Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

4 -- Straight Time DA -- generates an “official time line” that glosses over the complexity of violence(s) our critique illuminates. The perm works to “tease” out good police practices from the “bad,” performatively demonstrating their refusal to examine structural interdependence. Their step in the “right direction” is a step in a “straight direction.”

Russell, 20 – Emma K. Russell is Lecturer in Crime, Justice and Legal Studies at La Trobe University, Australia. She researches in the fields of queer criminology and critical carceral studies. She is the co-author of Resisting Carceral Violence: Women's Imprisonment and the Politics of Abolition (Queer Histories and the Politics of Policing, “Afterword: police power, queer resistance,” Routledge, 2020, pg 154-155)//BL

As a queer criminological text, this book issues a broader challenge to the discipline of criminology. It is a call to question the production of ‘official time lines’ and simplistic dichotomies for the exclusions that they engender and the complexities that they gloss over. Rather than tease out the ‘good’ police practices and strategies from the ‘bad’, a critical and historical queer optic allows us to appreciate the mutual constitution and interdependence of these categories, the slippages and continuities between them in practice, and the powerful forces that reproduce and circulate them. Rather than view the uneven and coercive effects of policing as products of the actions of biased, deficient, or ill-equipped individual officers, we should broaden our analytical framework to account for the historical genesis of policing as a heteronormative and settler colonial project. This reminds us of the importance of preventing (and pursuing accountability for) the immediate harms of policing and punishment—whether as activists or scholars—without getting swept up in the administration of these systems and therefore invested in their continuity. Instead, we might consider strategies to demilitarise and disempower police (McDowell & Fernandez 2018), as well as dedicating more resources towards exploring community-based responses to harm (Kim 2018). As an emerging field of study seeking to distinguish itself from ‘mainstream’ criminology, queer criminology has much to benefit from engagement with abolitionist and anti-carceral feminist thinking (Carlton & Russell 2018; Stanley & Smith 2011; Thuma 2015). We must remain attuned to the violence that underpins the state’s promise of protection. Rather than accepting it at face value that the incorporation of previously excluded groups signifies historical progress and positive change, this book has sought to illustrate the exclusive and regulatory effects of the politics of recognition. My hope is that the narrative presented in this book sparks new questions about the relationship between sexual and gender politics and police power. The surface support for LGBT rights amongst police leaders might indicate success on some levels for LGBT activists who have long fought for queers to be seen as other than criminal and to have access to state protection when it is needed or desired. However, the adoption of LGBT rights language and symbols in by police public relations produces ambivalence and hostility towards police within LGBT movements (Russell 2019). Evolving LGBT-police relations prompt renewed discussion about the role and effects of policing in society, for queers and others. Queer Histories and the Politics of Policing has sought to make sense of contemporary strategies of governing sexuality and gender—the histories from which they emerge and the futures they foreclose—and the threads of resistance running through them.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.