1 -- The negative’s call to predictable activist strategies is a thinly veiled move to institutional cooption – unpredictable modes of symbiotic relationality are key to effective strategies of queer resistance.
Demir ’20 -- (Aylime Aslı Demir, 2020, “Unpredictable Activism in Times of Uncertainty,” Museum International, 72:3-4, 178-187, DOI: 10.1080/13500775.2020.1873515, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki
Following an attempted military coup in Turkey on 15 July, 2016, a country that was already being governed under a state of emergency witnessed, through decree laws, the closure of pro-democratic NGO publications, detentions, arrests, and the narrowing of permitted public spaces. Thousands of academics and tens of thousands of public employees were dismissed, while hundreds of association-based publications were shut down. The members of the association Academics for Peace were fired from their positions without first being prosecuted, and the presumption of their innocence was ignored. Meanwhile, courses and theses on critical theory, feminism, gender, LGBTQI+ and queer studies were suddenly removed from university syllabi. Most academic research on gender, LGBTQI+ and queer studies was disrupted, and with the dismissal of academics who served as a bridge between academy and activism, social movements’ sphere of influence shrank even more. After all these losses, it can be said that social opposition constituents were subjected to a collective trauma. Hundreds of people lost their lives, and thousands of opponents, journalists, human rights activists were denied their freedom, detained and arrested. Moreover, the ability to imagine a future democratic life was shattered. Ultimately, LGBTQI+ activities were indefinitely banned in Turkey in November 2017 so as to include the whole of Ankara and the Istanbul Beyoğlu district—which are also the heart of LGBTQI+ activities, actions, and life. The governorship listed ‘social sensitivities and sensibilities’, ‘public security’, the ‘protection of public health and morality’ and the ‘protection of others’ rights and liberties’ as motivations for the ban on LGBTI+ activities. In announcing its decision, the government released the following statements, republished in English on the Kaos GL website: We were informed through various social media and several printed and visual media organs that several movie, cinevision, theatre, panel, interview, exhibition etc. events including several social sensibilities and sensitivities will be organized in various locations of our city by various non-governmental organizations in the name LGBTT (Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual, transvestite) and LGBTI (Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex). This situation was evaluated as that social media shares at stake may provoke one section of public with different social class, race, religion, sect and regional features to show hatred and animosity in the disadvantage of other section, therefore clear and imminent danger towards public safety may arise; also, considering that this may jeopardize public order, prevention of crime, protection of public health and morality, and protection of rights and liberties of others; as a result of several social sensibilities there may occur provocations and reactions by several sections towards groups and individuals who want to attend intended event. (Kaos GL 2017b) Just as Kaos GL Association had organised the Future Queer exhibition in order to launch a new public platform and space—one designed to create breathing room following the 2015 bombings—the organisation decided to stage innovative performance and unpredictable tactics in 2016, following the military coup attempt and after an ISIS plot to target the Kaos GL association’s offices was revealed. These new tactics had to be unpredictable, because the government was already aware of almost every tool of traditional activism. It had assimilated these tools and emptied all of the concepts that were meaningful for activists’ struggle. For instance, cases that were opened against those who encouraged attacks against LGBTQI+ people were dismissed by concluding that the perpetrators had exercised their right to freedom of speech, and that the state was obliged to protect the people’s right to freedom of speech, lest the police would be asked to respond to every call in which the word LGBTI was pronounced. Between 2017 and 2018, Kaos GL organised its second contemporary art exhibition, entitled Colony4 within the borders of the Fatih Municipality, in Sultan Ahmet Square. They chose it precisely because it is situated within one of the most conservative regions of Istanbul, and since there was no ban on LGBTQI+ events in the area. Without specifically naming the organiser or using terms such as ‘LGBTI’ in literature and without making any announcements in Kaos GL publications, Colony spread through word-of-mouth and earto-ear as much as silently, developing into a space of 4,000 square meters and an event that included some thousand voices (Fig. 4). In the age of the Anthropocene, in which humans themselves have been revealed as a geological force, and amid a climate of terrible uncertainty and fear which is created by unmanned air vehicles and suicide bombers, Colony set out to explore the possibilities of symbiosis, associations and interspecies relationships between humans