NATO’s sustainable – U.S. reliance and public support prove.
Simon Koschut 21, Heisenberg Fellow at the Otto Suhr Institute of the Freie University Berlin, Ph.D. from the University of Potsdam, former Fellow at the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs at Harvard University, “Whither the Liberal Security Order: The End of NATO as We Know It?” Hegemonic Transition, Chapter 8, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74505-9_8, RMax
Despite these obvious problems, however, it seems premature to join in the swan song for NATO. Indeed, with the incoming Biden administration there are many indications that NATO will continue to exist. A dissolution or disintegration of NATO cannot be ruled out entirely, but it is not very likely. This is mainly due to two reasons.
First, the US needs NATO in its conflicts with other hegemons. When the Cold War drew to a close, NATO lost its central importance in the eyes of many US decision-makers in Congress and in the White House, e.g., consider the sidelining of NATO during the so-called War on Terror or the Obama administration’s troop surge in the Pacific region in the wake of the so-called Asian Pivot. Recently, however, the organization has regained importance for the US in the course of the Russian annexation of Crimea and the threat to US security interests in the South China Sea. The US, in particular, is currently pushing NATO members to invest more in military defense in order to increase the deterrent potential against Russia and China (Defense News, 2016).
Second, domestic support for NATO remains high in the US. According to a 2016 survey by the Pew Research Center, a majority of the US population continues to see NATO as “good for the US” (Pew Research Center, 2016). This support has even increased under Trump over the past two years. Granted, this is mainly due to the support from the Democratic camp. Among Democrats, support for NATO is particularly high at 78%, compared to only 47% among Republicans. In 2016, the gap between the two parties was only 6% (Pew Research Center, 2018a). This shows an intensification of the party-political division in the US on NATO politics and seems to indicate that Trump’s criticism of the alliance has generated increasing resonance, at least among Republicans. 48 percent of all respondents in the US say that NATO is not doing enough to solve problems globally (Pew Research Center, 2018b). Nevertheless, around two-thirds (62%) of Americans see NATO positively, and the trend is increasing: approval of NATO has improved by 9 percentage points compared to 2017. It is the strongest US support for the transatlantic security alliance in recent years.
The current crisis surrounding COVID-19 has done little to change this. On an operational level, COVID-19 has impacted negatively on NATO’s missions and overall military interoperability. Moreover, the immense financial costs of cushioning the economic effects of COVID-19 will surely affect political debates on military spending. Some even suggest that NATO deterrence may suffer due the pandemic (Mölling et al., 2020). On a political level, and perhaps surprisingly so, the COVID19 crisis has done little to foster political cohesion and solidarity among NATO members. To be sure, COVID-19 has given attention to allied resilience and preparedness according to Article 3 of the Washington Treaty, and many member states have engaged in civilian and logistical support in response to the pandemic. For example, NATO’s Rapid Air Mobility initiative has facilitated the delivery of medical supplies and personal protective equipment to and from several countries, including the UK, Turkey, the United States, and Italy (NATO, 2020). But NATO, as a military security organization, is not well prepared to assist in combatting a global health crisis. As a result, member states have looked elsewhere for international cooperation and assistance or, as in many cases, pursued national policies.