Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

New cyber initiatives infringe on NSA authority, causing jurisdictional confusion and undermining their primacy.

Daniel Wilson 22, senior reporter covering government contract and defense-related legislative, regulatory and litigation issues for Law360, 1/24/2022, “New Biden Cybersecurity Memo May Sow Agency Confusion,” https://www.law360.com/articles/1457119/new-biden-cybersecurity-memo-may-sow-agency-confusion, cc

Law360 (January 24, 2022, 7:01 PM EST) -- A new White House memo aimed at improving cybersecurity coordination and standards across national security agencies may end up having the unintended effect of causing confusion when cybersecurity missions overlap with those of other federal agencies.

The Jan. 19 memorandum requires the U.S. Department of Defense and the 17 agencies and offices within the Intelligence Community to meet or exceed the same cybersecurity standards that "civilian" agencies — all the other executive branch agencies — are required to meet under a May 2021 executive order. The National Security Agency will take the lead in coordinating those efforts as a "national manager," according to the memo.

The document provides a framework for what should be done within the national security community to improve cybersecurity, but is not clear on when and how information and responsibility should be shared across civilian and intelligence agencies. This lack of clarity could potentially lead to jurisdictional clashes and confusion and to privacy risks related to information-sharing, according to Alex Major, co-chair of the government contracts practice at McCarter & English LLP.

"The fact that you now have NSA and [the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency] in a position where they're conferring on cybersecurity and incident response could pose a potential risk that hopefully the national manager and CISA are both cognizant of," he said. "It's not really raised in the executive order, but those kinds of privacy issues can become problematic if not done appropriately."

One potential area of confusion may arise in circumstances where there is a "fine line" between whether an incident should be handled by the law enforcement arm of a civilian agency or by an intelligence agency, according to Major, who is a retired Air Force intelligence officer.

For example, if there is a cyberattack that might involve a foreign power against a federal system that is not considered to be a national security system, uncertainty over who is responsible could delay the federal government's response or result in an agency with insufficient expertise leading the response. Such a scenario has the potential to worsen damages to those systems.

The government will need to issue guidance to clarify how clashes between areas of civilian and national security responsibilities will be addressed, experts said. Such guidance would provide important clarity for contractors who will help implement new cybersecurity programs, Hogan Lovells counsel Stacy Hadeka said. But so far nothing has been released since the May executive order.

"We're still waiting on uniform guidance on the civilian side, and have yet to get any updates if there'll be any kind of more uniform government requirements," she said.

At least some possible clashes could be avoided, however, by a provision in the memo that allows national security agencies to invoke an exception to address "circumstances necessitated by unique mission needs," said Reed Smith LLP partner Liza Craig, a former Navy attorney.

"Baked into this process [is an] exception where they can do things … to address greater national security issues as they arise," she said. "I think that, in and of itself, will minimize those turf wars."

The memo also lays out a clear hierarchy within the national security community that places the NSA at the top. The ranking order could help minimize clashes between national security agencies and eliminate instances of agencies keeping important cybersecurity information to themselves, according to Major of McCarter & English.

The NSA could also ensure continuity across different agencies with its authority to issue binding operational directives to other national security agencies to address known or suspected cyberthreats.

"The national manager is supposed to be there as a referee or an umpire to make sure that entities are doing what they're supposed to be doing," Major said.

Any regulations that may be forthcoming are expected to be crafted in a way that allows them to change over time in response to new kinds of threats and evolving cybersecurity technology, and will hopefully lead to a standardized approach across federal agencies, according to Reed Smith's Craig.

"To me, the takeaway is that this is no longer going to be left just to the agencies to craft their own responses, but they're going to be able to pool all the resources and all the knowledge and awareness and experiences of these agencies to do something governmentwide," she said.

Other indications that the regulations will be a "living document" include the memo's references to cutting-edge technologies like quantum cryptography, as well as the fact that the intelligence community is often at the forefront of developing and using new technologies, according to Hadeka of Hogan Lovells.

"NSA, I think, will be in a good position to hopefully take the lead and spearhead [efforts to ensure requirements keep up with technology] so that by the time something's implemented it's not obsolete, which I think is a big struggle with the federal government overall," Hadeka said.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.