Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Muslims are constructed as feminine and hyper-sexual, justifying the colonial legacy of penetration and domination of the Middle East

Zine, 2008. (Jasmine Zine, “Between orientalism and fundamentalism” Hunt, Krista, and Rygiel, Kim, eds. (En)Gendering the War on Terror : War Stories and Camouflage Politics. Abingdon, Oxon, GBR: Ashgate Publishing Group, 2008. ProQuest ebrary (Rishi).

Increasingly since the tragic attacks of September 11, 2001, Muslims have been positioned on the geo-political stage as anti-democratic, anti-liberal and living in societies located outside the western narratives of progress and modernity. The global fault lines of North-South are underscored by the complex fissures that occur as a result of social, economic and political disparities and ideological upheavals, yet the over-riding discourses being purveyed have reduced the dynamics of neo-imperial globalization to the essentialized notion of a ‘clash of civilizations’. Huntington (1993) warned that ‘the fault lines between civilizations will become the battle lines of the future’ (p. 22). This fatalistic prophecy inscribes present global conflicts and insurgencies with a Manichean dualism carving the world into rigid and culturally irreconcilable enclaves. Through this binary formulation of the ‘West and the rest’, Islam and Muslims have become the foils for modernity, freedom and the civilized world. The discursive arena of the ‘war on terror’ has re-inscribed the ideological rhetoric of the Crusades. The Bush doctrine used religious rhetoric to describe the early US campaigns against Muslims in Afghanistan, dubbing this military engagement ‘Operation Infinite Justice’, 2 thereby invoking attributes of God to justify their retributive incursions. Other ways of inscribing the ensuing military campaigns with theological purpose and justification came through Bush’s use of religious sanctions such as the need to rid the world of ‘evil doers’. According to Rosemary Ruether, a professor of theology at the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, Bush and many of his supporters on the Christian right speak of his administration as ‘messianic agents chosen by God to combat evil and to establish good’ (Lattin, 2004, p. A16). These pronouncements became similar in ideological nature to the ‘fatwas’ issued by Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda cohorts who characteristically invoked religious legitimacy in their campaigns of violence and ‘jihad’ against the ‘infidel’ West. Whether it is the jingoistic chauvinism of Bush’s ‘American messianic nationalism’ (Lattin, 2004) or bin Laden’s Islamist extremism, both views engage violent forms of religious rhetoric and fundamentalist notions of the enemy ‘Other’ in a theocratic Manichean divide. Along with religious rhetoric, the war on terror, like previous imperialist campaigns, is inscribed with the politics of race and gender. Whether we examine the historical relations of colonialism, or the neo-imperialist relations of current global politics, military violence is rooted in the complex inequalities of race, gender, class and ethnicity. The resurgence of racialized discourses is reminiscent of those predicated on early modernist tropes of social evolutionism and serve to cast Muslims in the global South as ‘uncivilized and barbaric’. Recall Bush’s dictum proclaiming the ‘we (read: civilized West) will bring progress and prosperity to Iraq’. This proclamation locates Iraq and Arab Muslim society in what McClintock (1995) has referred to as ‘anachronistic space: prehistoric, atavistic and irrational, inherently out of place in the historical time of modernity’ (p. 40). The narrative of ‘progress’ therefore creates a rationale for the occupation of Iraq as a benevolent gesture of humanitarianism masking the self-serving neo-liberal economic enterprise at the heart of its imperial design. Racialized knowledge production also acts in collusion with campaigns of power and domination. As Foucault (1982) noted, power and knowledge directly imply one another and it is through sets of discursive practices that particular kinds of subjects are produced (p. 27). Through the discourses of Orientalism, the late Edward Said (1979) described how particular kinds of Arab and Muslim subjects were constructed through literary practices as ‘demonic hordes of hated barbarians’ (p. 59)’, ‘inveterate liars … lethargic and suspicious’, who ‘in everything oppose the clarity, directness and nobility of the Anglo-Saxon race’ (p. 39), or as the archetypal Oriental woman; the Egyptian courtesan who never spoke of herself or represented her emotions, presence or history, but relied on the European man to render and inscribe meanings for her (p. 6). Veiled Muslim women were constructed in the Western literary imagination as objects of desire, sensual, elusive harem girls and yet they were disavowed in the same breath as backward victims of their heathen and misogynistic cultures (Zine, 2002; Kahf, 1999). These history lessons exemplify Said’s warning that ‘too often literature and culture are presumed to be politically, even historically innocent’ (p. 27). Such presumed innocence, masks the machinations of power that operate through discursive practices. The war on terror reinvents these existing tropes and discourses in new ways that produce Muslims as dangerous foreigners, terrorists, and threats to public safety and render Muslim women as victims of their anachronistic faith, lacking agency and voice. Neo-Orientalist