Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

GCMs and mainstream climate science are entrenched in masculinity which distorts their conclusions and erases the gendered nature of warming

Nagel 16

(Joane, 2016, Distinguished Professor of Sociology at the University of Kansas, is the author of Race, Ethnicity, and Sexuality: Intimate Intersections, Forbidden Frontiers., Gender and Climate Change: Impacts, Science, Policy, Routledge, hardback, JKS)

Gender Critique of Climate Change Science

If gender matters in some medical research, does it matter in all medical research, or all scientific research, especially climate science? Various critics of the research findings of the IPCC have focused on its reliance on large-scale general circulation models (GCMs).69 Feminist scholars argue that GCMs reflect a classically masculine approach which minimizes knowledge gained from human lived experience in favor of abstract mathematical representations of reality.7°Climate change skeptics charge that the models are "alarmist" social constructions that generate "phantom threats" designed to satisfy environmental press groups and to promote scientists' self-interest in fame and funding. Beyond their negative evaluations of GCMs, there is little other common ground for proponents of these two critiques, though both likely would agree that: [I]t is difficult to imagine an environmental phenomenon less directly observable, more remote from everyday experience, and more dependent on the technical apparatus of science for con-structing its apparent "reality" than the so-called greenhouse effect.72 Although GCMs are acknowledged by their designers to be complex, inaccurate, and incomplete representations of the actual global climate system, they are the backbone of the IPCC reports.73 Climate models rest on the prestige of their mainly male designers (prominent scientists and engineers), advanced technology used to create them (supercomputers), technical language (Navier-Stokes equations and computation ally intensive numerical models), and elevated status of the institution where they are refined and tested (national laboratories, scientific agencies, leading universities). The work of climate scientists and the IPCC has been and remain essential to understanding the physical processes associated with climate change and sounding the alarm about its seriousness. The predictions of these models and the science that supported them were' the basis of our discussion of climate change and its impacts in the previous three chapters. In fact, we spent the last two entire chapters examining the impacts of climate change on men and women, relying largely on the findings associated with GCMs reported in the 2013 IPCC's AR5, Climate Change 2013: 1he Physical Science Basis. Despite the importance of this research, there have been major blind spots weaknesses in climate science and the work of the IPCC, particularly in the area of climate justice, and especially with regard to gender inequalities related to climate change. In the first three chapters of this book on gender and climate change we depended on the 1552-page IPCC Working Group I report on Climate Change 2013 - The Physical Science Basis to estimate the gendered implications of its predictions, though the words “gender” or “women'' never appear in its pages. A word search of the report does, however generate dozens of entries for "human," mostly referring to human influence on the climate system. Apparently the IPCC's AR5 Working Group I is interested in humans, but not men or women. A similar search of the IPCC AR5 of Working Group II's "Summary for Policymakers," which focused on climate change "impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability," yields similar results - no men or women, only humans. The same absence of references to gender or women characterized IPCC ARS of Working Group Ill's "Summary for Policymakers," which focused on "mitigation of climate change." Some of the chapters of the full Working Group II and III reports do reference gender and women, but they do not discuss men, and few readers look beyond the more succinct "Summary" documents, since presumably that is what is important for policymakers and non-specialists to know. The disjuncture between "human'' causes and impacts of climate change and the gender causes and impacts, or the class or racial or regional or age-related causes and impacts of reflects the level of generality of much climate change science, including climate models. Climate science depicts the causes and impacts of climate change as a universal process in which human distinctions are irrelevant. This emphasis on "human" obscures differences between men and women, rich and poor, young and old, educated and uneducated, urban and rural, or global North and global South as they relate to the causes and consequences of climate change. “Human" implies a common and equal contribution to and fate in the face of climate chance. “Human” ignores unequal inputs as well as unequal impacts within and across populations. A critique of this universalism is that while we all may be human, and we all may be in this together, we do not all equally contribute to the problem, nor are we going to have the same experience of climate change. The IPP acknowledges that historically most greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions originated in the global North with increasingly catastrophic effects in the global South. Its failure to deconstruct "anthropogenic” climate change, however, obscures the raced, classed, and gendered nature of both its causes and consequences. The focus of GCMs and IPCC reports on "humans" creates a comfortable "objectivity" and distance for the model makers- a safe space that equalizes blame for the problem being studied by mostly male climate scientists from developed countries. By emphasizing the “human contribution" to climate change, researchers can ignore exactly which groups of humans are doing the causing and paper over who is responsible for climate injustices and inequality. How should we understand climate modelers' difference-erasing focus on the universal "human'' aspects of climate change? The study of gender inequalities in European molecular biology cited above offers two possible explanations: the emphasis on "human" is because male scientists do not see any significant differences among humans, or because they prefer not to acknowledge differences that are an indictment of the system in which they have not only an investment, but a controlling interest. Critics make a direct connection between the overrepresentation of men in climate science and policy and the gender biases and blind spots weaknesses in both climate science and climate policy. Men dominate the issue at all levels, as scientific and economic experts, entrepeneurs, policy makers and spokespeople. Since the 1970s climate change had been identified and explained by natural scientists... It is not irrelevant that the majority of climate scientists are men. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is mostly made up of male scientists, with "chairman'' Rajendra Pachauri leading at the global level. Men also dominate in the climate policy arena ... The most prominent politicians associated with the issue are male ... In 2007 an Internet survey of "global consumers" in 47 countries conducted by The Nielsen Company and Oxford University found that 18 out of the 22 "most influential spokespeople on climate change” are men.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.