Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Debate is a site of social formation – we retool the pedagogical processes of this space in service of reparative queer kinship that forms enduring bonds of solidarity and care within an environment of paranoid antagonism.

Ensor 17 (Sarah Ensor, English Language and Literature, Ecocriticism, gender and sexuality, JUNE 01 2017, “Relative Strangers: Contracting Kinship in the Queer Ecology Classroom,” https://read.dukeupress.edu/american-literature/article-abstract/89/2/279/5184/Relative-Strangers-Contracting-Kinship-in-the?redirectedFrom=fulltext; accessed 1/5/2022) ng

If this model of contracting kinship requires acknowledging our corporeal vulnerability, then it seems necessary to acknowledge, too, that this year in particular (2016) has made us viscerally aware of bodies at risk. Among the many sources of exposure that we continue to face is the changing climate of higher education, whose current condition makes it easy to believe that optimism in (or, indeed, about) academia is naive at best and actively harmful at worst. But within an environment that fosters paranoia, pedagogical kinship may not only become legible through a reparative reading practice but also may be a powerfully reparative social formation. For such a model enables a form of care that is embodied and improvisational, responsive to and inspired by the way in which vulnerability and community, contingency and possibility (for teachers and students, as for matsutake21) so often are intertwined. Although administrations increasingly hope that teachers’ and students’ relationships to the university—and to each other—will be contractual, the fact remains that our contracting takes place not only in the legal but also in the bodily sense. As opposed to being a means of institutionalization—of the standardization of relationships, the reproduction of existing values (and forms of privilege),22 and the kind of conservative resemblance among past, present, and future that often characterizes both kinship structures and higher education—this model of pedagogy is characterized by provisionality, surprise, and spread. The classroom exceeds the increasingly corporatized institution at the same time that it is housed within (and inseparable from) it, calling to mind the subtly spatial logic of reparative reading. Pedagogical modes of kinship thus come to resemble the “plethora of only loosely related weak theories,” brimming with “tenderness, wit, inventive reading, obiter dicta, and writerly panache,” that, in Sedgwick’s (2003, 136, my emphasis) account, are “invited to shelter” within the strong paranoid theory of a book like D. A. Miller’s The Novel and the Police. Indeed, as Sedgwick repeatedly insists, the reparative posture (with its forms of care) is structurally inseparable both from paranoia itself and from the Kleinian depressive position—and thus is responsive to, not avoidant of, fear and harm. But “its fear, a realistic one, is that the culture surrounding it is inadequate or inimical to its nurture”; as a result, “it wants to assemble and confer plenitude to an object that will then have resources to offer to an inchoate self” (149, my emphasis). The ethical possibility of caring for others “is founded on and coextensive with the . . . very often fragile concern to provide the self with pleasure and nourishment in an environment that is perceived as not particularly offering them” (137). Perhaps an institution such as mine is precisely the proper site for such an experiment in care. Unlike on traditional campuses, where students more often than not are following an expected trajectory (high school to college to employment), my students already have considerable experience with the “deroutinized temporality” (and openness to surprise) that Sedgwick (148) deems foundational to the reparative gesture. And unlike on traditional campuses, where students in any given classroom find themselves already sharing considerable common ground—from age range to family background, from spirit for the school’s football team to fraternity affiliation—my students are strangers to each other in a much more fundamental way. They are veterans of Desert Storm, Iraq, and Afghanistan, who sit facing the door to preclude being startled and who miss class for appointments at the VA Hospital. They are parents and grandparents who put younger generations through school before deciding to return themselves. They are twenty- and thirty-somethings who are being priced out of their hometown, for whom our city’s rapid gentrification and booming housing market are not fodder for abstract debate but rather embodied realities lived on a daily basis. They are adults who have had entire careers as reporters, social workers, and administrative assistants, who have found themselves on our campus after losing their jobs or deciding to change course. For those who are closer to traditional college age, my institution is hardly ever their first stop. Graduates of community colleges or students whose initial foray into higher education ended in