4 -- Linear Education DA -- Modern day education functions along linear logic – the construction and formation of subjects in certain ways after time. Our argument is that these forms of linearity are exactly what is used to create “docility” from queer subjects, forcing them into discreet indentitarian formations through the process of chrononormativity.
Kim ’17 Kim, Jainey Jung Yeon, "Picturing Queer Death: Alternative Instantiations of Temporality within Process Art." Thesis, Georgia State University, 2017. KZaidi
What, then, is Time? I know well enough what it is, provided that nobody asks me; but if I am asked what it is and try to explain, I am baffled.7
In his series of lectures titled “Birth of Biopolitics,” Foucault formulates the idea that the delimitation between state and society marks the turn from liberalism into neoliberalism. Neoliberalism, as Foucault defines it, is a political rationality that merges the social sphere with the economic sphere as a means to reduce state services and shift the language of responsibility and morality onto the individual subject body. Within neoliberalism, there is a shift in governmentality and social regulation “in the sense that subjects are increasingly conceived and conceive themselves as entrepreneurs of the self, who attempt to maximize their human capital.”8 As Thomas Lemke goes on to explain:
The neoliberal forms of government feature not only direct intervention by means of empowered and specialized state apparatuses, but also characteristically develop indirect techniques for leading and controlling individuals without at the same time being responsible for them. The strategy of rendering individual subjects "responsible" (and also collectives, such as families associations, etc.) entails shifting the responsibility for social risks such as illness, unemployment, poverty, etc. and for life in society into the domain for which the individual is responsible ... The key feature of the neoliberal rationality is the congruence it endeavors to achieve between a responsible and moral individual and an economic-rational individual. It aspires to construct responsible subjects whose moral quality is based on the fact that they rationally assess the costs and benefits of a certain act as opposed to other alternative acts.9
This “neoliberal rationality” roots itself through different regimes of truth, the types of discourse that get accepted as truth and established as hegemonic within the system in power. For example, in neoliberalism the language of morality becomes ascribed onto economic responsibility, and the neoliberal subject replaces the regulatory mechanisms of the state as a self-regulating subject, or human capital, of the free market. Therefore, neoliberalism becomes a determining factor in the societal and governmental response to AIDS in the form of what Leo Bersani calls “malignant aversion,” in which the funding for research and treatment for AIDS was delayed, a push was made towards testing rather than curing, and policies were made that had more to do with protecting straight communities from being penetrated rather than with saving queer communities. More specifically, in response to AIDS, “a public health crisis [was] treated like an unprecedented sexual threat” brought on by the queer body and its inability to police and regulate its own desires, and there was a “general tendency to think of AIDS as an epidemic of the future rather than a catastrophe of the present.”10 Therefore, during the AIDS epidemic, queer bodies within the neoliberal system became synonymous with death caused by an individual moral failure and sexual threat.
I engage with the term chronobiopolitics from a Foucauldian perspective in which we understand neoliberalism to be a configuration of power relations that is not only an intensification of capitalism and capitalist exploitation of bodies, but also a system that creates biopolitical regimes of truth11 that establish social practices necessary for the sustainment of neoliberalism as absolute. In this thesis, I situate linear temporality and chrononormativity as one such example of a regime of truth that neoliberalism asserts on the queer body with AIDS in order to regulate the individual subject body. Elizabeth Freeman describes this regulatory structure of temporality as such:
Naked flesh is bound into socially meaningful embodiment through temporal regulation: binding is what turns mere existence into a form of mastery in a process I’ll refer to as chrononormativity, or the use of time to organize individual human bodies toward maximum productivity. And I mean that people are bound to one another, engrouped, made to feel coherently collective, through particular orchestrations of time: Dana Luciano has termed this chronobiopolitics, or “the sexual arrangement of the time of life” of entire populations.12
The heteronormative structuring of social reality works under this very assumption of a chrononormativity that is linear and progressive, in which milestone markers of individual development—grade school graduation, college, career development and advancement, creating a nuclear family—are enforced and adhered to properly. The failure to adhere to this chrononormative timeline is seen as a failure to produce and mature into a moral, responsible member of society. Particularly in regards to productivity and the individual responsibility to maximize one’s own “human capital,” time becomes synonymous with money, and every minute becomes a commodity that must be capitalized on. Linear time becomes central to the organization and the maintenance of the commercial structure of society: hourly wages, monthly rent, time-interest rates, and built credit over time—things that visibly queer bodies of the late twentieth century did not often get access to.