Crisis-based environmental threat construction is incompatible with the alternative
Detraz, 2010. (Nicole, Assistant Professor in political science at U Memphis, “the genders of environmental security,” in Gender and International Security edited by Laura Sjoberg, p. 104-106; spp)
The environmental conflict perspective is the approach that most clearly links traditional -security concerns to the environment. Most authors who examine environmental conflict focus on the possibility that groups within society will engage in violent conflict as natural resource stocks diminish due to environmental degradation. These conflicts are understood to threaten the stability of the state. There are several broad trends that are identified as increasing the likelihood of environmentally induced conflicts, "including: expanding and migrating human populations; water, arable land and other resource and environmental scarcities; ... globalisation which brings people (and disease) into closer proximity; and increasing recognition of the injustice of Northern-induced underdevelopment of the South."6 Central to these discussions is the concept of scarcity. Thomas Homer-Dixon identifies resource scarcities as being potentially so severe that they can seriously undermine human well-being. He identifies three types of scarcities: supply-induced scarcity, demand-induced scarcity, and structural scarcity. 7 The main argument is that some types of scarcity, coupled with other factors, can contribute to violent conflict. 8 Given the similarities between the environmental conflict approach and "mainstream" security, a number of feminist criticisms of the environmental conflict approach can be read into the core feminist work in Security Studies. Specifically, feminist theories would criticize the environmental conflict approach's narrow definition of security, its state-centrism, its focus on scarcity, and its neglect of gender as a possible cause for environmental conflict. First, feminists argue that the environmental conflict approach holds an inadequate understanding of what security is. Environmental conflict scholars are focused on the potential for environmental degradation and scarcity to cause violent conflict, rather than looking at what happens to people and their environment during wars. To term something a "security" issue and then to leave important elements of insecurity untouched is problematic. Including gender means including the assessment of potential insecurities during wartime as well, given that women often face particular security risks during times of conflict. A second problematic element of the environmental conflict literature from a gendered perspective is its state-centrism. Feminists often engage in a multilevel analysis, with particular attention paid to individuals and groups within societies. Environmental conflict scholars typically restrict their attention to the level of the state, again demonstrating the close links between this approach and traditional Security Studies. 11 Feminists contend that it is necessary to pay attention to security at levels above and below the state in order to understand how women participate in and are affected by international security issues. Third, ecofeminists will take issue with the assertion of a link between environmental conflict and scarcity because they see that treatments of scarcity in this literature are largely anthropocentric, suggesting that the environment is made up of resources for human consumption. Authors like Carolyn Merchant call for the acknowledgement of a dynamic relationship between human and nonhuman nature, with each having a, degree of power over the other. 12 To use terms like "scarcity" implies that the environment is something of a stockroom of resources for humans that may become depleted, which disregards the deeper relationship between the two entities. Finally, feminists, in their concern for the gender-differential impacts of proposed cases of conflict are themselves gendered. The factors often put forward as potentially contributing to resource scarcity and conflict in environmental conflict literatures include population growth, human migration, globalization, and unequal resource distribution. Each of these topics has particular implications for gender analysis that are largely unaddressed within this literature. For example, environmental conflict scholars argue that increases in human populations can directly contribute to both supply-induced and demand-induced scarcities, which could result in violent conflict. This tells us very little if we do not consider where these populations are located and who they are made up of. Also, the issue of population has specific gendered implications. Impacts may be different if populations have “youth bulges” typically made up of young males. This group disproportionately engages in crime, commits suicide, or join militias, all of which are important security concerns. Additionally, by identifying populations increase as a contributor to environment conflict, these authors are automatically making women the potential target of “solutions” because of their role as child bearers. When issues are securitized, certain actions are seen as justifiable – and it is likely that men and women will experience these actions differently. Similar arguments can be made for a number of the other causal factors privileged in the environmental conflict approach. These instances of male/female differential impacts have implications for the security of particular individuals.