Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Chivalric masculinity employs crisis narratives (like the 1AC) to pivot from defensive posturing it into offensive violence, and war gets redeployed against marginalized bodies.

Wilcox, 2010 (Lauren Wilcox, Lecturer in Gender Studies and the Deputy Director of the Centre for Gender Studies at the University of Cambridge, whose work is located at the intersections of international relations, political theory, and feminist theory in investigating the consequences of thinking about bodies and embodiment in the study of international practices of violence and security. “Gendering the Cult of the Offensive,” in Gender and International Security edited by Laura Sjoberg, 2010, pp. 73-75 (SPP))

As gender is a relational concept, hegemonic definitions of masculinity necessarily entail hegemonic definitions of femininity. Nira Yuval-Davis has categorized several ways in which women function in nationalist ideologies, symbolically or in their actions. Women are constructed as the biological reproducers of the nation, as well as the cultural reproducers. After all, “group reproduction – both biological and social- is fundamental to nationalist practice, process, and politics.” Under nationalist regimes, woman are often expected to bear and raise young men who will fight on behalf of the nation. The national is therefore dependent upon women in traditional roles as mothers and caretakers to reproduce itself. The entire nation may be symbolized by a women who must be fought and died for. Indeed, nationalist discourses often present the nation as a woman, a guardian and symbol of the nation’s values, such as Germania, Britannia, or France’s Marianne, or the cult of Queen Louise of Prussia. These symbolic women were Madonna-like in their image as chaste mothers of the nation. Rape, then, becomes a metaphor for national humiliation, as in “the rape of Belgium” or “the rape of Kuwait” as well as a tactic of war used to symbolically prove the superiority of one’s national group. Not only do nationalist projects construct gender identities that prescribe different spheres for men and women, but this production of gender identities has been a necessary condition of nationalism as women have symbolically figured as the markers of the nation who must be protected by the men who run the state (or are trying to create one). Nationalism is naturalized, or legitimated, through gender discourses that naturalized the domination of one group over another through the disparagement of the feminine and the constitution of separate and unequal spheres for men and women. Gender is constitutive of nationalism, which is a factor in the promotion of offensive military doctrines and the cult of the offensive. Nationalism in terms of the assertion of the superiority of our men over their men often legitimates war in terms of a “protection racket,” in which offensive wars are fought in order to defend “women and children” from potential or actual threats. This “protection racket” extends the logic of nationalism to allow for offensive policies to be legitimated as defensive. Protection as offensive military doctrine: Rather than a unified, aggressive and warlike nature that gender essentialists like Fukuyama imagine, the hegemonic masculinity of World War I calls upon men to be courageous protectors of those less strong and capable: a chivalrous version of masculinity that has more frequently accompanied “offensive warfare” than a dominating, conquering bloodlust (although the former may resemble the latter from certain vantage pints). These gendered constructions of identity can make offensive military strategies appear to be defensive, enabling wars to take place. Often, the gendered ideologies that constitute nationalism contribute to forming offensive doctrines. “Chivalric” masculinity is not solely about men, but rather gendered relations of power. In particular, the just war narrative involve “good guys” or “just warriors” who fight against “bad guys” for just and valorous reasons. In order to produce the chivalric masculinity of the “just warrior, a ‘beautiful soul” and a malevolent other are needed. As Iris Marion Young explains, The gallantly masculine man faces the world’s difficulties and dangers in order to shield women from harm… Good men can only appear in the goodness if we assume that lurking outside the warm familial walls are aggressor, the “bad men, who wish to attack them. Not only does this “protection racket” legitimate war, but it may be said to legitimate the constitution of the state as the provider of security of outside threats as well. Feminist scholarship in International Relations has described the various ways in which this ideal of chivalric masculinity has formed the basis of the national security state as well the principles behind just war theory. For example, Jean Bethke Elshtain has described “just warriors” and “beautiful souls” as gender identities that legitimate war. Masculine “just warriors” are only reluctantly violent, but violent nonetheless as they wage war on behalf of the pure and feminine “beautiful souls” who are “too good for this world yet absolutely necessary to it.” While seemingly benign, such chivalric discourses require helpless, feminized victims: not full and equal citizens capable of defending themselves. The protector and the protected cannot be equal to one other. “the male protector confronts evil aggressor in the name of the the right and the good, while those under his protection submit to his order and serve as handmaids to his efforts.” Without this discourse of “protection,” many of the offensive military doctrines that resulted in war would not have been possible, as this discourse enables men to take violent action with the narrative that makes their actions seem moral, even commendable. Even so, specifics of time and place shape the specific forms this form of hegemonic masculinity takes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.