Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Including queer desire and sexual life in their analytic paradigm generates zones of possibility for insurgent Black life within the conditions of social death – non-normative desire contests the perpetual “threat status” of Black queer being and moves towards an autonomous articulation of life.

Avilez ’20 -- (GerShun Avilez, 2020, “Black Queer Freedom: Spaces of Injury and Paths of Desire,” Urbana: University of Illinois Press, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

In bringing injury to the fore, this book also prioritizes desire as a means for contesting or simply dealing with social threat. In the context of a pervasive environment of death, the question of desire becomes secondary in JanMohamed’s analysis. He explains, The imminent, unpredictable possibility of death makes [this subject] live in such a way that his being is consumed with the preoccupation of avoiding the possibility of death. On the other hand, the same structure requires him to control his desire to live as fully as he would like since stepping out of the bounds of his social-death could easily result in his death. He is thus obliged to control and repress his own desire for a full life. The deathbound-subject’s “life” is thus defined by the need to avoid the possibilities of life as well as the possibility of death. (19; original emphasis) JanMohamed does a skillful job in tracing out the systematic constraints that render the death-bound-subject a liminal figure who often must restrain or control desire with the goal of self-protection. However, the move to limit or restrain desire is not a prominent concern for Black queer artists and thinkers. Even as they trace out the exact kinds of restraints that JanMohamed describes, the artists considered in this book consistently and defiantly express desire and claim a freedom within restriction. I track an embracing of life and a declaration of desire, both of which are done within the context of injury. The recognition of the ubiquitous nature of many kinds of threats makes the insistence on life and desire more important and their articulations more compelling. The injury-bound subject is a subject who desires, a subject defined not solely by injury but by desire (i.e., affection, unrestrained pleasure, freedom of movement, self-definition, and unencumbered embodiment), and it is the threat of injury that often informs the investment in disruptive desire. These desires become the subject of artwork by Black diasporic artists, and I evaluate the means for expressing such desire and explain the artists’ detailing of the social and psychological contexts of threat. Throughout, this book demonstrates how desire is understood to be a space of freedom as well as a strategy that redefines space. This desirous freedom is not a panacea that solves all problems, nor is it necessarily long-lasting; nevertheless, it offers moments of satisfaction, control, and autonomy. Sometimes, a simple kiss can make one feel freed for a moment. My emphasis on desire in the context of injury builds on recent work from Black queer theorists around questions of the erotic and pleasure. In his exploration of the social significance of unprotected, or “raw,” sex to Black gay men, Marlon M. Bailey advances the concept of erotic (sexual) autonomy in exploring how gay men choose sexual practices in the context of structural drivers. He insists that there is a need to develop a method that “accounts for sexual desires and practices—the contradictions between them—and the social factors and conditions” that shape the paths of and contour those desires and practices.8 As much as his essay is about the value of taking pleasure seriously in studies of Black gay male sexual practices and HIV/AIDS, it also reinforces the point that desire is always expressed in a sociocultural setting, a setting that may be anti-Black and determined by social and economic disparities. For Bailey, raw sex becomes one means for a resistant expression of individual desire and a technique of critiquing prominent discourses about queer vulnerability. In a different context but a similar conceptual register, Amber Jamilla Musser argues, in her extended consideration of sexual objectification of minoritarian women’s bodies, for the importance of stressing embodied pleasure.9 Musser’s book centers around what she calls “brown jouissance,” a concept that emphasizes sensual embodiment (“fleshiness”) that brings together pleasure and pain, subjectivity and objectivity (3). She refuses an understanding of pleasure that might be understood as moving beyond the body (“jouissance” in the psychoanalytic sense). Musser rejects a binary understanding of racialized female embodiment as either being perpetually objectified or simply liberated in a way that might ignore the kinds of structural realities that Bailey describes. In my reading, brown jouissance is a framework for analysis more than a simple description of a kind of pleasure. Brown jouissance is not just about asserting a pleasure-centered subjectivity. The analytic highlights the social conditions that work around and often against the subject; it reflects a “move toward the space around the individual” as it accentuates expression of the sensual for the individual (42). For both Bailey and Musser, defiant assertions of erotic pleasure push against axes of discrimination. What I take from this body of work is that pleasure may be a tool for undermining acts of interpellation but only when queer pleasure is made visible within its restrictive contexts can we fully discern and evaluate the queer subject. Pleasure must be a primary analytic, but pleasure considered in a vacuum tells us very little. It is for this reason that I emphasize threat and forces that seek to limit expressions of queerness in my consideration of desire. The critical move to attend to the “space around” is a way to shed light on the dynamics and complexities of the threat feedback loop. In drawing attention to the “space around,” I consistently detail how this space—consisting of social elements, including laws, public opinion, built environments, family, and employers—determines the social legibility of queer bodies and influences individuals’ relationships to their bodies. The space around bodies informs our understanding of the bodies themselves. I am interested in bodies in space.

Intersections and Dissents: Black Studies and Queer Theory

Before discussing the particularities of Afro-Pessimism and Queer Negativity, definitions

of queerness and blackness, along with their general fields, are needed to place the overall

relationship between the two. Of course, queer theory arose as predominantly white in its subject

matter and considerations. Writers and theorists, such as Roderick A. Ferguson, Barbara

Christian, Evelynn Hammonds, E. Patrick Johnson, José Esteban Muñoz, Jasbir K. Puar, Kathryn

Bond Stockton, and Jack Halberstam, have attended to the field’s treatment of race “as an

addendum.” However, more work needs to be done in this regard, for the whiteness of queer studies still persists. We see this most explicitly in the ways in which queer theory and queer of

color or black queer theory appear as separate entities in disciplinary categories and even indexes

of books. Even if one considers queer of color theory as a subfield of queer studies, the blackness

in the theory must be stated; otherwise, queer theory assumes whiteness.

A similar dynamic applies to black studies, for unless queer is stated in the title of black

studies or in one of its projects, heterosexuality prevails as the assumption. Homophobia in the

black community is certainty a partner in this, which has been thoroughly critiqued by Audre

Lorde, Barbara Smith, and other black feminist theorists. Similarly, systematic racism speaks to

queer theory’s white default. This is not to say that the black community is more homophobic

than others or that racism and homophobia are comparable injustices. The point is that social and

political discriminations penetrate these theoretical modes. The fields’ focuses certainly

contribute to this issue, as queer theory attends to sexuality and black studies to race. The issue is

not the areas’ concentrations but is the assumptions which underlie their projects and manifest in

their scholarship. In other words, queer theory and black studies have enacted the norm of the

other: queer as white and black as heterosexual.

These theories and communities at large still enact these norms, perhaps, on more subtle

levels or, perhaps, not so subtle registers. We witness this in one recent controversy concerning

the rainbow flag. In the summer of 2017, the city of Philadelphia redesigned Gilbert Baker’s

original rainbow layout by adding two stripes to its rainbow—one black and one brown placed

above the rainbow. Philadelphia’s flag was a part of the city’s More Color More Pride campaign,

aiming to illustrate gay liberation’s need for and enactment of inclusivity. Despite the flag’s

intentions, its new design drew harsh criticism within the white gay community, as the critique

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.