Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

3 -- [EXTRA] Marxism should be theorized alongside queer theory

Liu 20 (Petrus Liu is Associate Professor of Humanities at Yale-NUS College and the author of Stateless Subjects: Chinese Martial Arts Literature and Postcolonial History. DECEMBER 01 2020, Social Text (2020) 38 (4 (145)): 25–47. https://doi.org/10.1215/01642472-8680426; accessed 1/7/2022) ng

Queer theory, even as elaborated by authors closely identified as arguing in favor of a radical linguistic constructivism, turns out to be a materialist theory of social structuration with affinities to Marxism. Queer theory does not argue that identity is fluid, mobile, definitionless, or freely chosen; rather, it shows that identity is produced by constraints, social norms, and other specters of the material beyond one’s knowledge and agency. Insofar as both queer theory and Marxism emphasize such primary ties to unknown Others as a source of human vulnerability as well as sociality, both are committed to a materialism even when the material remains unnamed, unidentified, or reduced to a spectral presence. The point of material analysis is not to reassert the priority of the economic but to show that questions of gender and sexuality are part of a matrix of social interdependence that connects the self to others beyond borders—geopolitical, ethnolinguistic, religious, or otherwise. These others may speak different languages, inhabit any kind of socioeconomic organization, and subscribe to a variety of cultural beliefs and customs. Hence, there is no reason to assume that a material analysis must begin with American capitalism, free wage labor, or class relations. Instead, a genuinely materialist analysis must look beyond the borders of the nation and provincialize US queer theory and Marxism as mere participants in a global conversation. While both queer theory and Marxism have largely relied on philosophical notions of ethical alterity to argue this point, philosophy can get us only so far. It is imperative for us as a field to move past philosophical questions of the Other in Kant, Hegel, or Levinas and begin seriously engaging the scholarship produced by the “actually existing others.” The kind of work that we read, produce, recognize, and disseminate as queer theory is all but one variant of a global discourse—there are many queer theories in the world that are generating valuable insights from different archives and social formations. Rather than asking whether queer theory is translatable or applicable to non-Western societies, we need to learn from their academic work and participate in international and translingual conversations. This move is logically demanded by the question of the material. My analysis of the material in queer theory and Marxism aims to show that the reduction of Marxism to an economic doctrine and the subsequent characterization of queer theory as its culturalist corrective reflect the provincialism of US multiculturalist politics. In the United States, the liberal-pluralist paradigm continues to be the primary language for progressive social policies, which has produced a deeply entrenched impression that the primary obstacle facing queer people is discrimination, mis- recognition, or other forms of mental judgment that impede parity in participation. Seeing the LGBTQIA+ “issue” as a battle against discriminatory attitudes and patterns of evaluation, critics believe that the proper remedy is the promotion of “diversity and inclusion” in the workplace or education. What the language of diversity and inclusion leaves out, of course, is the critique and analysis of the historical processes that authorized certain individuals to decide whom to include, tolerate, and accept in the first place. The implicit message to queer and other oppressed people is that, instead of questioning and demanding fundamental changes in the existing relations of power, they can rely on the good will of enlightened individuals in positions of power to bring about social change. The liberal-pluralist language of diversity and inclusion presents a reformist strategy to assimilate the disenfranchised into the national polity in accordance with mainstream views, instead of a transformative strategy that reconfigures relationships of power and expands the field of gender possibilities. A materialist methodology is a timely response at this critical juncture to counter the liberal-pluralist ideology that gender and sexual minorities only suffer from prejudices or invisibility. With materialist theories like Marxism and a rehabilitated queer theory, we can move past the fantasy that formal legal equality is all we need to eliminate oppression around the world. Though queer theory is haunted by the material, it has also necessitated a rethinking of the material.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.