An invasion is on the horizon.
Kathrin Hille 6/7, Greater China Correspondent at FT; and Demetri Sevastopulo, US-China Correspondent at FT, 6/07/2022, “Taiwan: preparing for a potential Chinese invasion,” https://www.ft.com/content/0850eb67-1700-47c0-9dbf-3395b4e905fd, cc
“This is the decade of concern, particularly the period between now and 2027,” says Phil Davidson, a retired admiral who commanded US forces in the Indo-Pacific until last year. “I make that assessment because of the staggering improvements in Chinese military capabilities and capacities, the political timeline for Xi Jinping and the long-range economic challenges in China’s future.”
Taipei wants to retain military capabilities, such as its F-5 fighter jets, to counter Chinese incursions © Ritchie B Tongo/EPA-EFE
Although China’s threat to seize Taiwan by force has been in place ever since the Chinese Nationalist government and army fled to Taiwan in 1949 after losing the civil war on the mainland, Beijing had long focused on pulling the island into its fold with economic lure and political pressure.
But many Taiwanese policymakers now believe that as the Chinese Communist party loses hope these measures will ever work and with its armed forces modernising rapidly, Xi might opt for war soon.
Taiwan came into renewed focus as an increasingly dangerous flashpoint just days after Biden’s inauguration last year when Chinese warplanes simulated missile attacks on a US aircraft carrier sailing in the vicinity of the country. Over the following months, China then boosted the tempo and size of fighter jet and bomber sorties near Taiwan.
Davidson sounded the alarm in March last year, telling the Senate armed services committee that he believed the threat of a Chinese attack on Taiwan would “manifest . . . in the next six years”. Shortly thereafter, a senior US official told the Financial Times that Xi was flirting with the idea of seizing control.
Since then such warnings have become more widespread — the background to Biden’s comments about responding to a Chinese invasion. It has also accelerated a shift in the conversation between Taiwan and the US over how to defend the island.
Although Washington has been urging Taipei for years to take that risk more seriously, the Taiwanese government and military were slow to respond. But the war in Ukraine has served as a wake-up call. Senior Taiwanese officials say Russia’s assault on its neighbour has highlighted the threat they face.
Phil Davidson, former US Indo-Pacific Commander, believes the threat of a Chinese attack on Taiwan will manifest by 2027 © Hugh Gentry/Reuters
“The danger comes from Xi Jinping and the fact that he will begin a third term later this year,” says one official. “Under China’s previous process where they would have a new leader every 10 years, their ‘historic mission’ of unifying Taiwan could be passed on to the next leader. But when a national mission becomes one man’s mission, the danger rises.”
“Putin would not have made a decision like this to invade Ukraine if he wasn’t deciding everything by himself. So Xi Jinping could well make this kind of misjudgement as well,” the official adds.
A shift from ambiguity
While the Russian invasion of Ukraine has focused attention on the potential threat to Taiwan, there is one big difference between the two situations: a Chinese war on Taiwan could be a war with the US.
When Washington switched diplomatic recognition from Taipei to Beijing in 1979, it replaced its mutual defence treaty with Taiwan with the Taiwan Relations Act. The law requires the US to give the country the weapons needed to defend itself, and to maintain the US’s own capacity to resist force or coercion that would jeopardise Taiwan’s security.
In the past, the US kept it ambiguous how far that commitment went. In an attempt to both deter Beijing from considering military force and discourage Taipei from formalising its independence, Washington declined to spell out whether it would enter a war between the two.
Biden appears to have drastically reduced that ambiguity. Asked by a reporter during his recent trip to Japan if he was willing to use force to defend Taiwan, he said: “Yes. That is the commitment we made.” The White House hurried to stress — as it did after Biden’s previous similar statements which some analysts viewed as gaffes — that US policy towards Taiwan has not changed.
President Joe Biden, during a recent trip to Japan, told a reporter he was willing to use force to defend Taiwan © Eugene Hoshiko/Pool/EPA-EFE
But senior officials in Taiwan and countries allied with the US believe Biden is trying to deter Beijing by signalling more clearly it might have to fight the US, too. “We think Biden has made a political decision to demonstrate that this option cannot be excluded,” says a senior Taiwanese official.
“In the Ukraine case, he said beforehand that the US would not enter the war. But when China feels that their military capability has reached the level ready for taking Taiwan, just using financial or economic sanctions will not create an effective deterrence,” he says. “So you must absolutely not let China believe that you will not take military action.”
Although there is growing concern about a possible invasion, the timeframe of any military action — and China’s real intentions — are still the subject of intense debate.
The year Davidson sees as the potential time horizon for a Chinese attack, 2027, is the centenary of the People’s Liberation Army. In November 2020, the Chinese Communist party said it wanted to “ensure that the 100-year military building goal is achieved by 2027”, called for faster military modernisation and reiterated the goal of making the Chinese military fit for networked, “intelligentised” warfare.
Although those are stock phrases China has used before, the Pentagon calls 2027 a “new milestone”. “If realised, the PLA’s 2027 modernisation goals could provide Beijing with more credible military options in a Taiwan contingency,” it said in its annual report on the Chinese military last year.
Some analysts doubt Davidson’s date. But one year on from his testimony, government and military officials in both Taipei and Washington say the window from now to 2027 is a genuine threat.
Avril Haines, director of national intelligence, told Congress the threat to Taiwan was ‘acute’ between now and 2030 © Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters
Last October, Taiwan’s defence minister Chiu Kuo-cheng said the PLA would have the “complete capability” to attack Taiwan by 2025. “The current situation is really the most dangerous I have seen in my more than 40 years in the military,” he told lawmakers.