Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1 -- Relational deconstruction DA – the perm solves best – including methodologies of queer social deconstruction enables a reenvisioning of class struggle through the lens of capitalism as a subjective construction rather than a preexisting formation and reshapes collectivity through the embrace of difference – prerequisite to effective resistance.

Green ’06 -- Doctoral Student in Sociology at the University of British Columbia (Brian Green, 09-05-2006, “The currency of queer theory for class analysis: remarx on subjectivities, class struggle, and subversion,” Rethinking Marxism: A Journal of Economics, Culture & Society, 14:4, 139-144, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

In the last decade, a powerful voice has emerged in social theory from its origins in cultural studies and discourse analysis. Loosely gathered under the label queer theory, this body of work has introduced substantial challenges not only to the heteronormativity of most social theory but also to the ways feminism, gay and lesbian studies, and analyses of inequality in general, have implicitly reproduced essentialist notions of identity and consciousness, thus constructed limits to their own subversive potential. Queer theory is less a homogeneous, coherent school of thought than a dialogue across disciplines that seeks to multiply the questions asked by social analysis. Emerging from more general trends toward deconstruction associated with poststructuralist thought, it takes as its starting point the social construction of apparently fixed identities, the reliance of such identities on presumed binary oppositions of difference which inhere in them, and the always unstable, always partial hegemonies of ‘the normal’ in real human life. In Seidman’s words “identities are always multiple or at best composites, with an infinite number of ways in which “identity components” . . . can intersect or combine. Any specific identity construction, moreover, is arbitrary, unstable, and exclusionary” (Seidman 1994, 173). Not only do constructions of identity always entail constructions of their opposite but, because those opposites are ideal-typical poles, they also produce unintended gaps on the continuum between them. And it is not so much in the recognition or affirmation of the ‘Other’ as here, on the multiple and shifting terrain between identities (i.e., the in-betweens of gender, race, and sexuality), that the potential lies for subverting essentialism altogether (Butler 1990; Seidman 1994, 173). This, then, is also where the importance of queer theory lies—not so much in the particulars of its diverse analyses of discourse, culture, theory, or law, but in its insistence upon the subversion of apparently dichotomous relationships rather than simply their inversion or recognition (Namaste 1994, 230). Such an analytic focus has significant implications for our understanding of, and political engagement with, relations of domination and resistance, including class relations. In fact, I would suggest that queer theory does for our understanding of identity struggle what Marx did for our understanding of economic struggle— historicizing its assumptions, identifying its subversions, articulating its alwaysalready existing potentials. And in doing these, it provides an opportunity to engage the relations of capital and class not as a set of immediately conquerable institutions but as a complex of ongoing relationships which is continually challenged, reconfigured and reinforced through the daily interactions of individuals and collectives (Namaste 1994, 224). How it does this, and the implications of that strategy for political class struggle, can be seen in the questions queer theory asks of more traditional approaches to gender inequality and heteronormativity, and the alternative political approaches those questions engender. Building on its roots in poststructuralism, queer theory interrogates not only the marginalized Others of social norms, but the dynamic and ever-shifting relationship between the poles; that is, rather than emphasizing the invisibility of women in patriarchy or of gays and lesbians in heteronormativity, the role those Others play is examined as always-already interior to the normal (Namaste 1994, 222). This is much more than a philosophical or discursive exercise, as too many Marxists are quick to assert—stressing the relational puts front and center the questions of interaction, of contestation, and of resistance. It implies that the binarisms upon which so much of identity is constructed cannot be preexisting, that neither pole in a dichotomy can be primary or natural, and that the formation, location, and interaction of such ‘opposites’ are the very substance of their continued reproduction. And if that is the case, resistance and alternatives become that much easier to locate as well, for three reasons: the recognition of identity as plural opens space for subversion, which can potentially include distinct and even apparently antagonistic groups; the emphasis on constructedness reveals that so-called normative identities (i.e., white, heterosexual, middle class) are no less unstable and partial than marginal ones, despite the significant privilege attached to them; and antagonism can never be rooted in immutable characteristics but must always and everywhere be located in existing relationships and the political strategies people employ to negotiate and renegotiate those relationships (Namaste 1994, 225). All this puts queer theory in marked contrast to more traditional approaches to social inequality, even those which sought radical political change. For example, previous theories of feminist and sexual liberation often tended to reproduce rather than subvert essentialism and binarism by opposing a unitary, victimized subject to a hegemonic norm, whether defined as male, heterosexual, or both. This can be seen in a wide range of politically motivated, even ‘revolutionary’ work, from radical feminism’s celebration of womanhood and privileging of lesbianism, and Dworkin and MacKinnon’s construction of an all-encompassing, inherently oppressive male sexuality, to Kristeva and Wittig’s searches for origins and even Wilkinson and Kitzinger’s arguments for political and identitarian unity in gay liberation struggles (Butler 1990; Bell 1994; Ingraham 1994, 213–5; Seidman 1994, 170; Wilkinson and Kitzinger 1994). In each case, patriarchy and heterosexuality remain constructed as universal and as intact; even where their naturally occurring status is called into question, they are seen as constructed upon real biological difference or imperative. Thus the hegemony of heterogender (Ingraham 1994, 204) is taken as a preexisting fact, rather than a recurrent tension, and the only possibilities for resistance are formal equality within existing parameters or inversion (but continued maintenance) of the hierarchy. By critiquing the tendency of much feminist and gay liberationist work to reproduce binarism, queer theory attempts to accomplish a rethinking akin to that brought about by postcolonial and black feminist thought in regard to assumed norms of whiteness—to promote a politically meaningful solidarity