writing has gained increasing currency since the 9/11 attacks and ranges from the sensationalist tell-all journalism of dissident Muslim journalist Irshad Manji (2003), marketing her pulp fiction ‘rufusenik’ angst in The Trouble with Islam to even more virulent racist and Islamophobic diatribes such as Italian journalist Orianna Fallaci’s (2002) The Rage and the Pride. Fallaci’s avowed antifascism rings hollow against her bitter racist manifesto. Consider this passage from her seething narrative exalting the ‘progress’ of the West and vilifying the ‘backwardness’ of Islamic society and culture: The motor, the telegraph, the light bulb, I mean the use of electricity, the photograph, the telephone, the radio, the television, have not been invented by some mullahs or some ayatollahs…And let us not forget the standard of life that Western culture has achieved at every level of society. In the West we no longer die of starvation and curable diseases as they do in the Moslem countries. Right or wrong? But even if these were all unimportant achievements, (which I doubt), tell me: what are the conquests of the other culture of the bigots with the beard and the chador and the burqa (p. 92)? She goes on to tirade against the undesirable Muslim foreigners ‘loafing around our cities with their “merchandise”, their prostitutes, their drugs…’ and defiling their cities with ‘the yellow streaks of urine, the stench of excrement blocked the main entrance of the San Salvatore al Vescovo: the exquisite Romanic church…that the sons of Allah transformed into a latrine…’ (pp. 129– 130). Muslim women are cast as ‘idiotic’ ‘uneducated’ and guilty of ‘marrying pricks who want to marry four wives’ (p. 95). Ordinarily such blatant xenophobic, neo-fascist, Islamophobic vitriol would be written off as a racist fiction: the baseless rambling of an acrid mind, however in the post 9/11 era, despite the protests of European anti-racist groups seeking its ban as hate literature, the book can be found easily in some prominent bookstores in the ‘international relations’ section, having garnered mass appeal and sales. 3 Such anti-Islamic and racialized motifs are activated in new ways to justify the current neo-colonial military campaigns in the Middle East by influencing popular consciousness and manufacturing the public consent required for these practices of war and domination to take place. Thobani (2003) aptly points out that the current discourse in the war on terror has an unsettling resonance with earlier colonial constructions of the enemy ‘other’: The language used in the construction of the ‘enemy’ is very familiar to peoples who have been colonized by Europe. It echoes colonial constructs of the native as barbaric and dangerous, whose colonization was not only justifiable but also welcome, bringing them into civilization and democracy. The use of this highly charged colonial discourse at that particular moment of crisis revealed the nature of the absolutist racialized Western ideology being mobilized to rally the troops and to build a national and international consensus in defense of the ‘West’ and its civilization (p. 402). Through the pervasive forces of the media, these ideas are easily and uncritically absorbed by the masses as a means to legitimate the right to power and the right to rule over others in an almost benevolent and paternal gesture of bringing modernity, democracy and liberalism to those Fanon (1963) poignantly described as ‘the wretched of the earth’. This new hegemony operates as a form of ‘camouflaged politics’ masking the self-serving economic and political rationale behind the global dynamics of power. The current rise of militarism is also galvanized by a globalizing patriarchy that purveys a conquest-driven masculinist stance. According to Okazawa-Rey (2001): Patriarchal values are promoted by militarism, particularly the social construction of masculinities that revere the (false) notion of invincibility, relationships of domination and subordination, the eroticization of domination, emotional detachment, and the dehumanization of ‘others’ into enemies, like Arab ‘terrorists’ and Columbian ‘drug lords’. Misogyny is also at the core of militarism (p. 21). As part of the ‘eroticization of domination’ the use of sex and sexual metaphors has long been associated with colonization as well as the current military industrial complex. For example, the feminization of land becomes a prevalent motif in colonial consciousness metaphorically tying the conquest of the female ‘other’ to the conquest of indigenous land. McClintock (1995) describes how geographic space became feminized in the narratives of exploration and conquest. From the time of Columbus, who described the world as the shape of a woman’s breast to the Enlightenment, McClintock describes the metaphysics of colonial fantasies that inscribed gendered notions of conquest and subjugation: Knowledge of the unknown world was mapped as a metaphysics of gender violence – not as the expanded recognition of cultural difference – and was validated by the new Enlightenment logic of private property and possessive individualism. In these fantasies the world is feminized and spatially spread for male exploration, then reassembled and deployed in the interests of massive imperial power (p. 23). Bullock (2002) describes how the colonial Orient was feminized and depicted in the travel writing of Flaubert who described swimming in the Red Sea as ‘lying on a thousand liquid breasts’ (p. 8). The male imperial gaze therefore allowed for the metaphorical