Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Criminalizes Justice

Securitization is fundamentally flawed – criminalizes those who advocate for social justice to justify securitizing “threats” – Milagro Sala proves

Selister Gomes and Rodrigues Marques, 21 --- Mariana Selister Gomes is an associate Professor of the Department of Social Sciences, of the Post-Graduation Program in Social Sciences and of the Post-Graduation Program in International Relations of the Federal University of Santa Maria. Collaborating Professor of the Post-Graduation Program in Sociology of the Federal University of Sergipe. Doctor in Sociology at the Lisbon University Institute. Master in Sociology by the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul and Bachelor in History by the same institution. Renata Rodrigues Marques is a teacher in International Relations at the Federal University of Santa Maria (UFSM). Graduated in International Relations from the same institution. Member of the GIDH Extension Project - Gender, Intersectionality and Human Rights and of the Feminist and Decolonial Research Methodology Research Project. (Mariana Selister Gomes and Renata Rodrigues Marques, "Can securitization theory be saved from itself? A decolonial and feminist intervention", 10-26-2021, SAGE Journals, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/09670106211027795)//EG

Despite the limitations set out above, securitization theory proves to be useful in enabling the analysis of power dynamics involved in state security discourses and the construction of threats as an instrument of state governmentality (). Feminist approaches to security and decolonial feminism, in turn, complement structural analysis by exposing the modern state as a gendered and racialized construction. The second argument of this intervention is a defense of empirical studies as a way of overcoming the neglects of the classical perspective of securitization theory by analyzing how the dimensions of coloniality intervene in processes of securitization. To illustrate how an empirical turn can make the case for securitization theory, we present our research on the construction of racialized women who actively participate in political life as a threat to the governmentality of the modern state. Our investigation focused on the case of Milagro Sala, an indigenous woman who is the leader of the organization Tupac Amaru in Argentina and who was arrested in 2016. The organization is linked to several different ethnic groups, such as the Mapuche, the Guarani, and the Kollas. The objective of our study was to analyze how the process of securitization in this case is intertwined with processes of racialization and genderization. With this example, which reinforces the requirement for theoretical openness, we seek to demonstrate the importance of methodological openness and empirical research that employs the variables race and gender in studies of securitization processes. Sala was elected as a member of the Mercosur Parliament, the civil representation body of the trade bloc’s member-states, at the end of 2015, and arrested shortly afterwards, in January 2016, because she was perceived as being the ‘organizer’ of a protest in front of the seat of government in Argentina’s Jujuy province. Sala and other activists from Tupac Amaru were accused of several crimes in relation to their protest in Jujuy, and legal recognition of the organization was suspended by Executive Decree 402-G. We conducted our analysis of these events using content analysis and critical discourse analysis of political and media discourses. The political speeches we analyzed were from 13 statements and interviews published in the newspaper La Nación during 2016, given by the governor of Jujuy, Gerardo Morales, and by Argentina’s president, Mauricio Macri, as well as by official representatives and allies of their governments. We also analyzed the decrees that removed legal recognition and government funding for Tupac Amaru (Decree No. 402-G and Decree No. 403-G, promulgated in the ‘Official Diary’ of the province of Jujuy on 13 January 2016). From the analysis of the data, we identified the state as the main actor in the securitization process under study. We verified the state’s actions through an examination of: (i) the speeches of Gerardo Morales (provincial governor), Mauricio Macri (president of Argentina), and their coalition allies in their respective governments, which reinforce an image of both Sala and the Tupac Amaru organization as enemies of the population of Jujuy; and (ii) the executive decrees that criminalized the political demonstrations that were being held in front of the provincial government headquarters, which were published shortly after Morales took over the government of Jujuy province. Several international movements and organizations denounced the criminalization of Tupac Amaru activists, highlighting the arbitrary arrest of Milagro Sala. This made it difficult to legitimize the process, but did not prevent the final decision of the state apparatus. Sala was sentenced to three years for the protest conducted outside the headquarters of the Jujuy government and barred from holding a position in any social organization. After her arrest, the Argentine government constantly tried to legitimize the process. Sala was granted house arrest after the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) requested a precautionary measure for her detention (). We therefore conclude that the actions of international organizations such as the IACHR had drawn attention to the case, which made it more difficult to establish the criminalization and securitization processes. However, the house arrest was revoked less than a month after its concession, and Sala subsequently returned to regular imprisonment. In relation to the gender variable, we observe that references to danger and violence were made more frequently in relation to Sala than to the organization as a whole. The statement that ‘she was the leader of an organization that politically managed a province’ was a constant (see, for example, ). As a political leader, Sala was constructed as being manipulative, dangerous, and violent – a treatment that reinforces the view, highlighted by , that women should not be in the political space and, if they are, it is because they are not good women. For our analysis, we also draw on fieldwork carried out by : 315), who regard the actions against Tupac Amaru as an example of criminalization of ‘female activists who question entrenched