The politics of the cyborg is a form of queer digital experimentation that affirms the ontological instability of queer life – we appropriate and reconstruct the technologies of modernity in order to transgress biopolitical boundaries of gender and sexuality and generate new worlds of possibility.
Haber ’16 -- (Benjamin Haber, 2016, "The Queer Ontology of Digital Method,” Women's Studies Quarterly , FALL/WINTER 2016, Vol. 44, No. 3/4, QUEER METHODS (FALL/WINTER 2016), pp. 150-169, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/44474067.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A16ac84823d870932dfbc4dad72c01232&ab_segments=0%2FSYC-6451%2Fcontrol&origin=, accessed 7-15-2022) -- nikki
For many in the field, the idea of queer method will always sound hope- lessly discordant - an awkward codification of a deliberately unstable and ontologically interdisciplinary discourse. If academic method describes a procedure, a codification of disciplinarily grounded rules, then we might imagine that queer thought would thrive mostly through provocation and deconstruction, not the building of a new canon. Indeed, to the limited extent queer method has been articulated, it has typically been to bring queer theory to method - subjecting the epistemological assumptions of fieldwork and textual analysis to critical scrutiny. While this tendency to mobilize queerness as a critical verb preserves maximum theoretical malleability while usefully complicating the assumptions of academic systemization, there is a limit to the political efficacy of queering existing methodologies. Of course there will never be a queer method, but the time has come to shift: from queering methods to experimentally using methods to more widely distribute queer politics, sociality, and sensibility. My focus here is encouraging queer digital experimentation in the practices of the everyday by appropriating, hacking, and even construct- ing networks of social, corporeal, and environmental sensors. While I'm not arguing that the built architectures of sensing and tracking data - networked, embodied devices like the Fitbit, ambient environmental sensors like Nest, or the oedipally named, versatile sensors of Mother by Sen.se - are queer, the increasingly pervasive underlying technology pro- vides possibilities for distributing a queer politics of ontological intercon- nection and indeterminacy. This sense of possibility, however, rests on an uncomfortable resonance between data capitalism and queer ontology that requires a critically engaged and reflexive methodology. Reaching into the beyond of biopolitics (Clough and Willse 2011), I look at capitalism and digital media after "the normal." As queer theo- rists continue to debate the value of critical orientations to normativity (Wiegman and Wilson 2015; Halberstam 2015), I explore the emergent postnormative, where the modulation and capitalization of bodies and populations rests less on broad cultural and technical averaging. In sug- gesting this realignment of queer attention, I do not discount the strik- ing persistence of wildly inequitable distributions of violence and death through the calcified norms of sexual, racial, classed, and otherwise corpo- really marked social violence. Rather, I hope to galvanize queer critical ca- pacity toward new forms of sociocorporeal modulation and classification and encourage experimentation with those quantitative and digital meth- ods typically dismissed or ignored by queer theorists. By foregrounding queer experimentation with digital methods, I look to balance an oppo- sitional epistemology with the more active development of "transgressed boundaries, potent fusions, and dangerous possibilities" (Haraway 1990, 154). How might we create new open-ended circuits using emergent tech- nologies to proliferate forms of relationality and bring queer notions of ontological indeterminacy and interconnection into consciousness? While the notion of using digitally processed quantitative data to pro- mote a queer indeterminacy might sound counterintuitive to some, it is a strategy that reflects the intensified biopolitical modulation that defines our age. While submitting "our" data to networks gives us free (Facebook) or subsidized (23andMe1) products, we rarely have access to these pref- erences, traces, or bodily processes. Therefore, while this networked data gets used by corporate entities to serve us ads or design our drugs, we are blocked from reimagining its social utility except in highly circumscribed conditions.2 In part, I'm advocating for queer theory to take a hard look at the quan- titative methodologies of what Nigel Thrift calls "knowing capitalism," the increasingly big business of studying and modulating the everyday (2005). Notably, the first stop of capitalisms "micro-sociological turn" (Thrift 2012, 148) is sex and relationality. Social connection is an almost unfath- omably massive enterprise, and companies like Facebook, Twitter - and a million upstarts - have a voracious appetite for difference. Its worth bald- ly stating: these are sociological companies with a narrowly instrumen- tal focus involved in not just knowing but actively modulating social life. And as I have argued elsewhere, companies like Facebook have monetized queer notions of sociality: the mutability of identity through the event and over time, the centrality of nonfamilial community in the understanding of the self, the celebration of recognition and visibility as core strategies of political engagement, and the interest in the nontextual, performative, and ephemeral (Haber 2016). Robert Payne has similarly suggested a queer modality of network culture that promotes a "multiplication and com- plication of intimate relations, the promiscuous commingling of self and other, self with self, user with interface, public with private, individual with social, and leisure with labor" (2014, 2). While these are infrastructures that many are already familiar with, more intriguing and concerning for me are still-emergent computational systems that attempt to build on the randomness-inflected development of life itself - circuitry that strives toward the complexity and plasticity of neural systems in the brain. There are even suggestions that biodigital sys- tems will increasingly try to harness the "realm of extension and thought at the inanimate level" (Parisi 2012, 45), to try, in other words, to monetize the indeterminacy and potentiality at the heart of all matter. In short, while I am arguing that queer theorists should take advantage of the indetermi- nate potential of digital networks, we must also sharpen our critical voices, as capitalism is increasingly able to profit through an alignment with queer ontologies of sociality, embodiment, and materiality. Queer method must be a witness to violence, and it must be performa- tively involved in the creation of new worlds. Knowing capitalism - much like the genealogy of queer indeterminacy I draw from - is increasingly concerned with the above and below of consciousness, the strange and monstrous assemblages that bypass our phenomenological experience of Cartesian boundaries. I draw connections between queer writing about materiality and biological systems with technoscientific investments also inspired by the indeterminacy of life and matter. I also look to blur and break down boundaries between queer and feminist theory, a split that has been hopelessly overdetermined. This is not to say that queer theory and feminist theory are the same, or that they always get along, but that there have been important crosscurrents of continuity in rejecting a determined body, subject, and form of relationality. I then highlight recent theoretical engagement with the work of Alfred North Whitehead by media scholar Mark Hansen, as perhaps offering a vision of this queer methodological potential, and I end with a discussion of the politics of queer method. With the ascendancy of a conservative LGBT agenda, including the nationalization of gender-neutral marriage law and impending changes to military rules allowing trans-identified folks to serve openly (Cooper 2016; Schaefer et al. 2016), queer ideas and queer politics have never been more needed, and methodological in- vention is key here as well. While corporate-owned social networks are solidifying their hold on the distribution of ideas, we are asked to believe assurances from Facebook s social scientists that the movement of media across their proprietary networks has more to do with "individual choice" than algorithmic predestination (Bakshy, Messing, and Adamie 2015). An active experimentation with the forms and formulas of digital media, espe- cially as it increasingly colonizes the depths of the body, is perhaps the key challenge of queer politics in the twenty-first century.