Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The international system as we know it is not governed by structure but rather by a constant chaotic process of violent statecraft, the representational production of sovereign political identities that ground themselves in gendered and sexual normativities – to rehearse the grammars of the resolution is to rehearse the grammars of our death.

Montpetit and Weber ’17 -- (Melanie Richter Montpetit and Cynthia Weber, 2017, “Queer International Relations,” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, DOI:10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.26, accessed 7-21-2022) -- nikki

State and Nation Formation How does Queer IR scholarship help us to understand state and nation formation? Like Mainstream IR scholars, Queer IR scholars study the historical rise of the modern interstate system, contemporary examples of state-building, and the politics of nationalism and national political identification practices. Like the work of Feminist and Gender scholars, Queer IR scholarship examines the role of gendered norms and identities in past and present processes of state and nation formation and thus the social construction of states, nations, and national identities. Taking these concerns further, Queer IR scholars study these in the register of sexuality. A classic argument in Queer IR on state and nation formation is V. Spike Peterson’s (1999,2013) scholarship on “nationalism as heterosexism.” Peterson’s research investigates how state and nation formation is not only socially constructed but works through ongoing processes of reproduction, resistance, and reconfiguration. Peterson’s Queer IR scholarship evidences the central role of gender and heteronormative norms and institutions in imagining or inventing nations, nationalism, and national identities. Drawing attention to how gendered and sexualized normativities fuel political identification processes and conflict, Peterson challenges state-centric conceptualizations of national groups and political identities found in Mainstream IR. Her queer analysis also challenges the implicit heterosexism underwriting much of the feminist scholarship on the fundamental role of gender identity and hegemonic masculinity for national identityconstruction. Peterson argues that early state-making processes were generative of gendered and sexualized norms and normativities, including heteropatriarchal marriage and family. In short, “making states makes sex” (Peterson, 2014A, p. 390). Peterson’s most recent work pursues these concerns through registers of intimacy in relation to heteronormativities and homonormativities (2014a, 2016). A prominent example for Queer IR scholarship that shows how state and nation formation is not a one-off occurrence but an ongoing process is the work of Cynthia Weber (1998A,1999, 2016A). Weber’s Queer IR scholarship on U.S.-Caribbean relations after the Cuban Revolution, for example, demonstrates how sovereign nation-states mobilized what she calls “queer performativities” in practice. Weber agrees with mainstream IR theorists thatmany U.S. policymakers and military officials perceived the Cuban Revolution as a crisis that jeopardized U.S. hegemony in the Caribbean region. By extending Mainstream,Feminist, and Gender analyses into the realm of Queer IR, Weber argues that this crisis of hegemony was related to two further U.S. crises—a masculinity crisis (which feminist andgender scholars identify) and a heterosexuality crisis (which Queer IR scholars identify).Weber reads key U.S. foreign policy documents and speeches to show how, contrary towhat one would expect, the United States addressed these crises of hegemony, masculinity, and heterosexuality by using what she called “queer compensatory strategies”—strategies that refigured the U.S. state in its Caribbean relations as queer(i.e., non-normative in relation to the gender and sexuality of the figural U.S. body politicthat appears in these documents) in order to appear to be hegemonically heteromasculine. Weber followed up on these classic Queer IR texts in her recent bookQueer InternationalRelations: Sovereignty, Sexuality and the Will to Knowledge, where she explains some ofthe broader domestic and international sexualized logics at work in both state and nationformation and in the organization of international politics. Through her queerreconsideration of Richard Ashley’s work on “statecraft as mancraft” (see Queer IRMethods section above), Weber explains how what she calls “queer logics of statecraft” function in domestic and international politics to create what she calls “sexualized organizations of international relations” (2016a, 2016b). Recent Queer IR scholarship on sexual justice struggles show that contestations overLGBT rights have come to constitute a key terrain of state- and nation-building and theconstruction of supranational identity—both among proponents and opponents of LGBTrights. For example, Lind and Keating’s (2013) work on postcolonial state-building in thecontext of Ecuador’s recent turn away from neoliberalism shows that in the quest tocentralize authority, the Ecuadorian state relied on a mix of state homophobia and what they call state “homoprotectionism.” Other Queer IR research on state- and nation-building argues that “the international”consists not only of states and international organizations but also non-state institutionsand queer popular culture. Catherine Baker (2016), for instance, conceptualizes theEurovision Song Contest as a popular-cultural text/event produced by a non-stateinternational actor as an important sight and site of international relations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.