Reducing life to existing economic markers disavows the really-existing labor such as care and nurturing which aren’t given an economic valuation. Such a masculine measure of economics epistemically guarantees their predictions are false while sustaining exploitation and violence against women.
Roberts 15
(Adrienne Roberts is Lecturer in International Politics at the University of Manchester. (2015) Gender, Financial Deepening and the Production of Embodied Finance: Towards a Critical Feminist Analysis, Global Society, 29:1, 107-127, DOI: 10.1080/13600826.2014.975189, JKS)
Theorising Finance as Gendered and Embodied The centrality of bodies to economic processes is a basic ontological premise that underpins the great majority of feminist economics and feminist International Political Economy (IPE), though this is often implicit rather than explicit. Drawing on fem- inist and historical materialist scholarship, we can identify three theoretical entry points, or premises, that are useful for thinking about both the inherently embodied nature of finance and the specific ways in which TBF agendas work to produce, or at times to disappear, bodies. The first premise is that all economies, including financial economies, are constituted by productive and reproductive labour, including the labour associated with biological reproduction. Insofar as many of the projects associ- ated with TBF remove from view the vast amounts of labour linked to social reproduction, they intensify the demands placed on women as workers and nurturers. The second premise is that we are witnessing the increasing “financialisation of social reproduction”, which is contributing to the commodification of women’s bodily capacities as they are projected as “untapped resources” in need of exploitation by (Western) capital. The third premise is that financial deepening contributes to the differential production of bodies, which includes the production of differences between bodies that stem from the differential valuation of their labour (the valuation of paid above unpaid, productive above reproductive, etc.). The production of differ- ence also takes shape here through processes that work to ostensibly erase the bodies of financial consumers in the Global North (i.e. through “abstract” assessments of risk) while actively producing financial consumers in the Global South as “people of the body” who make good investments precisely because of their association with maternalism. I will elaborate each of these in turn. (1) Economies are constituted by productive and reproductive labour, including the labour associated with biological reproduction. The first theoretical entry point is based on the observation first made by socialist feminists in the 1970s and 1980s that the economy is constituted by the social relations of labour that are involved in the production and exchange of commod- ities and the meeting of human needs on a daily and generational basis.8 These latter forms of labour are now more commonly described as “social reproduction”, which has a distinctly embodied dimension as it includes the work associated with: (a) biological reproduction (including social constructions of motherhood); (b) the reproduction, socialisation and education of the labour force; and (c) the reproduc- tion and provisioning of care.9 This work is linked to historically specific ideals regarding the gendered division of labour that feminise the (paid and unpaid) work of social reproduction and contribute to its devaluation.10 Given that finance is deeply connected to other forms of production and exchange, it should also be seen as structurally linked to labouring bodies, as well as to the mothering and caring bodies that together perform the productive and reproductive labour underpinning accumulation in capitalist societies. Most mainstream economics would reject this view of finance, as finance tends to be treated as an objective (and pseudo-scientific) tool that is used to allocate assets and liabilities across time. Bodies, as bearers of productive and reproductive labour, do not generally appear at all, though an abstract figure of homo oeconomicus does figure into the analysis. In this andocentric model, homo oeconomicus is presumed to represent all people, appearing as both disembodied and socially disembedded. Feminist economists have called this the “separative-self model”, as it abstracts the utility-maximizing rational actor away from all other social forms and leaves little to no room for considering non-maximizing behaviour and motivations (i.e., love, nurture, altruism, etc.).11 Yet, in the process of removing the material body from economic analysis, it simultaneously works to devalue the bodies of those tradition- ally associated with “non-rational” and “emotional” behaviour, which have historically included the poor, women and non-European “others”.12 What is particularly interesting when using this lens to look at the gender dis- courses of TBF is that while it tends to adhere to a neoclassical view of markets as coordinating mechanisms that are fundamentally disembodied and gender- neutral, it also draws on a historically constructed view of female economic actors as mothering and nurturing. That is, the body reappears here as women’s higher aversion to risk and greater likelihood to invest in their children is natura- lised, and implicitly linked to their (socio-)biological role as mothers. Yet, as I will further evidence in the third section, this does not lead the proponents of TBF to see markets as inherently gendered, but rather, gender continues to be externalised from broader economic processes. (2) The “financialisation of social reproduction” is rendering women’s bodies particularly susceptible to processes of commodification and exploitation A second theoretical entry point for thinking about the relationship between finance, gender and bodies has been opened up by recent writing on what we might refer to as “the financialisation of social reproduction”, by which I mean the mediation of social reproduction through financial markets and interest- paying financial transactions.13 For instance, it has been well documented in the academic and policy literature that finance has become increasingly important in mediating the social relations of housing (i.e. through privatised and securitised mortgage financing), forms of consumption (i.e. by using credit cards to pay for food), education (i.e. though student loans and, in the US, loans to pay for all levels of schooling), security in old age (i.e. through the privatisation of pension plans), and so on.14 In one of the clearest theoretical engagements with this trend, Bryan, Martin and Rafferty point out that the linking of financial circuits of accumulation to the reproduction of labour—though interest payments made on credit used to buy the commodities necessary for reproduction and other means—is helping to reconstitute labour as a form of capital.15 Although very little of this literature deploys a gender analysis or uses a frame- work of social reproduction per se, it is important in offering empirical evidence regarding the ways in which social reproduction, which has always been structu- rally linked to the accumulation of capital, is increasingly being structurally linked to finance. Given women’s positioning at the crossroads of production and social reproduction, it is therefore rather unsurprising that women’s bodies are increasingly being framed as “untapped resources” that offer potential profits to financial and other firms.