Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

3 -- Conformity DA – communist organizing inevitably excludes and silences queer members by forcing them to conform to their ideal vision of the proletariat. Communist movements have historically been homophobic and claimed that being lesbian arises from unjustified hostilities to men and was an example of developing a lifestyle under capitalism. Don’t let them get away with just saying “not us”; multiple examples of communist movements being exclusionary, and their alt doesn’t do anything to actively include queer people.

Devrim 12 (Libri Derim writes about their experiences in the Revolutionary Communist Party. “Out of the Red Closet: Gay and lesbian experiences in the previous communist movement” Kasama, January, 2012. https://www.marxists.org/history/erol/ncm-8/kasama.pdf) alowenstein

Much has been written about the Revolutionary Communist Party and its ban on gay people within its ranks. Some of us are familiar with the specific anti-gay rationalizations the RCP promoted for thirty years – including its notorious argument that same-sex attrac- tions are a politically reactionary, personal-ideological choice. But what was going on within the RCP was not just a stubborn and arrogant “error of line”– it was also an actual practice that had an impact on real people and real struggle. That is what I want to write about, including what it was like to live “in the closet” inside a communist organization. I want to talk about what it was like to be attracted to the dream of revolution – and then be told that my lesbian feelings were ideologically part of a corrupt and oppressive world order, and that I force myself to have sexual relationships with men in an effort to develop the sexual feelings I was told I was supposed to have, as part of being a revolutionary. I want to talk about the way decent but incredibly ignorant communist com- rades were instructed to correct me, my feelings, and my behaviors. And how, within a movement hoping to carry out liberation, the awful arguments and pressures of anti-gay bigotry were reproduced and enforced. RCP cadre and leaders looked people like me in the eyes and told us to change, conform and be silent — or else get out. At the height of the AIDS crisis, they knowingly opened a horrible split between com- munist activists and those fighting rightwing attacks on gay people. They reproduced within revolutionary ranks (and using “communist” rhetoric) the prejudices, arguments and repressive practices of rightwing re- ligious nuts – and they tried to promote such views more broadly within the left. It seems that most queer revolutionaries were attracted to what the RCP was putting out. That they’d go take out the RCP’s newspaper, the Revolutionary Worker, get involved, and then someone would meet with them to have serious talk about “the Homosexual- ity Question,” and then they would disappear. In that respect, I was a bit different. I got involved before I came out. After meeting the revolutionaries of the RCP, I joined the Revolutionary Communist Youth Brigade (RCYB), really throwing myself into it. I was con- vinced that a possible revolutionary situation might be just around the corner (remember that slogan, “Revo- lution in the ‘80s – Go for it!”?). All my free time was spent building for the work this party was doing in my area: I was going to dem- onstrations, taking the paper out, talking to everyone about Marxism-Leninism-Maoism (MLM), postering a couple times a week, going to meetings. It was my whole life. Falling in love Then I started feeling attracted to another girl who was hanging around the RCYB. She was really funny and cute and smart. I thought she was great and I really respected her, especially the way she stood up for what she believed at school, how she would face off the cops at a demonstration without fear, the way she was al- ways ready to take the paper out even when the rest of us got discouraged by all the rejection. I wanted to be around her all the time and I thought about her con- stantly. Everyone else could see I had it bad, but I never noticed! She gave me her green kaffyah and I wore it all the time, even when I went to bed. I always wanted to ride in the same car with her when we went some- place. Her high school was across town from mine but I’d always try to find a reason to go to her side of town to take the paper out in the afternoons so that I could be with her. Finally, one of the other guys in the RCYB said something about me acting like I was in love with her. They were all teasing me about it. I realized that I had had feelings for girls for a while and I started to come to terms with the fact that I was a lesbian. A family’s anger... When I came out, everyone at home was upset. I was prepared for their reactions, I’d heard other stories from teenagers who had come out about how they were rejected or kicked out of the house, so I was ready to face that from my family. My family was upset and angry. They were disap- pointed in me and wanted me to just “get over” what- ever young adult phase I was going through that made me “think” I was gay. I was so depressed that they couldn’t accept me, their daughter, for who I was. But knowing my family’s conservative background, I had expected them to have a negative reaction so it didn’t surprise me. ...then the rejection by comrades What really shocked me was how leaders in the RCYB and the