Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is worse. Anti-capitalist movements bolster gender-based oppression because feminized labor is rendered invisible.

Coleman and Bassi 11

(Lara Montesinos, Serena A., June, University of Bristol, UK and University of Warwick, UK, Deconstructing Militant Manhood MASCULINITIES IN THE DISCIPLINING OF (ANTI-)GLOBALIZATION POLITICS, International Feminist Journal of Politics, 13:2, pgs 207-208, JKS)

Gendered hierarchies and cultural scripts are not a side issue for movements that aim to contest the globalization of capitalism. Materialist feminists have highlighted how capitalism has relied upon concealed, underpaid or unpaid female labour (e.g. Eisenstein 1979; Barrett 1980; Fuentes and Ehren- reich 1983). As Rosemary Hennessy (2000: 6) puts it, ‘women provide most of the world’s socially necessary labor – that is, labor that is necessary to col- lective survival – but much of it is rendered invisible, both in and outside the value system of commodity exchange’. Materialist analyses have also highlighted the relationship between heteronormative and capitalist social relations. Leslie Feinberg (1997: 231, see also Hennessy 1996), for example, theorizes the oppression of transgender people under capitalism through a Marxist analysis of how an ideology of binary gender became hegemonic with ‘the rise of private property, the male-dominated family and class divisions’. Moreover, the power-laden performances through which gender is produced are intricately bound up with cultural scripts deployed in the imposition of capitalist relations across the world. J. K. Gibson-Graham (1996: 120–47), for instance, draws a parallel of globalization’s ‘tightly scripted narrative of differential power’ that celebrates ‘the inevitability of capitalist penetration’ in every corner of the world and the script that normalizes and naturalizes the rape of female bodies (1996: 120–1). Lara Coleman (2007) has explored how the violent imposition of neoliberal development in Colombia has mobi- lized gendered imaginative geographies, through which spaces targeted for ‘civilizing’ interventions are marked out in terms of sub-ordinate gender identities counterposed to the identity of an ideal citizen cast in terms of a hegemonic, bourgeois-rational masculinity. Similarly, Penny Griffin (2007) has highlighted the way in which dominant forms of heterosexual masculinity mark out the norms of successful human behaviour reproduced in the neoliberal discourse of the World Bank. The reiteration of gendered cultural scripts within (anti-)globalization politics does not only shore up capitalism’s unequal effects on women (cf. Sullivan 2005: 9). It also bolsters other effects of gender-based oppression on women, transgender people and men with non-hegemonic gender performances. Moreover, this reiteration of hierarchically ordered gender identities should be understood as reinforcing capitalist relations at a much deeper level, in that it restates the cultural scripts that capital deploys to normalize its interventions and policy ‘solutions’. There is a circular element to this too. Who is visible and who can speak within (anti-)globalization politics, and which bodies are privileged or excluded, derives from the gendered performance of ‘resistance’. Cultural texts assign roles defining, for example, who is able to speak with authority and who is confined to a walk-on appearance as a ‘movement housewife’ (Roth 2001). This in turn forecloses the possibilities for contestation and re-signification within spaces of ‘resistance’, reinforcing the tendency to re-iterate those cultural scripts that enhance the status quo.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.