3 -- [EXTRA] The negative’s imposition of certainty is a technology of fascism that enables the exertion of interpersonal control as a proxy mechanism for dealing with the inherent unpredictability of the world – unpredictability is a radical delegitimation of state power.
Demir ’20 -- (Aylime Aslı Demir, 2020, “Unpredictable Activism in Times of Uncertainty,” Museum International, 72:3-4, 178-187, DOI: 10.1080/13500775.2020.1873515, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki
This article explores the political and artistic potential of ‘unpredictable’ forms of activism: ones specifically devised in response to attacks on the Turkish LGBTQI+ movement by right-wing populists within the AKP government led by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, especially since 2015. Reflecting on the 2019 Conference in Marseilles at MUCEM—La Méditerranée du genre, de la résistance et des stratégies (The Mediterranean of Gender, Resistance and Strategies)—which spurred me to write the present article, it strikes me that at the time of that event, the world had not yet been tested with Covid-19. Although the growing spectre of the global climate crisis had already generated a significant sense of uncertainty and insecurity, we were still unfamiliar with the experience of our ‘safe’ realities and norms being swiftly swept away. We could not yet conceive of a reality in which we would not be able to hold the hand of our beloved at a funeral; or of the fact that our health insurance would not protect us amid hospitals full to capacity. Since the global pandemic swept the world, we have experienced the (co)dependency of our bodies with a sense of horror—representing, for the first time in modern history perhaps, such a globally reaching experience of radical uncertainty. Against all promises to the contrary, we are witnessing, in the time of Covid, how international bodies, states and institutions—no matter how ostensibly prepared they had been—cannot fulfil their responsibilities in protecting the public (or in certain cases prefer not to). At a moment when we are confronted with radical uncertainty, we are simultaneously facing the fact that we often have little choice but to act individually against collective risks. These individual actions include washing every surface or object you may touch with disinfectants, covering your face with masks even though public health authorities release contradictory and shifting statements around their protective capacities, or regretting your lack of good health insurance coverage and the precarious position it puts you in if you do get ill. From time to time, we become ‘good citizens’ who demand the harshest penalties for those who do not wear masks or disobey the rules of lockdown; or we establish a sense of personal ‘security’ by refusing access to our residential buildings for those who do not have the privileged position to stay at home, such as delivery people, service personnel and health workers—temporarily exerting a sense of control over our environment. In short, even for overprivileged individuals with excellent healthcare coverage, protected residences shielded from the outside world, and the ability to stay safe at home during a pandemic, all of us are confronted with radical unpredictability and incalculable risk in this age of Anthropocene. Moreover, with the challenges posed by neoliberalism—specifically the 2008 financial crisis and the Syrian War, which both sent reverberations around the world— right-wing populism has gained significant influence and political ground. As a way of doing politics, right-wing populism is noteworthy for its hybridity and adoption of uncertainty as a form of governing. It is hybrid because there is little consistency between the right-wing populist, charismatic leaders currently heading several countries around the globe—from Orbán to Bolsonaro and Trump—and the economic, political, judicial, scientific, philosophical, religious, moral and aesthetic ideologies and policies they represent and promote. For instance, while liberal values are adopted in some economic decisions, social rights might be accompanied by conservatism, pro-immigration policies by nationalism (and from time to time, even fascism). What is significant here is that while this ideological hybridity is not perceived as a negative trait by populist governments, which arguably thrive on inconsistency, it has an unpredictable power over citizens, because we do not know how such leaders will behave nor what they will do next. In The Anthropology of the State, Marc Abélès (2012) suggests that in order to legitimise political power under the law of reason, classical political philosophy differentiates between two conditions, natural and civic: On the one hand, there is a natural condition in which individuals are left to their own devices and this leads to an anarchical positioning. On the other hand, there is a civic condition emanating from the contract. In a literal sense, a political bond occurs only in the latter. Also, what conditions the existence and pérennité of the political bond is represented with its dual qualification in the forms of bringing together and empowerment. (p. 20) Thus, in order to remove the difficulties people face living in a lawless environment in which chaos dominates, the state will claim to bring fair, universal social solutions, which will determine the grounds of its legitimate power. Of course, this duality has been questioned in many instances and respects. For example, it can be said that the central objective of much research in political anthropology is to question this dichotomy established between the state and what supposedly existed prior to its formation. However, in the contemporary and neoliberal era, this duality has been blurred by the state itself, which instead opts for a mode of governing that fosters deep uncertainty. Even within the social sciences, the dualities generated by modern states, which are also legal entities, can be described in these terms: normal and abnormal, legal and illegal, permitted and unpermitted, public and private, etc. We witness how the lines between them change place arbitrarily, or become uncertain through government policy. Thus, when the distinction between what determines ‘normal’ and ‘outside of the norm’ suddenly become meaningless, not only are the laws of science that indicate the norm—which we can think of as something that repeats itself, or as rules—suspended, but so is the logic of law, on which states and governments are based. While the Enlightenment and its heritage has served as a common reference point for centuries, its notion of human rights is annihilated when the law itself is used as a tool for human rights violations.