conquest over feminized land to work hand in hand with concurrent physical conquest taking place. Veiled Muslim women, however, inhibited the imperialist masculinist gaze by covering their bodies and producing an effect whereby they inverted the gaze and could see but not be seen (see Bullock, 2000). Pornographic images of unveiled Muslim women were circulated in the form of postcards during the European colonization of the Middle East and North Africa in the nineteenth century, rendering the bodies of these women, otherwise covered and obscured from view by their veils, open to the imperial male gaze (see Alloula, 1986). Muslim women who were cloistered in the inaccessible inner sanctums of the eroticized ‘harem’ were now laid bare and open to the otherwise forbidden visual access of European men. Ella Shohat writes that ‘it is this process of exposing the female Other, literally denuding her, which comes to allegorize the western masculinist power of possession, that she as a metaphor for her land, becomes available for Western penetration and knowledge’ (1993, p. 53). During the 1991 Persian Gulf War, the feminization of land and masculinization of conquest was reinvented by invoking metaphors of sexual violence in the representation of the US military campaign. Analyzing the sexual politics embedded in the media representation of the Persian Gulf war, Kari Points (1991) observes how sexual violence was invoked in military euphemisms: ‘Listening to US military talk about the conflict, I began to realize, that the United States was being portrayed as the masculine conqueror and Iraq as the feminine victim. An air force pilot at the start of the war predicted ‘it’ll just be slam bam thank-you Saddam!’ (p. 1). Further, in response to Saddam Hussein’s famous dictum of fighting the ‘Mother of All Battles’, a US air force officer responded with the challenge ‘Tell him dad’s coming to kick mom’s butt’. One of the most chilling examples Points cites was reported by the Washington Post and describes how fighter pilots aboard the USS John F. Kennedy watched porno movies before their bombing missions (p. 2). This revelation allegorizes disturbing images of cascading bombs as the brutal ejaculate of US military imperialism being released upon the subdued feminized Iraqi nation. Sexual bravado and the emasculation of the enemy ‘other’ are legacies that have carried over to the current ‘war on terror’ with Iraq as the continuing theater of combat. New forms of violence and degradation now occupy the notorious torture chambers of Saddam Hussein’s Abu Ghraib prison. According to Burnham, ‘the Abu Ghraib portraits of sexual humiliation and submission have exposed the unbelievably tangled strands of racism, misogyny, homophobia, national arrogance and hypermasculinity that characterize the US military’ (2004, p. 3). She goes on to note that the demoralizing images of Iraqi prisoners forced to wear women’s underwear are a sign that ‘degradation and weakness are still equated with the female in this man’s army’ (p. 3). In this way, the sexualized narratives in the war on terror continue the discursive practices of European colonialism where according to McClintock (1995) ‘…the rhetoric of gender was used to make increasingly refined distinctions among the different races. The white race was figured as the male of the species and the black race as the female (p. 55)’. Therefore the grotesque feminization of Arab men through the degrading and sexually humiliating acts performed at Abu Ghraib recasts the earlier script of imperial domination in new yet equally demeaning ways. That Arab men are made to perform a debased and conquered feminized role in this new colonial narrative of occupation is as much a vulgar expression of the US military’s enforcement of their perceived racial and civilizational superiority as it is of their thinly guised misogyny and homophobia (see Brittain, Ch. 4). Speculation has arisen that this new form of sexual humiliation as a tool of military subjugation was inspired by the book The Arab Mind by anthropologist Rapheal Patai (1973/2002). 4 This book, detailing a litany of Orientalist claims about a singular ‘Arab Mind’ not only essentializes a presumed collective psyche but graphically depicts the perceived sexual proclivities of Arabs, such as the idea that masturbation was seen as more morally shameful than visiting prostitutes. Whitaker (2004) questions whether it was this ‘fact’ that lead to Iraqi prisoners being forced to masturbate in front of cameras. He goes on to argue that Patai’s book, dubbed as the ‘bible of the neo-cons on Arab behaviour’, provided the US military with the psychological ammunition to add this new form of sexual violence to their arsenal of racialized psychological subjugation. Whitaker notes that the Arab Mind is likely the single most popular and widely read book on the Arabs in the US military and while discredited as Orientalist fiction in credible academic circles, was used as a textbook for officers at the JFK special warfare school in Fort Bragg. This neo-Orientalist genre of literature has therefore had a powerful affect on shaping essentialized notions of Arab otherness based on presumed narratives of sexuality and deviance that has scripted the demoralizing role-play of Abu Ghraib. The role of Orientalist knowledge production therefore continues to play a powerful ideological role in the continuing imperial contest and enactment of violence against the body of the racialized Arab Other.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.