racial, gender, and class inequalities in Latin America’ given the large numbers of women in leadership positions within the organization. : 316) conclude that the persecution of the Tupac Amaru movement is related to ‘the circulation of radicalized hatred in a multi-ethnic society’, and that the government’s policy is based on an alleged need to ‘save’ the poor women and men who belong to the organization. In relation to the race variable, we observed that no explicit references were made to the indigenous issue and that Sala was not enunciated as an indigenous person in any of the political discourses we analyzed. This fact highlights deracialization as a form of securitization. This process by which ‘deracialization’ is used as a way to legitimize the criminalization of socially classified groups is related to what perceive as the link between securitization and racial governmentality. As deracialization is not explicit in the speeches analyzed, we can only perceive its colonial dimensions when we approach the context – in this case, the construction of Latin America, the Argentine state and its whiteness policies. While Sala herself uses the rhetoric of race, referring to herself as black, and the organization of which she is a part has an indigenous name, the apparatus of power silences this dimension. In the Argentinian case, then, race intervenes to deracialize, to diminish the strength of the indigenous movement. Our findings thus contribute to the discussions about deracialization as an instrument of power, reinforcing the argument that Latin American ideas about miscegenation (; ) were meant to hide racism and continue to be a method of silencing black and indigenous movements. Our findings thus appear to be relevant for several discussions about deracialization as an instrument of power in Latin America (; ; ; ; ), reinforcing the idea that ‘race’ was politicized by the state for purposes of homogenization, this time based on the concept of ‘mestizaje’. Whiteness played a strategic role in the project to homogenize the Argentine nation, where the participation of immigrants from Europe was extolled, while African and indigenous influences were rendered invisible in the nation’s historical-social and cultural construction. The imaginary that the nation is ‘plural’ at the same time that European descent is magnified can even be used as a resistance strategy when socially classified groups question pre-established categories of ‘race’ (: 104–105), but it mainly reflects the invisibility of the indigenous population. The term ‘ethnocidal miscegenation’ was coined to refer to a strategy to silence the participation of indigenous and Afro-Latino populations in Latin American societies that built the idea of ‘mestizaje’. The removal of racial/ethnic identifications in official population statistics and censuses in Argentina has been verified empirically by and . Against this background, we could observe in our results what has been identified as ‘silenced racialization’ of the indigenous population, whereby speech can be racialized even if such racialization is not done formally (: 77). We also carried out an analysis of media discourse in order to assess the extent to which the securitization process had met with acceptance and been regarded as legitimate. Our analysis was centered on the newspaper La Nación, since this is a recognized source of information on Argentina and has dedicated specific sections to the case of Sala and Tupac Amaru. More than one hundred news stories from 2016 were analyzed. As in the political speeches, the threat posed by Sala and her leadership role were underlined – often appearing together, as occurred in 31 news stories. As an example, one of these reports, published four days after Sala’s arrest on 16 January 2016, states that ‘thief, gangster and threatening are three of the softest words people use to describe Milagro Sala when asked who she is’ (). The articles emphasized the organization’s ‘accumulated power’, and the idea that Tupac Amaru constituted a ‘parallel state’ in the province of Jujuy was also reiterated. We see in this a ‘coloniality of security’ () that finds danger when communities inside the state practice any degree of self-determination, causing the state to perceive self-determination and difference as a threat. Rooted in power relations, the media discourses that we analyzed play an important role in the securitization process since they articulate affective dimensions on which the social representations of Sala and the Tupac Amaru organization are built. Sala is not represented as a woman who is the leader of an ethnic organization of political and territorial resistance, but as a violent and dangerous woman who has accumulated power in the province. This establishes an affective dimension of aversion: given that a significant part of the Jujuy population identifies itself as indigenous (), the failure to identify the organization and its leaders as indigenous prevents any form of empathy from being built in relation to them. Our analysis also allowed us to perceive various discursive disputes present in the securitization process, mainly related to the fact that Sala is a woman, indigenous and a parliamentarian. The exposure by international organizations of the race and gender dynamics present in Sala’s imprisonment is constructed by the media as a defense ‘rhetoric’, as if the use of such terms represented an attempt to ‘cover up the crimes’ of Sala. Paradoxically, Sala is constantly described as a violent woman. The Tupac Amaru movement employs a strategy of acting transnationally in an attempt to ‘counter-balance’ its confrontation with the state and securitization in the domestic arena, a characteristic also seen in several other social movements in Latin America (see ; ). In other words, our analysis showed that state authorities and the media engage in a silencing of the racial and gender dimension as a way of legitimizing the criminalization of the activities of Sala and Tupac Amaru, while international organizations and the Tupac Amaru organization itself emphasize these dimensions as a form of political resistance. Race and gender thus proved to be important variables that intervened in the process by which Milagro Sala was securitized – in ways that are not immediately obvious. The case analyzed here thus reinforces our argument about the need for empirical research on how the variables of gender and race interfere in securitization processes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.