Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Our praxis takes shape in the dissonant gaps of normative international relations – the 1AC destabilizes the monolithic signification of cisheteronormativity that the resolution’s political project relies on.

Weber ’14 -- Professor of International Relations at the University of Sussex (Cynthia Weber, 2014, “From Queer to Queer IR,” Queer International Relations, International Studied Review (2014), 16, 596-622, accessed 7-21-2022) -- nikki

What is queer? Why are queer international theories relevant to international relations? What might queer investigations of international relations look like? While debates about the meaning of the term “queer” and whether or not queer can be or ought to be defined rage on (Butler 1994; Warner 2012; Wilcox, this forum), many self-identified queer scholars cite Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s description of queer as their point of departure. Sedgwick suggested that queer designates “the open mesh of possibilities, gaps, overlaps, dissonances and resonances, lapses and excesses of meaning when the constituent elements of anyone’s gender, of anyone’s sexuality aren’t made (or can’t be made) to signify monolithically” (1993:8).2 Sedgwick’s exposition of queer makes clear the affinities queer studies has to feminist studies and gender studies—with their analyses of the political work that gender, sex, and (sometimes) sexuality do—and to poststructuralist studies—with their analyses of the political work that multiple significations do. Yet queer studies is neither reducible to feminist studies, gender studies, or poststructuralist studies. Nor is it the sum total of these theoretical dispositions. As an academic practice, queer studies has been and remains, as Teresa de Lauretis described it, an attempt “to rethink the sexual in new ways, elsewhere and otherwise” in relation to but also beyond traditional Gay and Lesbian Studies, Feminist and Gender Studies, and Poststructuralist Studies (De Lauretis 1991:xvi; Rubin 1992; Butler 1990). The “elsewhere” of queer studies about which de Lauretis writes has generally functioned to locate queer international theories outside of the discipline of International Relations (IR), largely because queer has been regarded as “otherwise” to what most IR scholars have been schooled to understand as international relations theory and practice (Weber 2014a). While the advantages and disadvantages of categorizing queer international theories as “elsewhere and other-wise” to a broader body of work called IR theory are still hotly debated in the discipline (Weber 2014b), there is a growing recognition among many IR scholars that the distinction between international relations theories and queer international theories upon which such debates rely is unsustainable. This is for at least four reasons. The first reason has to do with what queer studies and queer international theories are and do. Queer studies and queer international theories primarily investigate how queer subjectivities and queer practices—the “who” and the “how” that cannot or will not be made to signify monolithically in relation to gender, sex, and/or sexuality—are disciplined, normalized, or capitalized upon by and for states, NGOs, and international corporations. And they investigate how state and nonstate practices of disciplinization, normalization, and capitalization might be critiqued and resisted (Weber 1994a,b, 1999; Duggan 2003; Puar 2007). This is precisely what Foucauldian-informed international relations scholarship does, albeit usually without an explicit focus on nonmonolithic genders, sexes, and sexualities. Second, why a focus on nonmonolithic genders, sexes, and sexualities matters for the discipline of international relations is in part because states and states’ leaders in particular have made it a focus of their domestic and foreign policies. How states, for example, answer questions about the normality or perversion of “the homosexual” and “the queer” and how these two figures are related to one another currently influences how some states make domestic and foreign policy. For example, claims made by Putin’s Russia and Museveni’s Uganda that “the homosexual” and “the queer” are perverse led each country to formulate domestic policies that were to varying degrees punished by some states and international organizations (Rao 2010, 2012, 2014; Weiss and Bosia 2013). In contrast, the Obama administration’s figuration of “the homosexual” but not “the queer” as normal led it to champion “gay rights as human rights” as part of its foreign policy (Clinton 2011), a general and specific foreign-policy position that queer scholars critique (Duggan 2003; Puar 2007, 2010; Wilkinson and Langlois 2014). Third, queer international theories explicitly engage with what many IR scholars regard as the discipline’s governing dichotomy—order versus anarchy. Among the ways the “order vs. anarchy” dichotomy functions (and, importantly, fails to function) in international relations is by articulating “order vs. anarchy” as “normal vs. perverse” and, more specifically, as “hetero/homo-normative vs. queer”—which is one of the dichotomies that queer theorists investigate and resist. When an order vs. anarchy dichotomy is constituted and sustained by a hetero/homo-normative vs. queer dichotomy in international practice (as it is in the above examples regarding Russia, Uganda, and the