Ending the dual-hat arrangement cleaves personnel in half, undermining security.
James Di Pane 19, Policy Analyst, Defense Policy, Center for National Defense, 5/02/2019, “Should Cyber Command and the NSA Have Separate Leadership? How to Decide,” https://www.heritage.org/defense/report/should-cyber-command-and-the-nsa-have-separate-leadership-how-decide, cc
NSA and Cyber Command Pull from the Same Talent Pool. The NSA and Cyber Command operate jointly in many instances. Not only do they both hire the same type of employee, but a number of employees work for both organizations simultaneously, changing fluidly depending on the situation. Ending the dual-hat arrangement could result in personnel being forced to choose to work for either Cyber Command or the NSA, leading to personnel issues within both. Cyber Command still relies on NSA personnel for its command staff, even though it now operates independently of Strategic Command.
This would be challenging under most circumstances, but is especially a problem given the challenges that the NSA and Cyber Command have with attracting and retaining top tech talent. Additionally, cyber talent takes years to cultivate, meaning that the recruits filling the ranks would be less capable than their more experienced counterparts. Lieutenant General Stephen Fogarty, Commander of Army Cyber Command, testified before the Senate Armed Services Subcommittees on Cybersecurity and Personnel that the average operator can spend fully half of his or her six-year enlistment in training.29
Recent reporting shows that the U.S. government is struggling to attract and retain top cyber talent due to stiff competition from the private sector. The government has difficulty competing with the high salaries and swift onboarding processes large companies can offer. Cyber Command has outlined a series of initiatives to help improve talent recruitment and retention, including keeping close relationships with universities, increased pay scales, and retention bonuses. But the government may not be able to fill the necessary manpower demand it would create by splitting the organizations.30
The NSA and Cyber Command also share personnel because of the relative scarcity of cyber talent in the public sector. Despite Cyber Command’s Cyber Mission Force teams filling all of its 6,200 billets, recent Senate testimony revealed lawmakers’ concern about a “shortage of cyber-capable personnel.”31 This makes the efficiency of scarce resources essential for the command, and sharing personnel is key to that efficiency.