not on the basis of inherent sameness, but of constructed difference, not on the assumption of permanent, fixed identities but on fluid, partial, and contingent notions of selfhood and alliance which acknowledge multiple, intersecting relationships.1 Such a perspective may at first glance appear contradictory to the formation of political class solidarity in that it deemphasizes points of commonality, but on deeper examination, what appears is not a rejection of solidarity but a different conception of it. The point of commonality is not a universal sameness of oppression, not an unbesmirched essence buried beneath learned behavior, but the fact that we all share the experience of living with hierarchy-based identities, that we all experience only partial and unstable adjustment to identitarian regulations, albeit in different and even contradictory ways (see, for example, Wright 1997), and that all identities are at best incomplete, complex, and transitory. The resultant solidarity, then, is not one of a taken-for-granted unity or a presumed shared utopia, but rather a strategic solidarity which sees the sexual/ gender/race/class landscape itself, rather than any one, identifiable position on that landscape, as the common enemy. This, in turn, opens space for a plurality of resistances which can be seen not as competing but as mutually supporting, and provides for the possibility of alliance across sectoral divides. All this presupposes a very different approach to political struggle than we have been accustomed to. The broadly defined Left—be it feminist, Marxist, gay libera tionist, or nationalist—has tended to ground its political strategies and end goals in terms of an easily identifiable opponent: the class war rages between capitalists and workers; the feminist struggle between men and women; the sexual liberation struggle between straights and gays and lesbians; the antiracist struggle between racists and nonracists, as though real human relationships ever correspond neatly to such idealtypical poles. And while such oppositional organizing offered a means of establishing political community and articulating the value of alternative knowledges and alternative ways of living, in each case what was taken for the enemy was an embodied product of the system rather than the relational system itself.2 That is, the relation capital produces capitalists and workers, as though these were ahistoric, unchanging and easily identified categories; the gender system produces men and women, as though individuals were a necessarily wholly or permanently one or the other; the racialization process produces whites and blacks, as though these were somehow natural and timeless categories, rather than shorthand for a vast and ever growing range of miscegenations and racial and cultural identities. In each case, however, these presumed dichotomies are, in real human relationships, only-ever partial, can only be defined contextually, and are subject to constant redefinition. What needs to be analyzed and targeted politically, then, is not the individuals associated with various positions within such relational systems, but the systems themselves. Individuals are socially located not due to any essential characteristic which inheres to them, but due to their positioning within relationships and their roles in either reinforcing or subverting relations of domination. Rather than a retreat from conflict, then, the emphasis on relationships and systems helps to focus the object of struggle more clearly, to engage class, gender, heteronormativity, and racialization as processes of social reproduction rather than always-already existing states of being. What is more, it can accomplish these without either denying identity’s political relevance, as so many Marxists tend to do, or obscuring the play of structure, of material life, of laboring practices in seemingly ‘nonclass’ struggles, as is too often common in poststructuralist analyses. The emphasis on process and relationship is particularly well articulated by Judith Butler, for whom the starting point of analysis is a Nietzschean distinction between ‘doer’ and ‘deed’. This acknowledgement that identities and institutions are products of social interaction rather than preexisting states requires that we maintain an analytic and political focus on the ways that social relationships are produced and reproduced, on how they are constituted through their ongoing performance; “there need not be a ‘doer behind the deed’, but . . . the ‘doer’ is invariably constructed in and through the deed” (Butler 1990, 142). It is human action and interaction which is primary; thus, the political field is made more open to the subversion of normalcy and the multiplication of alternative potentials. Thus, while the political usefulness of Butler’s own work is limited by its focus on discursive production and individual interaction to the exclu sion of class struggles and laboring practices (Hennessy 1996, 225–8), her presentation of the problem has important implications for materialist, class-oriented analyses.3 Indeed, what are material institutions but the long-term and presumed-immutable outcomes of a previous relationships? What are ‘structural barriers’ but the concrete material implications of ‘doing’ or ‘performing’ social life according to culturally, politically, economically, militarily enforced rules of interaction? Thus it is here that we come to the concrete, political significance of queer theory for class struggles and for alternative ways of living: the queer theory approach provides an alternative set of questions which emphasize not only individuals in social relationships, but the production and reproduction of those relationships themselves, and the always existing gaps and breaks in social systems. When articulated with reference to concrete, material outcomes of relationships, queer theory emphasizes the production of alternative alliances and strategies which engage the reproduction of inequality as social process rather than as hegemonic entity, and provokes a political strategy in which liberation is not something ‘found’, but is achieved through ongoing processes of struggle, of solidarity in difference, and of relationship building. Queer theory, then, is not only or even primarily about understanding sexual diversity, but represents a significantly different approach to political analysis, and one which holds enormous potential for class analysts and class movements which seek an alternative to the legacy of Second and Third International Marxist-Leninist orthodoxies. It is an alternative way of thinking about social relationships which emphasizes process rather than product, subversive potential rather than end goal. Its implications for class analysis and political class struggle are to be found in the way it constructs domination and resistance as dynamic, as relational, as potential. Process and relationship become the central concerns not only of analysis, but of struggle as well, so that subversion is something to be uncovered and exploded, rather than implanted and left to fight a war of attrition for some always promised yet never attained state of bliss.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.