Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

LAWs lacking emotion is an aff argument – that makes them unethical because they lack the empathy to decide whether or not they should kill.

Kenneth Anderson (Contact Author), 2-28-2017, "Debating Autonomous Weapon Systems, Their Ethics, and Their Regulation Under International Law," No Publication, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2978359

In the foreseeable future, we will be turning over more and more functions with life or death implications to machines—such as driverless cars or automated robot surgery technologies—not simply because they are more convenient but because they prove to be safer—and our basic notions about machine and human decisionmaking will evolve. Aworld that comes, if it does, to accept self-driving autonomous cars may also be one in which people expect those technologies to be applied to weapons and the battlefeld as a matter of course, precisely because it regards them as better (and indeed might fnd the failure to use them morally objectionable). Te second argument is that AWS should be banned because machine learning and AI will never reach the point of being capable of satisfying the requirements of LOAC, law, and ethics. Te underlying premise here is that machines will not be capable, now or in the future, of the requisite intuition, cognition, and judgment to comply with legal and ethical requirements—especially amid the fog of war. Tis is a core conviction held by many who favour a complete ban on autonomous lethal weapons. They generally deny that, even over time and, indeed, no matter how much time or technological progress takes place, machine systems will ever manage to reach the point of satisfying legal and ethical codes and principles applicable in war. Tat is because, they believe, no machine system will ever be able to make appropriate judgments in the infnitely complex situations of warfare, or because no machine will ever have the capability, through its programming, to exhibit key elements of human emotion and affect that make human beings irreplaceable in making lethal decisions on the battlefeld—compassion, empathy, and sympathy for other human beings (Losing Humanity 2012: 4). Tese assessments are mostly empirical. Although many who embrace them might also fnally rest upon moral premises denying in principle that a machine has the moral agency or moral psychology to make lethal decisions, they are framed here as distinct factual claims about the future evolution of technology. Te argument rests on assumptions about how machine technology will actually evolve over decades or longer or, more frankly, how it will not evolve, as well as beliefs about the special nature of human beings and their emotional and afective abilities on the battlefeld that no machine could ever exhibit, even over the course of technological evolution. It is as if to say that no autonomous lethal weapon system could ever pass an ‘ethical Turing Test’ under which, hypothetically, were a human and a machine hidden behind a veil, an objective observer could not tell which was which on the basis of their behaviours. It is of course quite possible that fully autonomous weapons will never achieve the ability to meet the required standards, even far into the future. Yet, the radical scepticism that underlies the argument that they never will is unjustifed. Research into the possibilities of autonomous machine decision-making, not just in weapons but across many human activities, is only a couple of decades old. No solid basis exists for such sweeping conclusions about the future of technology.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.