Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Political leaders’ resistance to ban LAWs demonstrates their impulse to increase control and surveillance---even if they win the DA we are winning a root cause to long term governmental stability.

Sullins, 13 [John Sullins works for Sonoma State University’s department of philosophy, PhD, January 2013, accessed 6/30/22, 978-1-4799-0450-1, Cyber Conflict (CyCon), 2013 5th International Conference on Project: The Morality of Military Robotics, “An ethical analysis of the case for robotic weapons arms control,” https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261238028_An_ethical_analysis_of_the_case_for_robotic_weapons_arms_control/]/ISEE

If you are a politician in a liberal democracy, then the technology of unmanned weapons is the answer to your dreams. While armed aggression between liberal democracies is rare, they are involved in many military conflicts driven by clashes with nondemocratic countries or interventions in unstable regions of the world. Given the norms and values espoused in liberal democracies there is a political will to spread the virtues of democracy and check the aggressions of non-democratic powers. But other values and norms such as the distribution of political power to the voting population, severely hampers the governments of these countries who try to act on their military aspirations. There are massive political costs to be paid when it comes to deploying large numbers of troops in foreign lands. Sauer and Schörnig (2012), note that the governments of democracies want to engage in military activities but the citizens of democracies demand that these adventure be low cost with no casualties from their own military and low casualties inflicted on the enemy and local population. [T]he need to reduce costs, the short-term satisfaction of particular ‘risk-transfer rules’ for avoiding casualties, and the upkeep of a specific set of normative values – constitute the special appeal of unmanned systems to democracies” (Sauer and Schörnig, 2012, p. 365). Unmanned weapons systems would seem to allow all constituents within a liberal democracy to achieve their goals. The weapons are not expensive compared to the massive expense of building, deploying and maintaining manned systems. The missions are secret and so small they hardly warrant mention in the daily news back home. There is almost no risk to military personnel in their use and the number of enemy casualties per strike is relatively small. Also, politicians such as President Barack Obama have made claims that these weapons are far less indiscriminate and more tightly controlled in their killing than alternative modes of attack (Landler, 2012). We should note that this claim is backed up by what appears to be questionable methods used in the official calculation of civilian casualties since every adult male in the blast of the weapon is often considered a combatant by default, a claim that is often disputable (Qazi and Jillani, 2012). So the more precise targeting available on modern drones does not necessarily correspond to less civilian casualties (ibid). These weapons also come with a moral veneer that comes from the assumption that a more ethical conduct of war is possible using these machines. Sauer and Schörnig go on to conclude that the political goals along with the normative drives of liberal democracies necessitates that unmanned systems will continue to be armed with more powerful weaponry and that they will be given more demanding missions which will require greater autonomy from the machine (Sauer and Schörnig, 2012, p. 370). This argument shows that we can expect the research into autonomous weapons systems to increase and for these systems to proliferate into every aspect of military activities across the globe. Recent history has given ample empirical evidence to back this theory up. Even though President Obama was elected largely on an anti-war vote, it has been reported that there has been an 8% increase in the use of drones during his first term and in 2011 drones were used in, “…253 strikes – one every four days…. [And] Between 2,347 and 2,956 people are reported to have died in the attacks – most of them militants” (Woods, 2011). This trend has only increased since that time. Other countries such as Israel and Italy are known to operate reconnaissance drones but recently the German government has announced plans to invest in both armed and unarmed drones (Kim, 2013). As the enthusiasm for this technology grows, a mounting opposition movement has also emerged that claims that this technology is not a cheap, easy, casualty free means of propagating just war. Instead they claim that these technologies contribute to unjust military adventures and a indefensibly immoral push button warfare that claims the lives of thousands of innocents caught in the cross fire. In the interest of furthering the ethical use of these technologies, it is important that we give these counter arguments our full attention in this paper. We should note that some technologies can cause what philosophers of technology call reverse adaptation; “…the adjustment of human ends to match the character of the available means” (Winner, 1978, p. 229). This is where the social and political milieu of a society changes to accommodate the inflexibility of a technology, rather than waiting to deploy the technology when it is more suited to the human environment. A prime example would be the way that human societies changed due to the adoption of mass production necessitating all manner of social upheaval that proved to be the fault lines of human conflict over the last two centuries. There are many other examples of this in recent history, think of the social disruption caused by the introduction of the automobile or cellular telephone, etc. It is obvious that autonomous weapons are again confronting our societies with the problems of reverse adaptation. These weapons are completing a trend in technological warfare begun in the nineteenth century that is making traditional notions of ethics in warfare largely untenable. These notions were always on shaky ground to begin with, but the tradition of just war that reaches back to the middle ages has become almost mute in its ability to influence decisions made on the modern battlefield. If this was not worrisome enough, as aging drone technologies are replaced with better equipment, the surplus will find use in civilian law enforcement duties, this will complete the circle and technologies that liberal democracies gladly used to control their enemies will now be used in ways that challenge and potentially curtail cherished civil liberties at home. Because of this, it is vital that we engage in discussion of these technologies at every opportunity. We will take up this issue again and apply it to the problem of creating a realistic robotic arms control at the end of this paper.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.