RCP reacted when I told them I was gay. I have to say that none of the other Youth Brigade members had a problem with it except one guy. He was a little immature and made a joke about how he didn’t mind if a girl was gay but there’s no way in hell he’d sleep in the same room with a guy who was gay. (We’d just stayed at a motel when we traveled to another city for an event and all of us had shared a room). But re- ally most young communists of my generation never thought that being gay was wrong – it was something that had to be imposed on us from without, and was done without ever really hearing or respecting our insights. But while the comrades in the Youth Brigade were fine with it I was really shocked by how hostile the RCYB leaders were. I was immediately separated from the rest of brigade – they stopped having me there for meetings and paper discussions, I wasn’t invited to take out the paper or go running in the mornings, and when I showed up at the bookstore for an event I was told to leave. Being educated I didn’t understand the reaction. Finally, after several months of being excluded from everything and with virtually no communication from Youth Brigade leaders, I received a phone call telling me to show up for a meeting at a coffee shop across town the next weekend. Several Youth Brigade leaders were there as well as two RCP leaders (one of whom had never spoken to me before but was clearly in charge). Everyone was very serious. I was pretty intimidat- ed and scared. They were there to explain to me what reality was, and what a communist view supposedly was: Why be- ing a lesbian arose from unjustified hostilities toward men as a whole, how it was like being a feminist-sepa- ratist, and how in the new society, men wouldn’t hurt women and so women would no longer respond to their oppression by becoming gay. Their argument was that lesbianism was a form of reformism – because it sought relief from oppression by developing a lifestyle within capitalism. They made a series of deductive arguments – very divorced from reality and my own situation – that les- bianism was an ideological choice that embodied a re- formist political program and that was therefore not compatible with being a communist revolutionary. Let me remind you that all of this was happening to me when I was a high school student – just barely starting to sort out life, love and sexuality. Looking back it seems clearer they had reproduced within revolutionary ranks (and using “communist” rhetoric) prejudices, arguments and repressive practic- es that were not far removed from rightwing religious nuts and homophobes. I was very young and pretty naïve I guess – I took what I was told at face value as the communist verdict on gay people, and on me. But at a gut level I couldn’t reconcile the idea that my feelings for other girls meant that I was being bour- geois. I still was attracted to other girls, even when I berated myself for feeling that way. I was told that I was viewing the girl in the RCYB that I liked as a sex object, that I was objectifying her because I had sexual thoughts about her. In one painful meeting (at a Burger King – I never wanted to eat there again after this!) I admitted tear- fully that, yes, I had imagined seeing her naked while masturbating. I felt really guilty. I was pushed into the closet as a price for being considered a revolutionary by those I respected. And this was doubly painful: I was forced to deny my own feelings in public self-criticism, and I was being trained to confront my continuing feelings as reactionary in the privacy of my own mind. Under watch Once I started being allowed back to Brigade ac- tivities I apologized to this girl for objectifying her; but she just laughed and gave me a hug and said not to worry about it. Local RCP leaders and the Youth Brigade coordi- nator kept me away from her though, and talked about sending me to live in a Brigade house in another city for the summer. That idea was dropped after I failed geometry and had to go to summer school, but for the next year or so, I was closely watched. However, I was spouting the party line, so I was “welcomed” back in the fold. But part of me wondered, what would happen if I didn’t accept what I had been told to believe. A few years later there was another change in the division of labor, I was sent to go work in another area with a new group of people. I had left high school and gotten my GED so I was anxious to start working full time and not having to depend on my family. When I was told to apply for a particular kind of job and live in a shared apartment with some other party folks, I complied. I didn’t really have any reason not to, even though I knew that living with people would be like being at the brigade house full-time; I would never be away from people who could scrutinize my actions and “tell on me” to my leadership. This whole time I had been repressing my feelings, trying to just pretend that they didn’t exist. My leadership brought up homosexuality during a paper discussion and I started defending a group of gay activists and one of their slogans. I was criticized by everyone but this time I didn’t back down, I kept on saying that I didn’t understand the RCP’s position on homosexuality. (Actually, I did understand, but I didn’t feel like I could say that I didn’t agree, it felt safer to just say I didn’t understand).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.