2 -- Queer Marxism DA – queer engagement with Marxist utopian imaginaries grounds their movement in embodied queer/trans histories that foreground capitalist accumulation, exploitation, and alienation – class analysis is inseparable from the reproduction of social identity.
Raha ’19 -- (Raha, Natalia, 9-2-2019, "Queer capital: Marxism in queer theory and post-1950 poetics,” Sussex Research Online, https://sro.sussex.ac.uk/id/eprint/86259/, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki
Queer theory engaging with Marxism has reinvigorated key Marxist concepts by grounding theories of sexuality and queer and trans histories, cultures and texts into histories and readings of capitalist social transformation and accumulation. This includes the Marxist concepts of the commodity, value, labour, the gendered and racial division of labour, totality, reification, surplus population, primitive accumulation, racial capitalism, crisis, history and capital. These concepts have been engaged with to varying degrees of detail and Marxist orthodoxy, by drawing from different eras in Marx’s (and Marxist) thought – at times from the optimistic Young Marx of the 1844 Philosophic and Economic Manuscripts (1959), from the revolutionary Marx and Engels of The German Ideology and The Communist Manifesto, from the Marx of Capital. Queer Marxists also draw strongly from twentieth century Marxist figures such as Georg Lukaçs, Walter Benjamin, Ernst Bloch and C.L.R. James. As I detail in Chapter 1, Gayatri Spivak’s reading of Marx’s labour theory of value (1988) has a profound influence on queer Marxism’s conception of value. Furthermore, while often not directly cited, the strong influence of Louis Althusser’s critique of ideology (1971) is evident in some contributions (Ferguson 2004, Liu 2015). The aforementioned Marxist concepts have been studied and applied to deepen important current subjects within queer theory, including the history of sexuality, utopia (of course also a subject of Marxism), affect, queer of colour critique and race, embodiment, gender, activism, and the political economy of sexuality more broadly. For instance, the influential work of Floyd (2009) and Hennessy (2000) connects the transformations of discourses of sexuality (of sexology and psychoanalysis) in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century with developments in capitalist production and consumption. Hennessy and Floyd deploy Georg Lukács’ theory of reification (1971), a touchstone for the development of Western Marxism in the interwar period, to theorise the reification of sexual subjectivity and sexual desire (I discuss this work at length in Chapter 1). The variation in Marxist orthodoxy has had a positive influence on the development of queer Marxism within queer theory, allowing for heterogeneity in critical and theoretical approaches in the uptake of Marxist concepts. Indeed, as Floyd writes, queer Marxism pushes Marxism “to speak to certain dimensions in social and historical reality powerfully illuminated in queer theory’s relatively brief history, dimensions that Marxism has little history of acknowledging, much less examining” (2009: 2, 4). The endeavour to challenge he epistemological limits of Marxism has been particularly fruitful in the development and uptake of queer of colour critique as a mode of analysis, as I discuss below. However, queer Marxisms have at times foregone structural critique that connects queer life and culture to political economy and the critique of capital. In addition, the muted engagement between queer Marxisms themselves seems to have had an adverse effect on the theoretical consistency of, and collaboration within, the discipline. For instance, addressing early work by Floyd (1996), Hennessy highlights the lack of “studies that examine the historical relationship between the formation of new sexual identities and the reifying cultural logic of an emergent commodity culture” (2000: 97). This is the key thesis of Floyd’s The Reification of Desire (2009), which undertakes a detailed queer reading of Lukács as I detail in Chapter 1. However, Floyd’s text only minimally attends to the important queer Marxist work of Hennessy (2000), Joseph (2002), Tinkcom (2002) and Ferguson (2004).16 Such a lack of engagement with other queer Marxist texts has undoubtedly affected the development of the field within queer theory. An example of the theoretical heterogeneity of queer Marxism is found in the roundtable discussion ‘Queer studies, materialism, and crisis’ in the GLQ special issue (Crosby et al. 2012). The discussion pays particular attention to queer Marxism’s “orientation to political-economic questions” (127), utopia and totality, racial capitalism and capital’s need to make certain bodies disposable in its pursuit of accumulation. The discussion brings together prominent contributors to queer Marxism and queer theorists addressing class and queer liberalism. Floyd explicitly historicises the uptake of certain concepts in queer theory, such as utopia in the work of Muñoz (2009) and Edelman (2004), as “symptomatic of a moment in which capital’s colonization of the future appears both unassailable, as a familiar neoliberal narrative would have it [… and] transparently violent in a way that may suggest the opposite: accumulation’s radical fragility” (Crosby et al. 2012: 128). On this point, he emphasises that Marxism and queer studies arrive at the same conclusions. Furthermore, building upon his reconsideration of totality in The Reification of Desire, Floyd asks “Can one ‘re-pos[e] the question of totality’ without implicating oneself in an imperial, American universalism?”, and while gesturing towards Marx’s value-form highlights the “problem of grasping the ways in which capitalism’s gendered, racialized and sexualized violence is inseparable from … capitalism’s simultaneous identity and nonidentity with itself” (138, emphasis added). Two contributors strongly emphasise the relationship between capitalism, racialization and queer studies’ address of marginalised figures and groups. Lisa Rofel emphasises the importance of a queer hermeneutics for understanding capitalism’s drive for universality across “Euro-American metropoles” which is “undone by the ‘difference’” of the history of the “postcolonies”, and for understanding the relation between the value form, bodies and the value of marginalised lives (129). On the subject of racial capitalism, Fred Moten emphasises, citing Cedric Robinson (1983), the centrality of “racism not as capitalism’s instrument but as its conditions of possibility”, alongside the role of “regulative desire” in the pursuit of capitalist accumulation (130). Robert McRuer emphasises queer theory’s interest in “provid[ing] some account of capitalist modernity, neoliberalism, or globalization” must necessarily address “the invalidated and unthinkable”, crip “figures that are sick, infected, deranged, addicted, scarred, wounded, or traumatized” (131). He notes that queer Marxism must remain invested in crip and Mad bodies and lives (as I consider in Chapter 4). Dean Spade’s contributions describe the pain of the NGO-industrial-complex’s “eclipse” of grassroots LGBT activism, which has transformed queer politics into “a site for building white power” (135) through carceral regimes and non-redistributive equality politics, and highlights the importance of a critical trans politics that cognises “the material conditions of existence and the distribution of life chances” (143). In contrast to these approaches that connect the structural forces of capitalism globally to contemporary narratives of development, the transformation of queer politics by capital, and the situation of marginal queer lives within these contexts, Heather Love details her interest in working-class queer writing, sometimes by writers of colour, which “focuses on the lived experience of structural inequality” (131). For Love, this work however decentres its focus on capital and “can seem to lack a revolutionary horizon” (131). She emphasises that “this refusal of the choice between revolution and capitulation is what makes this tradition queer”. 17 Love’s pessimism seems to miss the potential of reading or theorising such lived experience into materials and ammunition of queer Marxism.