International Space Coop hinges upon the presumption of US paternalism – the aff relies on heteronormative and hierarchical tropes of masculinization and feminization
Griffin, 2009 (Penny, PhD and professor in the dept of politics and IR, Univ New South Wales, “The spaces between us: the gendered politics of outer space,” in Securing Outer Space, Routledge, p. 67-68, SPP)
The US is, of course, heavily reliant on its satellite-based systems, and to this end works (to a certain extent) within a regime framework of international space ‘law’ (Brearly 2005: 14). This is not to suggest that US discourse in not constructed around the imbedded belief that the US itself represents the global hegemon, and the only viable, indeed legitimate keeper of global ‘order’. The US may be challenged ‘regionally’, but considers itself ‘unlikely to be challenged by a global peer competitor’ (US Space Command, ‘Vision for 2020’), control of space assures the US ‘access to space, freedom of operations within the space medium, and an ability to deny others the use of space, if required’, with the US casting itself in a classic ‘warfighter role’. Sexing US Outer Space Discourse[:] The gendered assumptions that underlie this rhetoric are tacit but striking, and depend on two distinct, heteronormative, tropes of masculinization and feminization. First, the US’s ability to control ‘space capabilities’ depends upon assumptions of dominance and inherent superiority that revolve around the (gendered) signifier of the US’s role as ‘classic’ or ‘active warfighter’: assumptions including the need for speed and watchfulness (‘real time space surveillance’), agility and technical superiority (‘timely and responsive spacelift’), ‘enhanced protection’ (of ‘military and commercial systems’), robustness and efficient repelling capabilities (‘robust negation systems’), ‘precision force’ and ‘enhanced “sensor-to-shooter” capabilities. Just as Presidents Kennedy and Johnson summoned the spectre of an active, robust, potent American with the ‘Pilgrim and Pioneer spirit of initiative and independence’ (Kennedy, quoted in Dean 2001: 180), so George W. Bush calls to those able to show ‘daring, discipline, ingenuity, and unity in the pursuit of great goals’, the ‘risk takers’ and ‘visionaries’ of who America is so ‘proud’ (Bush 2004). Second, in establishing its (heterosexually masculine) credentials, the US’s techno-strategic discourse reconfigures all other space-able nations as subordinate, constructing a binary, heterosexual relationship of masculine hegemony/feminine subordination. Tellingly, US Space Command cites the forging of ‘global partnerships’ as essential to protecting US national interests and investments, where such partnerships are at the behest of the US, with those that partner the US ‘warfighter’ little more than passive conduits for US ‘opportunity’ and ‘commerce’ (‘Joint Vision 2020’).