abandonment of one form or another, they have found their way to our campus in the wake of other experiences of learning, often ones that did not lead where they planned. Like Sedgwick, they have long been “attune[d] . . . to a heartbeat of contingency” (147). Like Tsing’s subjects, they inhabit “salvage rhythms” (2015, 132). As with my pedagogy, their paths have already gone astray. Ultimately, their status as college students does not indicate any kind of elite escapism from the world’s patterns of circulation but rather a different mode of participating in—and being affected by—them.23 When such students (and I) become kin, then, the result is neither flat likeness nor any kind of codified bond. The aim is not for those who find themselves in my class to choose each other as lifelong friends (although sometimes they do) or for our kinship to be an institution that rivals (or even provides an alternative to) the broader university that houses us. Instead, we respond to the ongoing damage of the past and the emerging damage of the present with immanent gestures of community that help us move together, uncertainly, toward uncertain futures. Our kinship—like the reparative posture—fosters a “position from which it is possible . . . to use one’s own resources to assemble or ‘repair’ the murderous part-objects into something like a whole—though . . . not necessarily like any preexisting whole” (Sedgwick 2003, 128). Invested in hope without naïveté, in a mode of repairing that is not the same as healing or absolving, such practices evince care precisely in the absence of durability and optimism precisely in the absence of guarantees. In improvisational, unpredictable, and steadfastly material ways, through our own local practices and “nonce taxonomies” (145), we seek to make things better not only for each other but also for the community that accrues at the thresholds of our urban university’s porous bounds. We reckon with the ways in which higher education has abandoned us without ourselves abandoning it. Eventually, however, we do walk away from the classroom, a fact that might foreground the interplay of provisionality and endurance in this model of care. For the resulting marks—the imprint—may be permanent even if the relationships themselves are not enacted again in the future (and perhaps cannot be replicated outside the social milieu of the classroom). As the texts on our syllabus reminded us, fleeting interactions can have enduring effects. For instance, Dean, writing about the forms of consanguineous kinship developed via (voluntary) infection with HIV, insists that the encounters responsible for transmission queerly resemble marriage, insofar as they involve a lifelong commitment (to one’s own body, if not to the often-multiply anonymous body that infects one). These encounters, then, are “as far from casual . . . as one can get” (Dean 2009, 85); consequence endures even if relationality does not. In direct contrast to the line from a fictional song that comprises the title of Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel, I must always let my students go. And in letting them go, I trust that in some way, shape, or form our kinship will persist, that the material we shared (both in the sense of our readings and discussions, and in the sense of our resultant consubstantiality) will continue to matter. As in Weston’s (2001, 161) analysis of Youngblood’s transfusions, “These are not solidarities that endure but solidarities that allow people to endure.” My students and I—like all good kin—help each other to endure, in the sense of “to undergo without succumbing.”24 As with any emergent ecology, our kinship—“fugitive” (Tsing 2015, 255), “elusive” (282), “effervescen[t]” (255), “ephemeral” (255)—does not itself solve the problems that have brought us to this point, nor does it offer us a predictable program to follow in the face of the future’s uncertainties. (Needless to say, “kinship” is not now listed among the learning outcomes I am required to include on my syllabus.) However, like the “tiny actions” that, in Kirksey’s (Kirksey, Shapiro, and Brodine 2014, 49) account, have “the potential . . . to make the world a more livable place,” like Berrigan’s (2014, 169) experiment in contagion, which is “genuine in its reach toward empathy and self-care” even if its “intervention is inevitably deficient,” and like the interspecies assemblages that remind Tsing (2015, 282) that while it is “not easy to know how to make a life [within the ruin], much less avert planetary destruction,” “luckily there is still company, human and nonhuman,” this social formation limns the extant presence of alternatives both within the sanitized, corporatized university and to the habits of thought that so often keep us from reading higher education otherwise. By attending to such relational possibilities within the troubled ecology of higher education, we might catch “the scent of the latent commons” (282)—one thing, it seems, that reparative queer pedagogy can pleasurably and ethically track.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.