United States), any distinction between a general IR and a specific so-called Queer IR disappears. For investigating how these dichotomies function is (or ought to be) of central concern to both queer international theorists and IR theorists more generally. Finally, the breadth of Queer IR investigations now extends to what are arguably the three core domains in which IR scholars claim expertise—war and peace, international political economy, and state and nation formation.3 What this discussion suggests is that there is no definitive distinction between something called IR and something called Queer IR. Having said that, though, it is important not to lose site of the unique, critical difference “queer” makes— ontologically, epistemologically, and methodologically—to investigations of international relations theory and practice. Ontologically, Queer IR scholars focus on queer ontologies that do not or cannot be made to signify monolithically. These include trans*, inter, cross, and pan gendered, sexed, and sexualized bodies—be they physical, geographical, political, historical, economic, ideological, or other.4 These queerly figured bodies are often analyzed intersectionally through and in relation to figurations of race, age, ability, and class (for example, Nash 2008). Epistemologically, Queer IR scholars recognize that knowledge and ignorance in and about international relations are intricately bound up with sexual knowledge and sexual ignorance. This was Sedgwick’s general conclusion, based upon her observation that twentieth-century Western culture depends upon knowing who and/or what it means to be homosexual—because the heterosexual/homosexual dichotomy supports so many other meaningful distinctions. Sedgwick’s list of meaningful distinctions includes public/private, domestic/foreign, discipline/ terrorism, secrecy/disclosure, natural/artificial, wholeness/decadence, and knowledge/ignorance (1990:11). When critically employed, these matrices of knowing and/or not knowing allow us to reconsider not only a variety of heterosexual/homosexual dichotomies but also a variety of cis-gender/trans* dichotomies. In light of Lisa Duggan’s observations about how homonormativity functions in twenty-first-century Western culture—as “a politics that does not contest dominant heteronormative assumptions and institutions, but upholds and sustains them, while promising the possibility of a demobilized gay constituency and a privatized, depoliticized gay culture anchored in domesticity and consumption” (Duggan 2003:50; also see Duggan 2002)—contemporary Queer IR scholars recognize how various homonormative/homodeviant dichotomies increasingly are used to make sense of and to order intimate, national, and international relations. Informed by such queer epistemologies, Queer IR scholars employ methodologies that (like poststructuralist methodologies) do not seek to uncover “the truth” of sexed, gendered, and sexualized bodies, assemblages, institutions, and orders (Foucault 1979). For in what I call a queer logic of the and/or,5 such “truths” are never stable and their representation is never guaranteed; therefore, any attempt to represent them as if they were stable is understood as a political act. For this reason, Queer IR scholars instead track when queer figurations emerge and how they are normalized and/or perverted so that they might challenge but also support heterosexual, heteronormative, cis-gendered, homonormative, homophobic, and trans*phobic assumptions, orders, and institutions. The resulting “deviant knowledges” of international relations these methodologies produce can disorient Disciplinary IR knowledges not only about queer subjects (Ahmed 2006) but also about international relations subjects and the discipline of IR as a subject. What research themes and questions follow from queer understandings of international relations? I would suggest that there are at least (but not exclusively) three, often overlapping, indicative sets of research questions that Queer IR scholars have been and are generating. The first set of research themes explores how “queer” and “queering” are mobilized in international relations theory and practice. These questions often investigate how queer and queering challenge “the normalizing mechanisms of state power to name its sexual subjects: male and female, married or single, heterosexual or homosexual, natural or perverse” (Eng, Halberstam, and Munoz ~ 2005:1) in intimate, national, and international relations. This has led queer international theorists to consider: • Which figurations in/of international relations do not and cannot be made to signify monolithically in terms of gender, sex, and sexuality, and how research focused on these queer figures might make it possible to think and to do international relations differently (Weber forthcoming); • How queer(ing) nations, states, sovereignties, and empires affects international theory and practice (Weber 1998a, 1999; Peterson 1999, 2013, this forum; Agathangelou et al. 2008); • How queer(ing) the intimate relations of family and households queers the international (Peterson 2010a,b, this forum); • How queer(ing) mainstream IR theories like the “territorial peace” potentially rearticulates what the discipline of IR is and can be (Sjoberg, this forum; and more generally, see Wilcox, this forum; Nayak, this forum); and • How queer(ing) borders (Sjoberg, this forum) and movement across borders by queer