Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Talking about women isn’t the same as confronting structural gender violence

Collins 00 (Patricia Hill, Charles PHelps Taft PRofessor of Sociology and Chair of the Department of African-American STudies at the University of Cincinnati, Gender, Black Feminism, and Black Political Economy,"Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science , Vol. 568, The Study of African American Problems: W. E. B. Du Bois's Agenda, Then and Now (Mar., 2000), pp. 41-53))

Despite this important contribu- tion, one might ask, What about gen- der? On the one hand, it can be argued that Du Bois's work contains an incipient gender analysis (Gilkes 1996). Du Bois actually talked of African American women during a time when Black women were treated as objects of knowledge (Col- lins 1998a, 95-123). Some of his work does center on African American women and indicates his awareness of the distinctive experiences that characterized Black women's lives. For Du Bois, Black women carried a special burden-not only were they Black, poor, and second-class citi- zens, but they were female as well. Du Bois identified Black women's suffering as a "social fact that pro- vided an important and distinct angle of vision," and for Du Bois, three great revolutions were at work: those involving "women, labor, and black folk. In various writings, he observed that black women embod- ied all three of these revolutions in their historical roles in the family, the community, and the labor force" (Gilkes 1996, 112). Du Bois may have acknowledged African American women's central- ity within these three revolutions, but this does not mean that he afforded gender the same analytical importance as race and class in explaining them. For Du Bois, race and class constituted important sys- tems of power that explained Black political economy, yet gender far too often remained a personal identity category that described Black women's special circumstances in dealing with the more fundamental (and thereby more important) oppressions of race, class, and nation. As a result, Du Bois could be simultaneously progressive yet paternalistic-his intersectional analyses of race, class, and nation coupled with his recognition of Black women's special situation distanced him from avowedly sexist approaches yet did little to challenge masculine authority. His stance on gender was better than most but not as good as it could have been. This raises the question of whether interpretations of gender were available to Du Bois that afforded gender theoretical sig- nificance comparable to that afforded to race, class, and nation. Joy James (1996) argues that not only did such perspectives exist but that Du Bois ignored them. Thus, one can argue that Du Bois did have access to what we now call Black feminist analyses that view Black women's experiences as honed at the intersection of race, class, nation, and gender but that he rejected them. James suggests, for example, that Du Bois was familiar with the ideas of both Anna Julia Cooper and Ida B. Wells-Barnett, two prominent turn- of-the-century Black feminist think- ers. Both women used gendered analyses to explain important social issues. For example, Cooper'sA Voice from the South contends that only when Black women got their rights would African Americans as a collec- tivity be empowered (Cooper 1892). Similarly, Ida B. Wells-Barnett's analysis of lynching and institution- alized rape points to the significance of gender in explaining patterns of sexual violence confronting U.S. Black men and women (Wells- Barnett 1995). Neither Cooper nor Wells-Barnett elevated gender above other factors, but both clearly identi- fied its importance both for Black women and as a fundamental princi- ple of African American social organization. Why Du Bois failed to make use of these paradigms is a matter of specu- lation, but that he did not grant gen- der the same theoretical weight as that placed on race, class, and nation seems fairly straightforward. This has been a loss, because Du Bois did not incorporate into the corpus of his work two distinctive and important elements of U.S. Black feminism drawn upon by Gilkes and James, respectively, in their analyses of Du Bois. When read together, Gilkes and James identify two dimensions of Black feminist standpoint epistemol- ogy that might inform a gendered analysis of Black political economy.1

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.