Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Lethal autonomous weapons are the next step in posthumanism generating a new wave of dominant subjectivities.

Jones, 18 [Emily Jones is a Lecturer in Law at the University of Essex, 2018, Human Rights Clinic at the University of Essex, accessed on 6-21-2022, “A Posthuman-Xenofeminist Analysis of the Discourse on Autonomous Weapons Systems and Other Killing Machines” http://repository.essex.ac.uk/21540/7/E.%20Jones%2C%20posthumanxenofeminist%20autonomous%20weapons.pdf]/ISEE

Global military spending has been estimated by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) to have been around US$1.6 trillion in 2016. The military economy is not, however, just about state spending: direct and indirect employment within the U.S. aerospace and defence industry alone includes approximately 3.53 million people. Feminist scholars have highlighted how militarism goes further in that there are a number of key roles often played by women outside the formal work place. Militarisation can be seen as both creating and profiting from informal (unpaid) work by women, which also produces and maintains gender difference. In addition, military spending benefits companies. It does not, as two peace scholars point out, ‘compete directly with private investment. It supplements but does not supplant the private sector. Thus, its expansion will not undermine business confidence’. The military economy is a fast-moving one, creating continuous profits as technology advances and systems need replacing. Military development spending has increased over the past decade in many states including the U.S., Kenya, Brazil, Colombia, India, Malaysia, Poland and Russia. Much of this war economy is driven by the development and deployment of technology, which reaps profits not only through military use but also often later through civil use. Satellite navigation is a prime example of this. While existing weapons systems such as the PAC-3 and the Samsung SGR-A1 described below are more automated than autonomous, ‘there are significant global efforts in the research and development (R&D) of autonomous systems’. Artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies have seen considerable advancement in the commercial sector, which is leaving the military sector behind.11 States are beginning to note the need to “catch up with Silicon Valley”.Seeking to tap into the advancements made in the commercial sector, the creation of weapons systems with some level of autonomy has recently become a key focus for the U.S. Department of Defense through Project Maven. When establishing the project in 2017, the U.S. Deputy Secretary of Defense Robert O. Work stated that ‘the Department of Defense (DoD) must integrate artificial intelligence and machine learning more effectively across operations to maintain advantages over increasingly capable adversaries and competitors’. While Project Maven is currently focusing on the incorporation of algorithms into military operations, reflecting the current state of technological advancement, it seeks to consider and promote ‘all initiatives that develop, employ, or field, artificial intelligence, automation, machine learning, deep learning and computer vision algorithms’.In other words, Project Maven is not only creating more complex algorithms but is also actively seeking to ensure that the U.S. is at the forefront of the development of autonomous weapons technologies. In this paper I argue that feminist posthumanist theory is an important paradigm through which to understand our relationship to technology, and to autonomous weapons systems in particular. Feminist posthumanism uses technology (alongside the nonhuman animal and matter) to question what it means to be human, deconstructing the very notion of what the human is, noting that the concept of the human in dominant Western accounts of subjectivity creates hierarchies between humans as well as between the human and other living beings. A clear example of the way in which feminist posthuman theory challenges humanist accounts of subjectivity can be seen in Donna Haraway’s work. Haraway notes that humans are already cyborgs in that they are deeply connected to, desire, and are dependent upon technology.16 Such an understanding of technology is essential to understanding autonomous weapons systems. In noting the connection between the human and machine and deconstructing distinctions between autonomy and automation, a posthuman perspective on autonomous weapons foregrounds the need to focus not only on autonomous weapons but on the broad array of delegated killing. While current attempts at legal regulation distinguish between civil and military technologies, such a distinction becomes impossible in light of the clear links between civil and military technologies and the killing potential of many technologies, including artificial intelligence (AI). This article therefore contributes to legal studies as well as the discourse on autonomous weapons. It further contributes to feminist approaches to international law, inserting such approaches into the realm of military technologies and highlighting the relevance of feminist approaches to all areas of international law. Law and gender theory is an important lens through which to analyse military technologies. Military technologies touch on several political and philosophical issues that gender theorists have long discussed. Legal articulations of subjectivity in particular are something that feminist legal theory has long problematised, and is directly relevant to the question of the ‘legal person’ as machines become more and more autonomous.20 This may require legal change to allow for ‘electronic’ subject-recognition. In addition to this, gender theories have developed a nuanced set of tools through which to analyse issues around inclusion, exclusion and justice. This can be seen in gender theory’s commitment to intersectionality, which looks at gender alongside race, sexuality, ability, class, etc. A gender perspective ensures the consideration of the multiple ways in which technologies may impact on intersecting groups, which may be missed in mainstream discussions about the use of autonomous weapons systems. Despite the many debates on autonomous weapons, there has been little consideration of such systems from a feminist posthuman perspective. Mary Manjikian appears to be the only scholar who has sought to apply feminist posthumanism to the realm of autonomous technology. Manjikian discusses the ways in which military technologies may be used to create either a less or a more militarised world, concluding that technology is more likely to create a more militarised, hyper-masculine world. Heeding Manjikian’s suspicion of the hyper-masculinity of militarism, this article works in the vein of Haraway and other feminist posthuman thinkers such as Rosi Braidotti and the ‘xenofeminists’, a collective of scholars working under the name ‘Laboria Cuboniks’ who seek to use and appropriate technology for feminist aims – to think critically about the significance of autonomous weapons systems, for the ways in which law fashions our understanding of human subjectivity. This paper adds to the discourse on autonomous weapons by proposing a xenofeminist posthuman perspective, providing a different way of understanding these systems while contributing to the development of feminist approaches to international law. While Haraway is fundamentally positive about technology’s potential to be used for feminist aims, she notes that feminists must also ensure that technology is not used to create ‘the final abstraction embodied in a Star Wars apocalypse waged in the name of defence, about the final appropriation of women’s bodies in a masculinist orgy of war.’ Haraway also notes that technology is embedded within capitalism, pointing out the fact that the people usually making the machines are often poor women from the Global South.28 Haraway’s work seeks to create a feminist techno-future in spite of and while trying to avoid the risks of a possible hyper-masculine techno-future. While Haraway seeks to promote the use of technology for feminist aims, the Xenofeminist Manifesto (XFM) has a more focused feminist project in mind. The XFM seeks to destroy capitalism through the accelerated use of technology to create a post-work world, thereby directly advocating for post-capitalism as a feminist aim. Thus, the XFM insists not only on the need to accelerate our use of/dependence upon technology, but also to appropriate this technology for feminist aims, ensuring that such technology remains loyal to the politics they wish it to promote. Such feminist aims include the will to ensure the free distribution of hormones or the will to use technology to restructure gendered systems of reproductive labour and care.While the xenofeminists note the dilemmas technology brings and the need to ‘explicit[ly] acknowledge… these conditions as a target for elimination’, they do not address the fact that the creation of a post-capitalist world will not be not immediate. In the meantime, as Haraway notes, science and technology have both contributed to and changed the face of ‘late capitalism’, with more work becoming precarious and being done at home, which affects women and people of colour most. Technology is largely designed by (and profits) people who are white, male and living in the Global North, while the raw materials are mined and manufactured elsewhere, by others. While some xenofeminist scholars propose the ubiquitous use of technology as the way to a feminist future, that future is less utopic when one considers that much technology is developed, first and foremost, for military purposes. While there has not yet been a feminist posthuman reading of autonomous weapons systems which seeks to dissect the false binaries upheld within the debates on these weapons between the human-machine and autonomy automation, there has been some limited engagement with these systems from a feminist perspective by NGOs, one example being the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom’s disarmament programme, ‘Reaching Critical Will’. They consider the masculine nature of militarism and the ways in which this would only likely get worse if machines stripped of empathy engage in killing, instead of soldiers in face-to-face combat. It is interesting to note that many of the posthuman perspectives which currently exist on the topic of conflict and technology do come from a gender perspective. These works come from outside the legal discipline, however, and tend to focus on drone warfare. Posthuman theory, however, could have a key impact if applied to legal studies and the debates around autonomous weapons. In refusing to see the machine as other, noting the links between the machine and the human, a posthuman approach would refuse the exceptionalism promoted by existing discourses on autonomous weapons, allowing for discussions to encompass a wider range of human-machine life/death decision-making. Killing machines may not be created as killer robots but may come into existence through other civil or military technological developments, such as artificial intelligence (AI) which may not have been designed to kill, but may ultimately be used to kill.38 More mundane but equally dangerous are developments in algorithm-driven decision-making.39 Further to this, given the vast advances in wearable military technologies and human enhancement technologies, a killer machine of the dystopian kind envisaged by many NGOs may, in fact, come about through technologically enhancing soldiers and turning them into superhuman soldiers. While such cyborg soldiers would not be deemed autonomous weapons under existing understandings of such systems, they will beg the same ethical questions around control and accountability, something which has not yet been recognised by the existing work on autonomous weapons. After all, at what point does a technologically mediated human become more machine than human? While job automation may indeed help create a post-work, post-capitalist society,40 such systems pose vast ethical issues around control and accountability. ‘Fully automated luxury communism’ seems less luxurious in the face of machines taking professional killing jobs.41 Drawing on the XFM, this article concludes by proposing the need for a posthumanxenofeminist discourse on autonomous weapons systems and other civil and military technologies. This means that we do not need to ‘abandon’ technology, but rather to use it warily, drawing on the wisdom of intersectional critiques and seeking a post-capitalist vision of society.42 This article therefore makes several key contributions. First, the paper adds to the debate on ‘autonomous’ weapons by challenging existing definitions of such systems. The paper also analyses the international debates on these systems from the as-yet unapplied perspective of posthuman-xenofeminism, highlighting both what feminist posthuman and xenofeminist theory may add to the debates on autonomous weapons systems. Further, this article adds to feminist approaches to international law by situating them within discussions of autonomous weapons, proposing a new posthuman-xenofeminist methodology for such approaches. I conclude that there is a need for feminist posthuman intervention into the legal regulation of all technologies – one that understands the ways in which humans-machines work in connection while seeking to prevent the creation of all killer machines, thereby refusing current attempts at technological legal regulation which distinguish between civil and military technologies.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.