Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The AFF’s pragmatic reform cannot disrupt the structural patriarchal ordering – the link outweighs the turn

Howell, 2018 (Alison, PhD in PoliSci@YorkUniversity, AsstProfPoliSci@Rutgers, Forget “militarization”: race, disability and the “martial politics” of the police and of the university, International Feminist Journal of Politics, Volume 20, Issue 2) BW

Feminist praxis can benefit from questioning the concept of “militarization” so as to more fully excavate the violence of liberal order. In particular, the methodological primacy of examining “women’s lives” (or militarized masculinities) risks subsuming analyses of race, Indigeneity, disability and coloniality under gender. The result is an incomplete accounting of the ways in which war-like relations and systems that are “of war” are symbiotically and thoroughly part of liberal order, and not an exceptional aberration from it. To capture these dynamics, I have proposed an alternate concept, “martial politics,” which seeks to illuminate the histories of our present imbrication with war – a move made possible by shifting to an analysis that foregrounds historical relations of race, Indigeneity and disability alongside sexuality and gender. Yet what is at stake here is not only feminist methodology and theory, but also our activism. So, what of expediency? Do we lose too much if we can no longer demand demilitarization? In the 1980s when sex-negative radical feminists engaged in anti-porn activism, they found themselves with strange bed- fellows in the Christian right. This should have served as ample evidence that it was time to reconsider their perspective, and it is a lesson for the present day. Feminist scholars and activists should be similarly concerned that the concept of “militarization” is popular amongst small-state, right-wing libertarians associated, for example, with the Cato Institute (see Balko 2013). With this lesson in mind, I argue the concept of (de)militarization guides us in asking for too little of the wrong things. From the perspective of “demilitarization,” Obama’s 2015 cancellation of the federal government program of granting local police forces military equipment seems like a significant victory, but to be satisfied with this fails to address how policing imposes order through laws that criminalize Blackness, Indigeneity, disability and gender deviance or queerness. We must demand more. By recognizing that we are steeped in martial forms of politics, feminist anti-war praxis could work not (just) towards demilitarization; it could also more consistently align with anti-racist and disability organizing for prison abolition and deinstitutionalization by recognizing these institutions as central to “martial politics” – that is, because they are war-like and “of war.” This kind of resistance is already robust, not only in Black Lives Matter and prison abolition activism in relation to policing, but also in relation to the colonial foundations of universities. Recent student movements from South Africa to the UK, from India to the US and beyond, have been calling into question the Whiteness of universities and their founding in, and continuing celebration of, (settler) colonialism. For instance, students have contested the continued celebration of brutal colonist Cecil Rhodes on the University of Cape Town and Oxford University’s campuses, and slave owner Isaac Royall Jr.’s family crest at Harvard, tying these histories into contemporary racial inequalities in admissions and campus life. They have demonstrated that diversity is insufficient, and that the university must be decolonized. Similarly, disability and anti-racist student activists have drawn attention to the continued legacies of eugenics in universities. If we are to understand the martial politics of the university, the police, or of any other institution, we would do well to pay attention to this activism. The concept of “militarization” is, at this point, an easy out. In a time when academics are under increasing pressure to produce articles and books at breakneck speed, it may seem expedient to apply the framework of “militarization,” especially when the concept is reduced to the surface analysis of military aesthetics in so-called civilian life. The careful historical work for which I am calling in order to specify expressions of “martial politics” is not fast or easy, but what is at stake is too important. If we are to grapple with the violence of liberal orders in a more robust way, if we are to attend not only to the gendered dynamics of military power but also to race, ableism, (settler) colonialism and other forms of injustice, we need to do better and do more.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.