and non-humans— even if the desire of bio-genetic studies is to create the ‘perfect’ human. The exhibition bulletin reads as follows: Fostered by the globally immediate socio-political juncture, artistic production, and academic discourse, Colony brings the definition of ‘human’ into question. Engaging critically with the means of making knowledge, science, technology, and politics, the exhibition questions that which privileges the human species by attributing a prioritised conception of existence to mankind. Through the agency of intimating a body and bodybeings, Colony gathers together artistic inquiries that reconsider constructed dichotomies such as human/nonhuman, nature/culture, and organic/ synthetic. Across moralism(s) and between female-male morphologies fixed in procreation, Colony explores the constitutive ways in which nature’s sanctions of normativity operate. Interfaced with discussions around language and gender, the exhibition probes for contemporary (collective) bearings that evade self-constituted, human-centered narratives derived from the alliance of culture-historysociety-power. Through the scope of post-human and queer critique kinship, colony embodies a range of perspectives that discuss these critical narratives.’ (Colony exhibition bulletin 2017) In the Turkish landscape, institutional support for artists is rare. Accordingly, following this exhibition, Kaos GL founded the Ankara Queer Art Programme, considering processes of artistic production in order to expand the limited opportunities for organising exhibitions and make such initiatives sustainable. The International Guest Artist House provides residencies for artists to work and live in Ankara for two months at a time, and supports their research and artistic projects. Today, while international travel remains risky due to the pandemic, the programme is continuing to offer financial support to artists and manages its consulting work online. Doing uncertain politics Over the past few years, we have witnessed countries that invented globalisation begin to adopt antiglobalisation policies, as right-wing, populist and nationalist politics gained momentum. But the walls that states have built up in order to protect themselves from immigration or free trade do not protect them against the climate crisis or from terror. When bombs started to arbitrarily explode in the streets of Ankara, the city was shocked by the knowledge that the victims were completely random, and shaken by the thought that anyone might become the victim of a terror act anytime, anyplace. Those in the crowds who wore thicker clothes than the seasonal norms, or those who ran away were not protected from the bombs; similarly, individual measures taken against the unpredictability that Covid-19 has created do not confer total protection from the disease. The state of not knowing what will happen no matter what one does has a horrific tendency to pacify individuals, who are paralysed with worry. Since the government knows by heart the current tools and probable moves of the resistance, we need to devise different tactics and exit the current ‘cat and mouse’ game. To respond to a government who desires to monopolise the power of creating uncertainty through governing that uncertainty, queer activism might represent a way of doing uncertain politics: one that offers the quickest and most effective responses against oppression. For instance, when officials told LGBTQI+ activists ‘you can’t gather in Istanbul’, we transformed numerous streets into spaces of action, effectively saying ‘Well then, we will spread out across the city’. When they said ‘You cannot walk beyond the barricade’ in İzmir, we responded by running back from the barricade. When they said ‘You cannot gather to protest in the streets’ we transformed the sea into a space of action and activism by taking a ferry. My sense is that we can find some inspiration in such a movement with regards to unpredictability. Traces of this form of activism can be observed in the work of one of the artists featured in the Colony exhibition (Abud Efendi Mansion, 2017-2018), Kerem Ozan Bayraktar. His video, entitled ‘Mimicry’, focuses on the ‘machineplant’ relationship (Fig. 5). The work, presenting footage from an orchid factory, reads the relationship between machines and plants as a symbiotic one. As in the biological evolutionary processes through which the cultivated orchids had been attracting bees in order to ensure their reproduction, within this contemporary factory setting, orchids ‘attract’ the machinery, namely the technological processes designed by human beings. This type of relationality negates the common assumption that the species that can sustain their existence through the evolutionary process are the fittest ones; since the orchids most capable of adapting to and cooperating with other species are constantly evolving and adapting enhance their survival capabilities through enabling the machines that are integral to their life cycles. Of course, the history of social movements can give us an idea of who our possible future alliances will be. However, if we see the basis of activism as affirmation of life, these alliances can change with every new situation encountered, like an orchid’s relationship to a machine. Else, the organic and inorganic world, as well as the history of activism, can seduce the survival strategies expected from our identities.