Impact – Structural Patriarchy guarantees war – we must refuse to buy into Hegemonic Masculinity and the Protection Racket, because it will always find a threat to justify enlarging and improving the military industrial complex
Padmi, 2021 (Made Fitri Maya Padmi, IR Scholar, Lecturer at University Jakarta, Master of Science focused in International Security Studies from University of Bristol. “Redifining Gender Role During Wartime: Power Relations, Disparities and Impacts,” Global Insight Journal v. 6 no. 1, http://journal.uta45jakarta.ac.id/index.php/GIJ/article/view/4438; spp)
War and conflict have been the main features of international relations study. History is full of heroic stories of men fighting for their nations’ security and dignity. In Ancient Greek mythology, for example, Homer through his poems told of the Trojan War, which was triggered by the abduction of Helen from Greece by the Trojan prince Paris. Helen’s enraged husband Agamemnon, King of Sparta, commanded the greatest warriors in Greece to wage war against Troy in the name of the nation’s pride. Thus, almost immediately, the aims of the war expanded well beyond Helen’s return. Its justifications became about restoring the honour of a nation and illustrating the bravery of his soldiers and his military power. Realism and neorealism approaches have dominated international security studies for decades. The core assumption of these approaches is states’ relations in anarchic realm. As a critique to these perspectives feminism has emerged to question the realist/neorealist concepts of power, rationality, and patriotism which are used often in security studies. Thus, both state and international systems are inclined to the characteristics of masculinity. Feminists have criticised the approach taken by Realist and Neo-Realist about state and international system which they consider gender-biased or tending to privilege one particular gender only. Feminists have tried to provide wider perspective in international security studies by adding gender characteristics into security phenomena, including war. This approach is not only about advocating women or adding women into a male-construction, but giving multiple gender-based perspectives to international security studies. Understanding gender is not simply based on the biological sex attached to every single human being. Gender is a socially constructed symbol given to describe the social characteristics of ‘male’ or ‘female’. While masculinity emphasises rationality, bravery, toughness, aggressiveness, and independence, femininity is associated with being irrational, interdependent, emotional, nurturing, vulnerable, and gentle. Elsthain (1987) described this polarisation between the sexes in the following terms: ‘Women are excluded from war talk and men excluded from baby talk’. Many approaches are used to explain the cause, conduct, and consequence of war; one of them is a gender approach. Considering again the Trojan War, a gender perspective allows for wider analysis of how masculinity and femininity play significant roles in the war. The abduction of a wife could be seen as a disgrace to the values of manhood. Using military capability to show the power of nation is the identic notion to prove masculinity which is thought to be tough, aggressive and confrontational. Meanwhile Helen, the woman caught in this war, was left and is seen as either the cause of war or the victim of war. Across time and culture, war and military attributes have been associated with masculinity. In social and political life, men are in the top position of the social hierarchy, and their position grants them the authority to become political decision makers. As stated by Dawson (1996, cited in Kennedy, 2007, p.119) in ancient Greece, some form of military training was regarded as a prerequisite to manhood. In the other words, if a man did not attend or even failed in military training, he would be classified as a ‘woman’ to highlight his weakness. Regarding the assumption of women’s weaknesses and vulnerability, women are usually made the victims of war; even when there is involvement of women soldiers, their participation remains invisible. Throughout history during wartime, women often experience sexual violence in the forms of rape, prostitution, and forced marriage. This paper argues that war is not a ‘gender-neutral’ phenomenon. Gender perspective plays a significant role not only in shaping and executing warfare, but also in giving the specific impact of war. Whitworth (2008) argued that ‘gender-neutral’ analyses of armed conflict regularly do not focus on people at all—conflict is conducted between states or armed groups, the specific impact on people’s lives is a marginal concern and instead the focus of analysis is on territory and resource gained (or lost) and the outcome (in terms of winners and losers) of battles and war. Through gender lenses, this paper tries to make correlation between war and people and endeavours to analyse the role of gender perspectives during wartime. The first part of paper describes how masculinity shapes state behaviour regarding the use of violence and war, as well as masculinity’s role in militarisation. Second, it describes the evolution of women’s involvement in conflicts, such as women as victims of war, as combatants, and peace-makers. Third, this paper discusses the use of gender categorisation in international humanitarian law which attempts to give more protection to women during times of conflict. Masculinity, Militarism and War In many cultures in the world, people determine social roles based on gender disparities. In social constructions, gender is used to differentiate roles, responsibilities, rights, abilities and limitations between men and women. Patriarchal systems can be seen as sets of social rules or norms based on maleness, where man is placed at the head of the family and is a property owner, protector, and decision maker. As Lauren Wilcox (2007, cited in Sjoberg. 2010, p.3) explains, ‘Gender symbolism describes the way in which masculine/feminine are assigned to various dichotomies that organize Western thought’ where ‘both men and women tend to place a higher value on the term which is associated with masculinity’. This vertical power relation creates a social hierarchy based on masculine and feminine characteristics, and many feminists refer to this as Hegemonic Masculinity. Women are portrayed as caring, nurturing, emotional, interdependent, and vulnerable; therefore, they are assigned to roles in domestic labour, nurturing children, and are considered objects of protection. On the other hand, men are seen as and expected to be rational, independent, tough, physically strong, and aggressive figures. The assumed roles of men are those of leaders, decision makers, and protectors of families and society.