Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Baudrillard is profoundly sexist- he just disguises it through a veneer of edginess

Gallop 13

(Jane Gallop is a distinguished professor at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, “French Theory and the Seduction of Feminism”, published in “Men in Feminism (RLE Feminist Theory), edited by Alice Jardine and Paul Smith, pg.113-114, 2013, date accessed: 4/8/15, )

Nonetheless, Baudrillard’s contradictions seem less subtle than those of other practitioners of such theory, since he remains within a classical theoretical rhetoric of assertion, category, logic. If Baudrillard’s case is interesting to me, it is, first of all, because of the blatant enormity of the contradictions which are better hidden by the stylistic charms of a Derrida or a Lacan. And second of all (this second reason being for me the primary one – my hidden agenda, in fact), because the contradictions seem linked to a rather rabid attack Baudrillard makes on feminism. Many of us have seriously wondered about the effect of French theory on feminism’s health. Baudrillard is, to my knowledge, the male French theorist who most explicitly and most frontally adopts an adversarial relation to feminism. I would like to quote you a passage from the first chapter of De la seduction where the theoretical contradiction occurs within Baudrillard’s pronouncement of the proper course for women: “Now, woman is only appearance. And it’s the feminine as appearance that defeats the profundity of the masculine. Women instead of rising up against this ‘insulting’ formula would do well to let themselves be seduced by this truth, because here is the secret of their power which they are in the process of losing by setting up the profundity of the female against that of the masculine” (p. 22). When he writes “insulting formula,” he puts the word “insulting” (injurieuse) in quotation marks. He does not consider it an insult to say that woman is only appearance. Baudrillard is writing against the history of writing against appearances. He is for appearances, and against profundity, so when he says that “woman is only appearance” it should be taken as a compliment. Nonetheless, when I read this passage, as a woman, I feel insulted. Baudrillard would have it that my feeling of offense is a great error which stems from my inscription within the sort of masculinistic essentialist thinking which condemns appearances as misleading mediations of essences, realities, and truths. Yet, in considering the passage carefully, I decide that it is not what he says about “woman” that offends me so much as what he says about “women”: “Women would do well,” he advises, “to let themselves be seduced by this truth.” It is the phrase “would do well” (feraient bein de) that irks me. Although he puts “insulting” in quotation marks, he uses the word -“truth” (verite) straight. He knows the truth – the profound or hidden truth, I might add – about women, and women, “would do well to let themselves be seduced” by the truth he utters. He speaks not from the masculine or masculinist position (which he identifies as against appearances and for profundities) but from a position that knows the truth of the feminie and the masculine and can thus, from this privileged position beyond sexual difference, advise women how best to combat masculine power. It is his assumption from this position of superiority, of speaking the truth – more than any content of “truth” that he may utter – which offends me. Women, he wants, are in danger of losing their power, but if they would only let themselves be seduced by what he says… A line if ever I heard one. The problem may not lie with the women – the women are not “letting themselves” be seduced – the problem may lie with Baudrillard’s “technique.” Perhaps truth never seduces, or at least not self-certain truth or certainly at all. Baudrillard asserts, in this book, which is, after all, very insightful about how seduction works, that “it is by our fragility that we seduce, never by powers or by strong signs.” (p. 115) As opposed to truth, which is necessarily irreverersible (the opposite of the truth cannot be true), seduction, as Baudrillard understands it, is the very principle of reversibility. Hence the very best “technique” for seduction turns out to be that which can never be simply a technique at all. As Baudrillard puts it: “To be seduced is yet again the best way to seduce… No one, if he is not seduced, will seduce others.” (p.112) Truth cannot seduce; only seduction seduces. Baudrillard cannot seduce feminism with his truth, because he protects his truth from being seduced by feminism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.