subjects (Fortier 2002; Gopinath 2005; Luibheid 2005, 2008; Arondekar and Patel forthcoming) might unanchor international relations from its obsession with sovereign nation-states as its relatively fixed object of study. This first batch of themes might give the impression that the queer (and Queer IR) research questions queer(ing) generates are always transgressive and transformative. This is not the case. Indeed, to reduce queer and/or Queer IR to some heroic championing of an always already dissident figuration is to overlook how “queer” is mobilized to constitute and preserve various hegemonic imaginaries of sex, gender, and sexuality and the powerful assumptions, orders, and institutions they support. It is, therefore, vital to pose a second set of Queer IR research themes and questions that take account of how “queer” is sometimes claimed in the name of normalizing and depoliticizing understandings of sex, gender, and sexuality rather than contesting them. Research questions that explore these dimensions of queer often investigate how the nonmonolithic character of queer signification—a queer logic of “and/or”—is appropriated by hegemonic actors, alliances, and orders as a national and international strategy of governance through securitization and marketization. How, for example, do states, international alliances, international orders, and international institutions present themselves as: Simultaneously straight and/or queer, as I argue the United States (US) performs its hegemonic masculinity in relation to the Caribbean (Weber 1998a, 1999); • Simultaneously politicizing and/or depoliticizing, as Duggan’s account of how homonormativies sustain a plethora of depoliticizing neoliberal institutions and aims in the name of a selective politics of inclusion suggests (2003); • Simultaneously exceptionally tolerant and/or intolerant of LGBTQ populations, often in the form of policies that praise so-called modern states for their tolerance as a way to further abject as intolerant and intolerable so-called traditional populations, as Puar (2007), Kuntsman (2009), Schulman (2012), and Remkus Britt (forthcoming) argue supports Israeli policies of occupying Palestinian territories; • Simultaneously pro-LGBTQ and/or anti-LGBTQ, as Lind and Keating argue is the case with present-day Ecuadorian state policy (Lind and Keating 2013; Lind, this forum); • Simultaneously protective of LGBT citizenship rights and/or dangerous to these same citizens because of the specific ways LGBTQ citizens are incorporated by states, as Haritaworn, Kuntsman, and Posocco argue through their analysis of how “queer necropolitics” functions (Haritaworn, Kuntsman, and Posocco 2013b)? In so doing, these scholars have generated a range of useful concepts and ideas that enable a rethinking of specific aspects of international theory and practice, including how actors, orders, institutions, and alliances are formed through and sustained by “queer compensatory strategies” (Weber 1999), “homonormativities” (Duggan 2003), “pinkwashing” (Puar 2007), “homonationalisms” (Puar 2007), “homoprotectionism” (Lind and Keating 2013), and “murderous inclusions” (Haritaworn et al. 2013b). These analyses have also led to speculation on what kinds of “queer protest” and “queer protesters” might be the most effective in challenging conservative mobilizations of queer (Rao 2010; Duggan and Kim 2011–2012). Finally, a third set of themes and questions generated by Queer IR scholars and scholarship considers what being a Queer IR scholar and doing Queer IR scholarship does specifically in and to the discipline of international relations, especially Disciplinary IR. For example: • How do disciplinary strategies like shunning on the one hand and the “gentrification” of Queer IR research on the other give the impression that “there is no queer international theory?” (Weber 2014a,b); • As LGBTQ issues become significantly more visible in foreign policy, might it be at the discipline’s peril to erase Queer IR scholars and scholarship and to relinquish their domains of analysis to other (inter)- disciplines like Global Queer Studies? • Could acknowledgment of Queer IR scholarship broaden and deepen understandings of what Disciplinary IR claims as its three core domains of research excellence: state and nation formation, war and peace, and international political economy? • Might such analyses generate a novel range of theoretical insights that are primarily informed by both queer theory and international relations theory, particularly because both of these theoretical perspectives have so much to say about (in)securities? • If so, should Queer IR scholars enter into a proper institutional alliance with Disciplinary IR—into a “gay marriage” of sorts—with (in) security functioning as their axis of sameness/similarity? • Would this “queer the discipline of IR”? Is “queering the discipline of IR” possible? Or would the discipline of IR never accept a theory that “elevates perversion to philosophy”?6 As this discussion suggests, queer theorizations of international relations exist, they are relevant to core international relations questions and topics, and they have long been generating robust international relations research programs. The contributions to this forum evidence and further these research programs, making clear the critical difference queer can make for international theorizing.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.