The drawing of boundaries creates feminized subjects between those with control over a domain and those without
Deerfield, 2016. (Kat, PhD in Critical and Cultural Theory, Cardiff University UK, “Heavenly Bodies: Gender and Sexuality in Extra-Terrestrial Culture,” Dissertation, http://orca.cf.ac.uk/93157/, SPP)
The relationship between cartographic borders and bodily-spatial borders is a key focus of Kirby’s work on exploration and mapping discourse. In ‘Re:Mapping Subjectivity: Cartographic vision and the limits of politics’, Kirby argues that ‘cartography selectively emphasizes boundaries over sites’: both the boundaries between delineated spaces and the boundaries between body and space.23 Cartography, as Kirby illustrates, intrinsically privileges the boundaries between spaces over the spaces themselves, as this is how spaces become representations on a map. Kirby further argues that carography’s emphasis on boundaries/borders extends beyond the material constraints of mapping. The emphasis on boundaries also applies to the construction of what Kirby identifies as the Enlightenment or Cartesian subject, the subject of the early exploratory ventures that gave Western spatial discourse its origins. Kirby explains: The similarity of mapped space and the mapping subject stems from the way the boundary between them is patterned as a constant barricade enforcing the difference between the two sites, preventing admixture and the diffusion of either entity. Cartography institutes a particular kind of boundary between the subject and space, but is also itself a site of interface, mediating the relationship between space and the subject and constructing each in its own particularly ossified way.24 In cartography, Kirby argues, the exploratory subject’s body is defined by its remaining bounded from exterior space. This ultimate construction of boundedness is threatened by what is traditionally understood as the feminine attribute of bodily permeability.25 This strictly bordered subjectivity is additionally threatened by the risk of the subject getting lost within the landscape. In this way, Kirby argues, cartography as a way for the subject to not be lost relies on two different kinds of borders – the borders drawn on a map, and the borders separating the body of the subject from its exterior.26 In Kirby’s discussion of the Western subject ‘being lost’, she explains that it is necessary for the Western explorer to conceive of himself as separate from the landscape, in a 'position of mastery' above and outside of the territory itself.27 This, Kirby argues, is one of the primary functions of cartography: ...to ensure that the relationship between knower and known remains unidirectional. The mapper should be able to 'master' his environment, occupy a secure and superior position in relation to it, without it affecting him in return. This stance of superiority crumbles when the explorers' cartographic aptitude deteriorates. To actually be in the surroundings, incapable of separating one's self from them in a larger objective representation, is to be lost.28 This has a particularly masculine association, illustrated by considering again Rose’s argument about the ‘master subject’ and this subjectivity’s need to deny its own corporeality. Without a pre-existing map, Kirby argues, the Western exploratory subject in a foreign land is always lost, because his perception of space requires that he be safely bounded from it. A female subject, Kirby goes on to argue, cannot occupy this subjectivity, because of the associations of femininity not only with the body but with a body that is not able to divest itself of spatial awareness.29