Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It’s especially necessary because of Ukraine. Backing down would be a catastrophe.

The Times 22, Britain’s oldest national daily newspaper, 2-15-2022. “The Times view on the Ukraine crisis: Preserving Peace,” The Times, https://archive.ph/lfew2#selection-743.0-743.54

For more than 70 years, NATO has acted as the guarantor of western security. Russian aggression and threats against Ukraine have nothing to do with any supposed provocation by the transatlantic alliance. Demands by the Kremlin that Kyiv forswear forever any ambition to join NATO are a smokescreen for its real objectives and, even if acted upon, would not defuse this crisis. Western governments would merely be inviting further revanchism by President Putin if it entertained them for even a moment, let alone acceded to them.

The notion of a bar on accession to NATO momentarily excited hopes of a solution to the crisis whereby 100,000 Russian troops have massed across Ukraine’s eastern border. Vadym Prystaiko, Ukraine’s ambassador to Britain, appeared to suggest in a BBC interview on Sunday that Kyiv might abandon the aim of joining NATO as the price of avoiding war. A spokesman for Mr Putin said that, while this did not mark a change in Ukrainian policy, it would be a step in the right direction.

Mr Prystaiko swiftly retreated from any such insinuation yesterday, however, saying his remarks had been misunderstood and that the aim of accession to NATO remained part of Ukraine’s constitution. And so it does. Ukraine’s government has compelling reason to seek a way out of the crisis and to lift the threat of invasion. Russia’s illegal annexation of part of Ukraine’s territory in 2014 and continuing warfare, with about 14,000 lives lost to date, are a disaster and an outrage.

Ukraine has requested an urgent meeting with Russian representatives to discuss the crisis under the auspices of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe. And Kyiv might judge that preserving a circumscribed type of sovereignty, comparable perhaps to Finland’s relations with the Soviet Union in the Cold War, is the least bad option. But for great powers to compel it to adopt such a policy would be unconscionable.

Nor would it even work, for it would demonstrate to the Putin regime that by threats and outright invasion it can change the borders of Europe and dictate the alliances of sovereign states. Other nations would be at risk, including the Baltic member states of NATO that were once subjugated by the Soviet Union. This is no way to preserve peace; it is an invitation to aggression.

The Kremlin’s complaints about NATO are a canard. Russian propaganda maintains that the United States gave a commitment at the time of German unification that NATO would not expand eastwards. That account is not supported by James Baker or Mikhail Gorbachev, the leading diplomatic players on either side at the time. Ukraine’s demands in 2013 were for closer relations with the European Union rather than NATO. It was this that Mr Putin could not abide: the prospect of Kyiv allying with western liberal ideals of constitutionalism rather than Mr Putin’s ahistorical fantasies of a common Slavic civilisation.

Kyiv does not have a right to join NATO, for there are stringent criteria for accession. It certainly cannot meet these when part of its territory is under occupation. But it has every right to aspire to membership, even if there is scant likelihood of its acceding in the foreseeable future. For bigger states to force it to renounce such a policy would violate the terms of the Charter for European Security of 1999, which rejects the notion that big powers can legitimately consider any part of Europe as their “sphere of influence”.

Russia is a signatory of that charter and must abide by its terms. NATO is not the aggressor in this crisis; Mr Putin is. NATO powers should strain to resolve it by diplomatic means, but lasting peace is not secured by acquiescence. It requires resolutely opposing imperialism and aiding Ukraine’s legitimate government. As in the Cold War, preserving peace and maintaining deterrence are not alternatives but the same cause.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.